Deviation Actions

Theamat's avatar

X-Men Guernica

By
Another week of The Line it is Drawn! This week's theme was "Alternate Reality Character Designs", and my pick was X-Men, designed by Picasso.

See the other contributions here: goodcomics.comicbookresources.…

This piece is based on the painting Guernica: upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia…

X-Men Guernica - SKETCH by Theamat

X-Men Guernica - INKS by Theamat

Find this work and others on Redbubble! Shirts, phone cases and more:

www.redbubble.com/people/theam…
Image details
Image size
6800x4400px 17.75 MB
Published:
© 2012 - 2021 Theamat
Comments50
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
beccablast's avatar
:star::star::star::star::star-half: Overall
:star::star::star::star::star: Vision
:star::star::star::star::star-empty: Originality
:star::star::star::star::star: Technique
:star::star::star::star::star-half: Impact

The Spanish Civil War, if thought of at all today, is usually discussed and dismissed as "the dress rehearsal for World War II", in that it involved active participation from Hitler's Germany, Fascist Italy, and the Soviet Union. The glibness of that phrase glosses over what that really means -- despite the brutality of the First World War, the Second was exponentially worse -- most certainly in terms of the destruction visited on civilians. That was something all sides engaged in in Spain, most famously in the annihilation of a Basque town called Guernica by the German Luftwaffe. Pablo Picasso, an expatriate Spaniard living in Paris, took the atrocity as a subject for a mural -- a painting that he vowed would never be seen in Spain until democracy was restored. "Guernica" is the best-known and perhaps greatest artwork of the 20th century, and virtually synonymous with Picasso.

When a comics artist is given the challenge of "show the X-Men as designed by Picasso", the bait is tempting -- the X-Men are by far the series most concerned with bigotry and intolerance -- one of their members is the descendant of Holocaust victims, and their greatest rival/ally is a direct survivor. Not to mention that when Stan Lee and Jack Kirby invented the series, it was a direct metaphor to the racial issues of the 1960's. The Xavier Institute for Gifted Students has been devastated and rebuilt over and over. This is not the Justice League in their oh-so-safe satellite -- these are heroes under siege in a world that hates them. Their home HAS been bombed. If any comic characters can say to have experienced what happened in the original work, it's them.

The way of determining whether the piece is worthy of the concept is a different matter. We can admit the concept and not like the piece; we can admire the craft and dislike the subject. The craft here is exquisite -- even in the chaos of the piece, the X-Men are clearly identifiable. The use of angle light and shadow to create the cubist effects of the original piece -- Cyclops' eye beams, the small lightning bolts from Storm, making sure the white streak in Rogue's hair is visible -- are dead-on in the style prescribed. The arrangement of characters matches well with the original work (with a few exceptions I'll get to in a minute. We have in the original a wailing woman with a dead child under the eyes of a panicked animal -- here we have an anguished Rogue cradling Nightcrawler's body under the gaze of a panicked Beast. Two women appear like shrieking wraiths with candles and pleas -- here we have a fearful Storm and Emma Frost, of all people, in full desperation -- perhaps Emma because Cyclops is in danger; I would have thought Kitty to be more suited for her position. Where the original had a man on his knees hands up to the sky, the mandatory Wolverine has claws out but looks particularly helpless.

There are some differences, though, and that causes some troubles. Possibly the most famous of all the images in the mural is the panicked horse who has thrown his rider and readies to trample his prone master. That gets transformed here to a rampaging Magneto about to stomp the prone Cyclops. Storm seems to be casting lightning at Magnus as much as anything else; is he the one who attacked, ripping the iron gate in the foreground (no such barrier in the painting) apart? Or is he merely another victim? His inclusion in the position he is in adds an ambiguity that reinforces another problem, but this issue is with the very concept.

Part of the inhumanity of the Guernica attack, and the power of the piece, is the anonymity of the victims. The very evil Picasso was decrying was the dehumanization of the people. Making them famous characters like the X-men, with roles and backstories, adds a layer that works against the intent of Picasso. By cleverly slotting the characters, Thea manages to avoid this most of the time -- Beast mirrors the animal, for example, and Nightcrawler is dead. Magneto is the major problem, and he's in a bad place for ambiguity. If I had to answer, I'd say he's being attacked like the rest, but there is that question.

Inserting the Phoenix and the fence, items without a parallel, point this out more than they fill necessary gaps. Is the Phoenix supposed to be a replacement for the light bulb? Or is it simply, like Wolverine, something you have to have in the piece if it's going to be an X-work?

Because, I really miss the light bulb, or any equivalent to it. The electric light shaped like an eye is one of the great images in Western art; Picasso uses it to attack the viewer, and the culture that saw this happen, and yet did nothing in response. That eye is a challenge to the viewer of the painting to respond to the work. The viewer watches the painting; the eye is "watching" the viewer to see if they, like everyone else, lets this pass.

Which brings us back to the question of whether including the X-Men is damaging to the work. The best X-comics, such as "God Loves, Man Kills" or "Days of Future Passed" have always contained that element of challenge to the reader. (The only thing that makes modern Cyclops tolerable is that you can see how years of this struggle can warp even the best of people.) Through creative skill and a sense of arrangement, Thea has certainly done that. The questions are important, but the overall work is sublime. I have seen few others who would even attempt this, so give her full credit for audacity and vision and nearly full for execution.

OH, and before I forget -- this was done in her SPARE TIME, over the course of perhaps a week at most. That is nothing short of phenomenal!
Theamat's avatar
Most definitely fair! OMG, so much thought went into this!

Becca, in answer to your question on the Phoenix and the fence:

There was a meaning behind it. Especially the placement of Phoenix. I did choose to replace the lightbulb with the Phoenix. Please notice how the character of cyclops stares up at the sky. His single eye beam is centered on his vision of hope, the Phoenix. Although he seems defeated by war, he still has hope. It is something I've admired about the character, something I wish all people had despite the war and destruction around them. From the ashes of the burning Phoenix, there is life and hope.

A different message than picasso's to be sure, but it was what I had to say from the heart.

A thank you for your lucid and thoughtful comments. you are an awesome critic!
ElRinaZuza's avatar
Marvelous critique! That is exactly to which I aspire while writing critiques by my own. From my point of view any work like this should be marked as fair even for its size and for the time that the "writer" had spent on leaving a thoughtful and detailed comment instead of a little comment where would be written only "Super", "Good" or even "Wow"! Yours is a beautiful example of an incontrovertible work/critique!
gowdi's avatar
A brilliant piece Thea -- my brain has trouble taking it in all at once -- I can't imagine how tricky it was to put on paper.
Theamat's avatar
Thanks! It was tough. I kept wanting to correct my lines and had to keep convincing myself to let the shapes just be shapes. It's much harder than it looks. Lol
sauronct's avatar
In the Wolverine Vol 2 issue 36, Wolverine WAS really in Guernica the same date of the attack. Good mash-up
Theamat's avatar
Wow! that's a blast from the past. Thanks for the info!
plupluche's avatar
The idea is excellent ! You strike a big blow.
Theamat's avatar
jfmolinera's avatar
Excelent !!! great job !!
anthrodiva's avatar
It sounds like there were other possibilities for you to interpret? This one is a poor image to choose, to say the least. It is important artistically, historically, and even topically. They covered the tapestry version of this at the UN for Colin Powell's address in 2002 in favor of going to war. It is powerful because it shows the death of innocent citizens (and their children) essentially as part of a product demonstration -- Hitler was showing off Messerschmidt's to Franco. Distinct parallels to today.

I understand your argument, except that X-Men are not real and real people died in Guernica. There is no way, regardless of execution, that this treatment of such a massively important painting in this manner, could fail to be read as trivializing those deaths.
Theamat's avatar
I respectfully disagree with the premise of comparing my piece to the original, especially outside of the context of The Line It Is Drawn. It artificially inflates the value of my piece in the cultural milieu and unjustly degrades the original's. But as I have stated before, I apologize to all for any unintended misperceptions.
azuthell's avatar
this is so rude! guernica was made, about the bombings of the town guernica.. there are tears on it, there are sorrow and grief on it.. and you made it with xmen? and think that its so funny and clever? for me its so rude, and an insult to humankind!!
Theamat's avatar
Sorry that you do not see the purpose, thank you for posting your commentary.
arachnidman's avatar
This is truly AMAZING! Not much more I can say to express how I feel about it. I'm by no means an art critic but I know what I like and I really like this!
Theamat's avatar
Thanks for the stamp of approval!
davel-jonez's avatar
This is a very good execution of disgusting idea.
The only Guernica comic mashup I can imagine not being offensive is perhaps Art Spiegelman’s Maus.
Theamat's avatar
Thanks, I appreciate that you give me props for skill, if not for content.
Fabulous, wish it was for sale.
Theamat's avatar
Nope! Sorry, not a penny! But you can download to your heart's content.
Fabulous, I wish it was for sale
m7781's avatar
very glad you lost that coin toss.. you are brave for tackling this one..
you couldnt have made it any better..
perfection!
Theamat's avatar
Your so nice, thanks. It does take the sting out of that coin toss! Lol
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In