Deviation Actions

windfalcon's avatar

Mary Sue - How to Tell

By windfalcon
EDIT 3: 11/22/09 You guys are kidding me XD For goodness sakes, reaaaaad the liink here: [link] Every time I get a comment that reads "the one on the left is a Mary Sue because she has green hair and a power," I realize that they're not reading the description which contains this link: [link]

tl;dr: If 'special' traits fit in with the universe, it doesn't automatically make the character a Mary Sue. What if everyone else in Ami Machida's universe has green/blue/purple hair? What if everyone else has a cat power? Does that make her a Mary Sue? Not necessarily.

Please, spare me the time from having to point you BACK to the silly description and just take a minute to read the link. You know, the one I linked to a bunch of times up above. And the link here: [link]

EDIT 2: 10/11/09 I suppose this is long overdue, but for those of you with confusion, here is an explanation on why I perceive the one on the left as not a Mary Sue: [link] For the love of god stop whining about it D:

EDIT: 6/21/09 Okay, everyone, please chill with all the 'hay is my character a mary-sue!?11" questions. I get about 3 a day now and one thing you need to understand - I AM NOT AN AUTHORITY ON MARY SUES. This picture is a parody. Just for fun. The one on the right is obviously an extreme exaggeration of a stereotype and not the definitive definition for a Mary Sue. D:

Please full view. You won't be able to read the text if you don't.

For those of you who don't know, a Mary Sue, in a nutshell, is a fanmade character that is usually extremely beautiful, powerful, smart, talented, and in plain words, perfect in every way.

These characters tend to be quite a bother in fanfiction and role playing, since they simply can't be beat, and thus become boring.

Have any of you ever been rping, and come across a character who is like, " oh, well, that planet in the way isn't a problem *blows it up*"

Or, is like, "well, Vegeta and Goten and Trunks and Goku ALL have a crush on my character"

Yep. That's a Mary Sue.

So, for people who still don't understand, I made this little picture/diagram. Usually, Mary Sues have TONS of talents and TONS of powers, and no weaknesses.

Enjoy ^_^

-Done in Copic Markers, with the background and text done on computer -
Image details
Image size
1293x961px 902.09 KB
© 2004 - 2021 windfalcon
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
CuteYoshiLover's avatar

Ami is precious. but Jasmyne is a lil overpowered.

At least Amichan will learn from her mistakes and has weaknesses

AnimeJewel246's avatar

How do people think Winry Rockbell from Fullmetal Alchemist is a Mary-Sue then?

*Shakes head* Honestly...

TayToon's avatar

Honestly I don't care if your character is a "Mary Sue" as long they're entertaining, I like them. A Mary Sue is a Mary Sue if their creator kept on shoehorning down people's throats trying so hard to say that their character is not "said label."

28118's avatar

Even though I know I'm supposed to despise the Mary Sue on the right, I have to admit that creating phoenixes from your hands does sound like a cool power to have.

Eric-Michael-Kline's avatar
Here's how I define a Sue/Stu character.  I believe a character can have flawless beauty, be a total badass, have genius intellect, be loved by everyone, and be a paragon of virtue and still not be a sue or stu.  (IE-Boa Hancock from One Piece has most of the traits you'd expect from a Sue but definitely is not one).  For me, the defining trait is whether they serve the story or the story serves them.  What I mean is the entire story is centered around how awesome they are rather than their awesomeness serving to advance the story.
Skirret-Resetar's avatar
If someone needs a laconic definition for Mary-sue, then here it is: “someone who does not follow the rules of their reality”.
 I think what’s missing for most people is context: neither of these two would be out of context in the right setting (appearance wise at least, the details would just need tweaking). Take the one on the right; she’d likely fit in a very surreal setting, even the parentage thing might work in a very surreal fanwork (and by surreal, I mean like the Beatles and the Yellow Submarine kind of surreal, not the very troll-y kind): I can imagine her being in an anime/Marvel inspired work (if you don’t know how it can have Marvel inspirations, you either need to look at something like Dr. Strange, or just quit now).
With the one the left, she actually would just need tweaking to fit into “My Hero Academia”; she has a power, she has the appearance, and she has a very average background, it would be easy.
MissLadyC's avatar
Man this is old....
ShadowCrystalFox7's avatar
I also hate math. Got an E😑
RetroForLife's avatar
Me: See Prince Vegeta 

saiput's avatar
Loud and clear, this comparison sum up everything.
phoenixawesomewolf03's avatar
CleanClear777's avatar
Man, I'm so fucking glad & happy that my AJ's-(average joes*) & PJ's-(plain janes*) pure human, pure non-human, & half human―half non-human characters with(out) superpowers aren't like these Mary-Sue & Marty-Stu characters. However I have some Mary-Sue & Marty-Stu characters with(out) superpowers as well, so my AJ's/PJ's have some characters to torture to death. 
KarmaKiruu10155's avatar
This is why I name my fuckin’ hellhound boy “Chris”
KarmaKiruu10155's avatar
PETFAN776's avatar
i act same as your left oc lmao
Kenneth-Setser's avatar
Sparkybonbom27's avatar
Is mine a mary sue
my oc is sparky (she likes lolita and harajuku style unlike people who like trendy clothes)
she is very old billions
hair color is cream yellow 
species is something i made up
puffaballoo they can live forever but they aint invincible their hair can change shape and is another dimension
she dosent like sports and is in a video game club 
only a mother she is a puffabaloo too
gpa: C+ Although she is very smart
power: I just said
companion: rabbit who likes harajuku style
Weakness: scared of bugs,dark,blood,bad at getting a relationship on purpose because she no want 1
Sparkybonbom27's avatar
Also she has rabbit traits 
not all people like her and she aint the smartest although she is very smart with a iq of $ 
she aint perfect
Sparkybonbom27's avatar
Hobbys include drawing video games playing with toys and social media and games
obsesses over pop'n music (especially kirara) otoca d'or pokemon kirby nintendo in general and the duck life series
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In