5555x6110px 8.43 MB
Hello dear Deviant mate,
I was browsing through some critiqueable deviations and i just came up on yours. Here's my POV that i'm going to split in 3 parts :
About originilality : Yup, i just gave you 2 stars for originality because your art is a simple copy/remade of an existing logo. I have seen the Finder logo somewhere on the Internet with exactly the same look. But whatever, originality is the not the goal that you try to reach through this remade (i guess)
Technique : Your technique is good, i don't have seen any mistake in your remade. I'm givin' you 5 stars in Technique because even if Finder's logo remade is not the best way for you to display your skills, your skill was good enough to reach your goal and do a perfect Finder logo. Maybe you should step up, try to do other remades or works that can really bring you into difficulties.
Impact : Frankly, i would say that the 2 stars for Impact have almost same reasons than for originality... It's Finder's logo, there is nothing really tremendous, but once again, i don't think that impact (or originality) was the point !
'hope that i helped you with my little critique, by the way, i'm sorry if i made some mistakes in english, that's not my native tongue.