Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
:icontimeboy08:TimeBoy08 posted a status
To all MCF writers...

im sorry but the universe is a bit of a mess? What's the continuation of a series and what's a different retelling?

Characters  from old eras; how r they in modern time?

Devious Comments

:iconboyinthebluebox:
BoyintheBlueBox Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I've never read any stories. But visiting the journals and the premise of the series, the MCF universe seems to be all over the place. And the explanations on how the characters based on historical figures are in modern times is nonexistent, making it rather convoluted. And the character witness stories inspired by films like Frozen and the Marvel Cinematic Universe just seems redundant. Heck it happens in other people's hero team stories!! Why have the characters go through something that we've seen already in the main media? We'll just know what happens next. sure one can put twists. But in the end, the story involving other characters participating in the events of other media while using the original script will end up making the story predictable.  
Reply
:iconamulet-star:
Amulet-Star Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
To be honest...I feel kinda nervous about my stories. I want to have them make sense, not make the world messy or whatever
Reply
:iconamulet-star:
Amulet-Star Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
I admit...You have a point.

It also doesn't help with my OC Amanda when it comes to her family. The best thing for that is to have her live at the castle, and only do rare cameos of her family.
Reply
:iconangelthewingedcat:
angelthewingedcat Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
As for the retelling thing, I don't have any plan for MCF through some could say my 'Wing and Ever After High' could be a bit like one since some events from the web-show are shown...with that said, the shown parts are big events that effect the main plot for Wing as well like with the whole destiny thing since, at the time, she had no clues on her birth parents whatsoever, first became the Green Hood, and the headmaster wanted her to follow in Jack's footsteps. With some other 'retellings' however, I do agree it's not that great when the new characters only really react to things.
Reply
:icontimeboy08:
TimeBoy08 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Yeah...
Reply
:iconangelthewingedcat:
angelthewingedcat Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Sorry if I don't make any sense.^^;
Reply
:icontimeboy08:
TimeBoy08 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
No it's fine 
Reply
:iconangelthewingedcat:
angelthewingedcat Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Honestly, it's something I want to figure out too, partly for when I start writing my own MCF stories.^^; I mean, yes we could say some characters are AU from the original source but then we would need to change some things for them to set better into the modern times and the setting.

Through, with the parents, I did suggest that when they got their magic it causes them to age slower, something unknown to them when they first got their powers, so it could explain how Anya and Dimitri are still alive and had children in the year they did. With some others however, I have no idea how we could fully explain it yet.
Reply
:icontimeboy08:
TimeBoy08 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Agreed. Plus considering all that Homura did in Rebellion there's that to get into the mcf verse and how Madoka and Homura are still in speaking terms AND Sayaka not killing Homura for allege did.

and agreed...sadly I don't think we're gonna get answers.
Reply
:iconangelthewingedcat:
angelthewingedcat Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Right. Through, we did mention some plans with why that is like with Homura's devil form that would be revealed in the Gem arc completely in notes. Course, I do plan on some foreshadowing before that, even if it's in very small ways, just so it doesn't feel like it came completely out of left field. Plus I already mentioned with Saber, it would be based off of an ending that was made into an OVA as to why she is still there.

Well I thought Monica mentioned she liked the magic idea for the parents. But like with Anna, who had no magic, I'm not sure how it would work like it would have for Elsa. Unless we do something like 'pocket dims' were time move slower for certain areas that the girls could go to. But that's about the only thing I can think of that would work and may not do well for the type of world MCF seems to be.
Reply
:iconmagicalalchemist17:
MagicalAlchemist17 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
I admit I kinda forgot about your idea with Anya and Dimitri. ^^;
Reply
:iconangelthewingedcat:
angelthewingedcat Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Well, with everything going on and how it long had been, I can see why.:nod:
Reply
:iconmagicalalchemist17:
MagicalAlchemist17 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Yeah :nod:
Reply
:icontimeboy08:
TimeBoy08 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Yeah, I mean we did say wing is vital to Homura being good and yeah on Saber.

time travel in mcf just seems too confusions
Reply
:iconangelthewingedcat:
angelthewingedcat Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
That and the reason why Devil Homura doesn't appear until a later arc to in season six.

Yeah, that's why I said it may not work.^^; While time travel is shown to exist, it's confusing on how it works.
Reply
:icontimeboy08:
TimeBoy08 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Right.

heah..OUAT just seemed to hand wave it aside:
Reply
:iconangelthewingedcat:
angelthewingedcat Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
:nod:

Yeah.

I mean with some other characters like Anna and Elsa, the AU version I mentioned in the first comment could have worked...if it wasn't for the fact we were already told it was the same ones from the Disney movie. Partly due to something that is mentioned early on in the XXXHolic manga that was mentioned with how some characters like in certain worlds for it and Tsubasa.
Reply
:iconmagicalalchemist17:
MagicalAlchemist17 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
I admit...I've been struggling to figure out just how Anya and Dimitri are in Modern Times but with the whole MCF in a bit of a mess right now. It's been a bit hard to figure out how to explain Anya and Dimitri in MCF...
Reply
:iconpixargirl:
Pixargirl Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
i know right?
Reply
:icontimeboy08:
TimeBoy08 Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2016
Oh my god, thank you so much! Finally, someone who understands me .
Reply
Add a Comment: