Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
Luna's First Proclamation by Wolf-Fairy Luna's First Proclamation by Wolf-Fairy
Edit: What a surprise the comments have been these last few days. Some of you were able to talk to me with respect about how you stand with the subject. I'm really impressed. This has honestly been a learning experience for me and I'm definitely taking some of you guys' advice. Thank you all for the comments. I really appreciate them. ^w^


Philomena agrees.

Btw drawing lashes on a pony is apparently hard.

Please people, this is my opinion on the story is all. I don't agree to censor literature as a whole, just with this fandom. MLP is an innocent show with love and morals for the whole family. It doesn't need this. I'd not want something censored that doesn't deserve it, but this show didn't need this gortesqueness in the first place so it needs to be censored. Really if you had kids and showed them the show, and they eventually see a pic of Pinkie Pie with a knife and all bloody or something(cause all the kids know is that its an innocent cutesy show), what would you tell them? It's a story with unnecessary violence from a show that was innocent to start. It's like maiming a slice of my childhood and my innocence and love with cartoons in general. It's my opinion. And Pinkie Pie is my favorite character for god's sake, her cutie mark doesn't symbolize murder and cannibalism. Everyone has their own and this is mine. Respect it like I respect all of yours.
Add a Comment:
 
:iconderroflcopter:
Derroflcopter Featured By Owner May 14, 2014
I like Cupcakes, but whatever, faving because Luna.
Reply
:iconmylittletabbycat:
mylittletabbycat Featured By Owner Jan 11, 2013
I don't believe in mature mlp literature either, GO WOONA!
Reply
:iconsweetannabee:
sweetannabee Featured By Owner Mar 19, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Reply
:iconmylittletabbycat:
mylittletabbycat Featured By Owner Mar 20, 2013
YYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHH!
[link]
Reply
:icon7980:
7980 Featured By Owner Jul 17, 2012
i thank that bird loves luna thy i would say
Reply
:icontickletron2000:
TickleTron2000 Featured By Owner Mar 21, 2012
MLP doesn't need "Cupcakes"? It doesn't need ANY of this! Not "Massacre" or "Harvest." Not "Experiments" or "Rainbow Factory." And certainly not "That's Once!"
Reply
:iconponylover555:
ponylover555 Featured By Owner Feb 3, 2012
wow, it's really true, if you hear to many times about something you get boner from it
Reply
:iconlasalle1alpha:
lasalle1alpha Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2012
yes...
YES!!! ALL HAIL LUNA IN YOUR TRADITIONAL CANTERLOT VOICE!!!
---
Cupcakes was just freakin disturbing. I only read about a couple of paragraphs and I couldn't stomach the rest...
I've read more grotesque Naruto and Harry Potter fanfics, but these books and manga already have elements of violence in it to begin with.
MLP FIM? Pinkie Pie? No... just NO to 'Cupcakes'
Reply
:iconmotoneko:
MotoNeko Featured By Owner Nov 27, 2011
those are wise words :D
Reply
:iconcreatorx33:
creatorX33 Featured By Owner Oct 7, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
LONG LIVE PRINCESS LUNA!!!
Reply
:iconawesomepony777:
awesomepony777 Featured By Owner Sep 29, 2011
YES!!!
Reply
:iconunwrittentale:
UnwrittenTale Featured By Owner Sep 29, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I support your statement with full agreement. :heart:

This is innocence. This is where we come to escape the madness and deluge into the happiness. And you spoil it anyway. Why?
Reply
:icontriple-a-battery:
Triple-A-Battery Featured By Owner Sep 17, 2011  Hobbyist Writer
I agree wholeheartedly. But isn't Equestria a Diarchy? As in, a place with two rulers of equal power? So Luna would already be in power, Celestia is just better-known. While I do agree with artistic license and the freedom to write what you want, if you know the internet probably won't like it, don't upload it. Or at least make a site for grimdark stories so we don't get roped into it by simply going on Equestria Daily.

Anyways, I agree. Cupcakes was a very disturbing fic.
Reply
:iconinvisiblemang:
InvisibleMang Featured By Owner Sep 15, 2011
....i love you alot more now luna
Reply
:iconkaijuguy19:
KaijuGuy19 Featured By Owner Sep 9, 2011
We support your proclamation all the way Luna!!!:#1:
Reply
:iconcrucifythewolf:
CrucifyTheWolf Featured By Owner Aug 25, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
Well I'm kinda into the whole Cupcakes thing,but It's a bit too bizzare for my taste,something I wouldn't read everyday but You have a point.It's an innocent show and it shouldn't be butchered like that,but these ARE fandoms..

Glad to see another Fellow Luna fan =).
Reply
:iconvampirenerd13:
VampireNerd13 Featured By Owner Aug 19, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Yes. I think I like Luna even more now -- if that's possible.
Reply
:iconsbg6:
SBG6 Featured By Owner Aug 17, 2011  Student General Artist
Very good job on this!

The coloring is well done as well as the expressions. Although I can also see Princess Celestia also having those same ideas if she were to look up the fanfic.

I agree on the Cupcakes fanfic. Although I could see this fanart as a satire, but since this is actually based on your opinion I respect that as well. That fanfic to me is out of character and very offensive. It went way too far. I understand this is the internet and all that freedom, but still. I know there is creepypasta, but this is beyond it. It could be qualified as a trollfanfic or an anti-MLP fanfic since it's bashing the characters in a horrifying and disturbing way. There is also an equally worse one starring Rarity and I heard about it on YT that someone read called "Rarity's Dress" or something like that. *shudders* I guess it was meant to test out how much of a shocker it is and how many can they piss off MLP fans. Then there are alternative endings to the infamous story by other fans to try to make it look good which is alright I guess if it means that the characters were alive the whole time. Still.. But enough about that.

Anyway, good job on this!
Reply
:icont-800ofcyberdyne:
T-800ofCyberdyne Featured By Owner Aug 14, 2011
Yes, my mistress! :bow: I will ban it from all that holds literature within hours!

I wish I seriously could, because I agree with you. Cupcakes is the peak of stupidity and hatred for the show and the human race on creating fanfictions.
Reply
:iconsanguijuela:
Sanguijuela Featured By Owner Aug 14, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
Well, there's also pony porn AKA pornies. :O
(and I haven't read "Cupcakes", but I know what the story's about and it kind of made me even more scared of girly girls...'cause I'm a tomboy like Rainbow Dash)
Reply
:iconvarietychick:
VarietyChick Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
I've never actually read the story, but apparently it's pretty bad. So...go Luna! :giggle: :clap:
Reply
:iconskyhammerstrike:
SkyhammerStrike Featured By Owner Aug 19, 2011
"I've never actually read the story"

Try to keep it that way. It is... disturbing, even to the likes of me.
Reply
:iconthepossumface:
ThePossumface Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Let me start by saying great picture. No problems there. And as you are entitled to share your opinion, so will I.

People have to let the story ruin the show for them. Yes, it's nasty and gory but it's just a stupid story. I have nothing against it because it's just a part of fandom. I know it's not canon and that Pinkie Pie would never do those things, but it's funny to make jokes about, and I have no problem with someone making a theory about Pinkie's mental stability, even if it is portrayed rather graphically.

As to your kids finding any pictures related to it: don't let your kids online alone, especially to places they could easily find such images. Like dA, many sites have a mature content filter that they would have to sign up as 18+ to get by. You shouldn't let your kids wander the web alone if they're young enough to be bothered by that.

The writer, however twisted he may be, has opened up thousands of creative doors to lots of writers and artists, and has spawned many conversations and discussions such as the ones in the comments here. I know it may bother some people, but if it does, ignore it! Plain and simple. Even if you don't agree with the story or like it's content, it is another person's creation and you should just respect that it isn't going anywhere.

People need to pony up--- those stories don't ruin anything for you unless you let them. As a previous person mentioned, you can't be against censorship unless it's helpful to you. I understand what you're saying completely, so you needn't tell me your point of view again. I understand what you're saying, the show is innocent, but with a fanbase of 17-35 year olds, the art/stories made are not all going to be innocent. If we were to ban everything not innocent that fans had made about innocent shows, we would half the art we have today.

No matter what, this will keep happening. Agree or not, it's freedom of speech and I see nothing wrong with it (although maybe the person who wrote it has some problems, but again, not my place to judge).

My advice? Just pretend like it didn't happen. You'd find stories like Cupcakes in any fandom. If it bothers you that much, then I don't know what to tell you. It's like me saying Rainbow Dash is a serial rapist who beats Scootaloo: everyone knows it's not canon, but neither is anything not directly mentioned in the show, such as Octavia being Pinkie Pie's sister, or Derpy Hooves being Dinky Doo's mother. It's all fan speculation, no matter how far fetched or wrong it is. We can't stifle that. So just ignore it.

Again, great art. :D
Reply
:iconwolf-fairy:
Wolf-Fairy Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
:icontwilightclapplz: Well I thank you for taking the time to make such a long comment. Your points are valid and I appreciate them, its just the fandom kinda blurred those kind of opinions from me because of the way people handled parts of the fandom.

I think people are misunderstanding what I mean about the kid thing. I meant was that, what if your child sees something different from what the norm of the show is, something like Cupcakes. No matter how its seen wasn't the issue. Everybody has accidentally stumbled onto one thing or another online. But yes parents should monitor their children's internet activity. The internet is a wide open place for lots of things so.

Thanks again for speaking your opinions to me. I really appreciate how you as well as most people who have commented this pic here have been so mature about talking about this. ^w^
Reply
:iconmagicaitrevor:
MagicaITrevor Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Writer
WOOOOO YEAH! GO PRINCESS LUNA! ALL HAIL THE NEW LUNAR REPUBLIC!
Reply
:icondracosderpyhoof:
DracosDerpyHoof Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student Artist
I think it should be censored; or just hidden away this way kids can't see it. The same thing could be said for Harry Potter fanfics I've seen.

But, parents also need to take responsibility; I'm agreeing with you, but I just think people need to be responsible as well. If your daughter wants to look at DeviantArt put on the mature filter. :/ You know? Common curtsy man..... everyone needs it.
Reply
:iconwolf-fairy:
Wolf-Fairy Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Yep. That's right. ^w^ Common courtesy is just one of things that would make the world that much better. If only everyone in the world just looked out for others' well beings.
Reply
:icondracosderpyhoof:
DracosDerpyHoof Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student Artist
Yea, and it doesn't help DA has gotten laid back on the maturity rules.
Reply
:iconwolf-fairy:
Wolf-Fairy Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Not at all. :| I don't think DA cares about anything anymore.
Reply
:icondracosderpyhoof:
DracosDerpyHoof Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student Artist
Yea, definitely living up to "Deviant" Blegh.
Reply
:icondracosderpyhoof:
DracosDerpyHoof Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student Artist
And this was funny. I was watching a South Park episode about this very subject.
Reply
:iconwater-avian:
Water-Avian Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student General Artist
I wish I knew what this is about...Some terrible crack fanfiction I suppose?
Reply
:iconwolf-fairy:
Wolf-Fairy Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I'll tell you about it on msn. x3
Reply
:iconwater-avian:
Water-Avian Featured By Owner Aug 12, 2011  Student General Artist
Okays :3
Reply
:iconalexlayer:
Alexlayer Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Yes, yes and YES! :D
Reply
:iconk4nk4n:
K4nK4n Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011
I support your decree 200%, my Princess!! Ban "Cupcakes"!! And banish the person who wrote the fanfiction in the 1st place! I'LL SUPPORT PRINCESS LUNA TILL MY VERY END!
Yay, Princess Luna sees things the same way I do. I HATED that "Cupcakes" fanfiction. I think that fanfiction was probably written by an Anti-Pony under the guise of a Brony so nopony will suspect.
Reply
:iconks-claw:
ks-claw Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Professional General Artist
As one who has read Cupcakes, I couldn't agree more. It's one of those stories that you wish hadn't even been considered to be written =I But every fandom has its dark side.
Reply
:icontippytoe-zombie:
TippyToe-Zombie Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011
I mostly just thought Cupcakes was stupid. I mean yeah the concept was scary, but the fic was so badly written that I didn't really find it that scary.
Reply
:icontippytoe-zombie:
TippyToe-Zombie Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011
I propose a toast to our genius ruler Princess Luna and her wonderful idea.
Reply
:iconaleximusprime:
AleximusPrime Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
I love you for making this!!! :iconfinallyplz:
Reply
:icongodzillaprime01:
GodzillaPrime01 Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
You go Luna!
Reply
:icondarkhorseartie89:
DarkHorseArtie89 Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student General Artist
I haven't read Cupcakes, but to be honest, I don't think I'd really care to, since all it's really doing is putting things into little stereotypes. Stereotypes into which people think that almost everyone who likes MLP is a sick, twisted freak who can't have the show as is without excessive violence and innuendos.

Then of course, there's people who complain about people who like Luna because "She's only had a few scenes and she's the bad guy..." Actually, that's very normal for many fandoms... Just look at all the stuff about any Disney villain... They get way more appreciation than the heroes do. Also, more people like Shadow than Sonic, and while I'm at it, GENO...
Reply
:iconwolf-fairy:
Wolf-Fairy Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Yep. :| It's something that makes me worry about people new wanting to see the show but know of the fandom's...ways. It makes innocent fans look just as guilty for something they aren't apart of.

Really? And yeah its normal for other fandoms, but this seems like the most controversial fandom in a long while. Unless I've been under a rock and am wrong. :P I just haven't been apart of something so much that I want to break away from it so soon. I thought at first the fandom was going to be something wonderful, but it didn't turn out that way so much. :< I can believe the disney thing. XP And the Shadow thing. You're right.
Reply
:icondarkhorseartie89:
DarkHorseArtie89 Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student General Artist
Well, I haven't actually watched any of the show yet, simply because I don't have the time (also, I just don't know where to find YT clips that aren't YTP), but it looks like I don't have to because of the fans. However, regardless of what the fandom has done to "taint" my view on it, I don't feel bad about liking the show.

I think the big reason why people get so ruffled about Luna/Nightmare Moon is because of how she got introduced; she comes back after being banished for a 1000 years and wants to trap all of Equestria into a permanent night time, and since this is a kids show where rainbows and sunshine are unrealistically the good and night is unrealistically evil, it goes downhill from there (but it's okay to take, say, the goofy Pinkie Pie and turn her into a mass-murderer or make Celestia a pedo [when at worst she'd be a control freak]). To me, she had her justifications for her revenge and plans (as well a somewhat "just" penalty), but the fandom won't accept it.

And yeah, just look up some other villains on DA and you'll see what I'm talking about. And Geno of Super Mario RPG is rather ridiculous when you see fandom debates about him.
Reply
:iconwolf-fairy:
Wolf-Fairy Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Well I don't feel bad liking the show either. I just wish that when brought up in a convo with new people they don't think of things like Cupcakes instead of thinking of the innocent show it is.

I agree with that. She did have every right for revenge. And the show was clever to have her play such a good villain. But yeah quite hypocritical if they accept those things you listed as well as something like Scootabuse and Trollestia which I don't like those things either.

Oh. I heard some thing about Geno, but not anything big. I'll have to research.
Reply
:icondarkhorseartie89:
DarkHorseArtie89 Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Student General Artist
Yeah, I understand. :nod:

Yes, research on Geno and you can pretty much see why I have no issues with Luna.
Reply
:icondahila-mockery:
Dahila-Mockery Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Writer
That's a good rule.
Reply
:iconace12541:
Ace12541 Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011
You have my vote ^-^
Reply
:iconsyrinkitty:
SyrinKitty Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist Writer
Cupcakes is the Goatse of MLP fanfiction. It is only intended to shock and disgust, and nothing more. It wont ruin anything if you don't let it. Stop talking about it and it'll go away. (If you don't know what Goatse is, don't look it up, and if you do, don't say I didn't warn you.)
Reply
:iconk4nk4n:
K4nK4n Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011
Problem is "Cupcakes" just WON'T GO AWAY! Everyday I pen up deviantART to see bloody and gruesome "Cupcakes" art in the "My Little Pony : Friendship Is Magic" group. The only way for it to go away is if the groups were more responsible at blocking works containing those elements.
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×




Details

Submitted on
August 10, 2011
Image Size
198 KB
Resolution
927×768
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
4,954
Favourites
153 (who?)
Comments
99