Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
Group Info Group Founded 3 Years ago Statistics 649 Members
17,408 Pageviews569 Watchers


Hello, and welcome to our group.

Until further notice, group submissions have been lowered down to one submission per deviant per day.


Please read these carefully
(I know when you haven't)

1. Please understand that flat out insulting another's art is not the same as critiquing. Same goes for flat out only complimenting the piece. When you critique, you need to say what is good about the piece, but also what they need to improve on. This includes giving them tips and examples on what they can do to improve their work and their style. Also, please be serious about the critique.

2. Bullying will not be tolerated within this group. If you are caught once, you will be given a warning. The second time you are caught, you will be kicked out of the group.

3. *Please put art in the 'Needing Critique' or 'Critique a Sketch' folders so we can get to it. Once it has been critiqued, we administrators will move the art to their proper folders. All sketches go in Critique a sketch.*

4. Please make sure that your artwork has the mature content filter if needed.
--4a. Types of art that need mature filter: contains nudity/anything sexual, contains gore, contains violence, has swearing, or is considered ideologically sensitive.
--4b. If your art has this and does not have the mature content, it will be reported and removed from the group. You will also receive one official group warning. If you are caught doing it again, then you will be kicked from the group.</i>
4c. Please do not submit fetish art. We are not your fetish dumping grounds.

5. Do not steal someone else's art and submit it to the group. The piece will be removed and you will be kicked and banned from the group. The ban may be lifted once you prove you can stop stealing artwork.

6. Please, take all critiques in a mature fashion. Do not whine or complain when someone is trying to help you improve.

7. Please, no troll accounts. We do not have the patience for those. Any and all trolls submitting non-serious pieces of work will be terminated from the group

8. In that matter, no joke art either. Submitting joke art only makes it harder for us to critique the real pieces that have been submitted for seriousness and awareness of improvement. Any and all joke art found will be immediately taken down from the group

Well, enjoy your time here.







Group Info

So, this is a group where we will critique art to help others improve.
Critiquing is usually confused with bashing and hating, but that should not be the case. A good critique tells the artist what is good about the piece but also what areas they need to improve in.
So please, come and join us.
Founded 3 Years ago
Jul 31, 2016


Group Focus
Art Critiquing

649 Members
569 Watchers
17,408 Pageviews
Daily Pageviews


Members of True-Honest-Critique,

It's not easy to give and get feedback. If it was easy, we'd all be giving and getting a lot of feedback. It wouldn't matter if the feedback was comments, critiques, :+fav:, :+devwatch:, exposure - you would get lots of it on every piece of artwork you uploaded.

The sad reality is that doesn't happen on DeviantArt. If it does for you, awesome - this message isn't for you. For the majority on this community, though, our art barely gets seen, let alone faved or critiqued.

That's part of the reason why ProjectComment was created. Like many comment/critique/feedback groups, ProjectComment was made to give you the comments you deserve.

Every single one of you deserves one comment. That has been our unwavering belief since 2009. But, it's not enough to exist on belief. What do I mean by that? Well, nobody can get comments if nobody gives them.

Instead of dividing a community filled with aspiring artists between groups that are no longer active, join us today at ProjectComment. Join us today in uniting our community, supporting one another, and fighting against the lack of feedback that can be seen everywhere on DeviantArt.

Take note: I'm not offering a magic button, or a genie in the bottle, that will grant you every kind of feedback you desire, whenever and as often as you wish. That's fantasy - it doesn't exist in reality.

What I am offering is a platform, that has existed for more than 9 years, so that we can come together and support one another. If you're not interested in helping your fellow artist who is in the same exact position as you, don't bother.

I'm not saying it's going to be easy. It's going to take a lot of time, effort and more, but together... we make a difference.

Join Us At :iconprojectcomment: Today

More Journal Entries


Amazing people who came for a visit

You're not here because you're not logged in
  • :iconfrancourecompositor4:
    Visited here 1 day ago
    Isn't a member
  • :iconsokoistrying:
    Visited here 2 days ago
    Isn't a member
  • :iconrukuha-san:
    Rukuha-san - Members
    Visited here 2 days ago
    Did something awesome on June 13th, 2017
  • :iconmyovada:
    myovada - Members
    Visited here 2 days ago
    Did something awesome 2 days ago
  • :iconjjaethedemon:
    jjaethedemon - Members
    Visited here 2 days ago
    Did something awesome 2 days ago
  • :icon420linxcat:
    420linxcat - Members
    Visited here 3 days ago
    Did something awesome 3 days ago
  • :iconbastionunity:
    BastionUnity - Members
    Visited here 5 days ago
    Did something awesome 3 days ago
  • :iconninja-doggo:
    Ninja-Doggo - Members
    Visited here 6 days ago
    Did something awesome 6 days ago
  • :iconsnooblydoodle:
    snooblydoodle - Members
    Visited here 6 days ago
    Did something awesome 6 days ago
  • :iconositodraws:
    Ositodraws - Members
    Visited here 6 days ago
    Did something awesome on April 11th, 2019




Add a Comment:
420linxcat Featured By Owner 4 days ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
How do you draw curley hair i really struggle with this
Aeccelia Featured By Owner Jan 11, 2019  Student Digital Artist
Do we just comment on the pieces in the needing crit folder? and then the admins/mods check back on them and see if they've gotten any??
A-Mire-Situation Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2019  Hobbyist General Artist
Gonna try my hardest to give some well-thought feedback Charlie Dance 
lillyay4 Featured By Owner Sep 11, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
So hang on, After re-reading the rules, I need to check something- Can you submit art to the group when it's still on the original user's account, With their permission of course?
Sorry, I just want to be sure.
RosalieCiraptor Featured By Owner Sep 6, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
I somehow accidentally submitted like ten pieces???? Sorry-
MissDollicia Featured By Owner Mar 29, 2018  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
So I'm brand ssspanking new to DA, how do I submit a photo here?
Lady-Saki Featured By Owner May 25, 2018  Student Traditional Artist
So, most of the folders are  blocked off from submission.  You can go to needing critique, or critique a sketch and there should be a button in those folders that allows you to submit art
JimmyJonJones Featured By Owner Mar 7, 2018  Student General Artist
Thank you for accepting my request.
nazu-nyan Featured By Owner Jan 23, 2018  Hobbyist Artist
Thanks for accepting my request! I'm new to DA and I'd really appreciate some advice on how to improve. I'm not very experienced so I don't think I'm ready to give out critiques yet.
Add a Comment: