Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login

AutoShoujo Cover Contest Winners!

Journal Entry: Tue Sep 1, 2009, 5:37 PM
If you want to contact me, email works better than DA notes. Email address down below my ID on my DA page.

Commission info!
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+


Congratulations to the winners of the AutoShoujo Cover Contest!

FIRST PLACE: Clockwork Boyfriend Tomorrow -- Shira-chan

Clockwork Boyfriend Tomorrow by Shira-chan

Rachel:  A brilliant mélange of shoujo plot tropes, from the "you must be my servant" bargain to the rock band to the tragic car accident, but the heroine holding the literal key to the hero's wind-up heart elevates the whole thing to cracktastic genius.

wintersweet: One of the most expressive covers with great facial expressions and a really imaginative take on the title, which did a great job of working in established manga/anime tropes. It's also very well designed and laid out, and looks very professional.

telophase: Rachel and wintersweet cover it all: awesome graphic design and attention to detail, like picking the absolute right font for the title and echoing it on the back, intriguing characters, and a crack-filled plot!


SECOND PLACE: Number One Singing King -- AmbrMerlinus

:thumb133337460:

Rachel: I loved the wacky yet poignant premise, which mashes up two shoujo perennials-- genderbending and a talent contest -- into the tale of transgendered singer Thomas/Amanda, who may lose his chance at singing fame if he takes voice-changing testosterone, and pins his destiny to the outcome of a drag king contest. Truly a manga-worthy plight-- and one whose more detailed description seems supportive of all the myriad ways in which people can express their gender and their sexual orientation.

wintersweet: This entry was one of the ones where I focused on the story. It's intriguing and something I'd be very likely to pick up if I had a chance.

telophase: The design of this cover is simple and dramatic, showing that you don't always have to throw everything plus the kitchen sink into a design to make it effective.  I also love how the protagonist is faced with an agonizing choice to make between his dreams and his heart.



THIRD PLACE Absolute World-Class Childhood -- Achiru-et-al

Absolute World-Class Childhood by Achiru-et-al

Rachel: The inventiveness of using more autoshoujo titles as individual episodes, the amount of work it took to generate all those screenshots, and the playfulness and charm of the art and story combine to make a remarkably plausible DVD.

wintersweet: This was my vote for first because of all the work put in on the screencaps (they even look like animation stills, not just small rectangular art), the use of even more Autoshoujo titles as episode titles, the believably bizarre "everything in a blender"-style plot, and the detailed design. It looks like a ton of work was put into it!

telophase:  Everything from the color scheme to the font to the graphic design of this entry screams professional. Add in a cracktastic storyline, and you've got a winner!

=====================================

We would like to extend congratulations not only to the winners, but to everyone who entered: you guys turned out a fantastic bunch of manga, book, and DVD covers and made it very, very hard for us to judge this contest. You should have seen the emails we sent back and forth lamenting that we couldn't give out more prizes, and whining about how hard it was to narrow our choices down!

We've included some Honorable Mentions below, to single out some of the other outstanding entries, but, really, you are ALL wonderful and we thank you for sharing your thoughts, creativity, and hard work with us.  If you ever publish ANY of the stories we saw here, we'll be right there at the bookstore!


=====================================


JUDGING PROCESS

In case you were wondering how we judged them, each of us - Rachel Manija Brown, wintersweet, and myself, telophase - compiled a list of our top 10 picks in order from 1 to 10.  Once we established that at least 3 entries appeared on all three lists, we assigned each position a number value: the first pick got 10 points, the second 9, and so on down to the tenth place, which got 1 point.  We added the numbers together for each entry on all three lists, and then sorted them according to the total, which gave us the top three picks.  Clockwork Boyfriend Tomorrow had 23 points, Number One Singing King had 22, and Absolute World-Class Childhood received 21.  You can see how close that was!

As always, judging a contest like this can be subjective, and perhaps you don't agree with our choices.  If that's the case, we encourage you to reward the person you think should have won! Buy them some paid time on DA, or feature them on your journal or even just drop a comment on their entry letting them know how much you like it!


=====================================


Rachel's Honorable Mentions:

Secret Clouds. I was entranced by the numinous, Miyazaki-esque premise, not to mention the eye-catching glowy fish. I was also amused by the blurb from DA Magazine.

Land of Scrapped Shinigami. Striking art and the irresistible subtitle "A junkyard that houses discarded psychopomps."

Sky Battle Cocoa. Absolutely convincing as sweet-enough-to-rot-your-teeth magical girl adventure. "Sky Battle! Transform!"

Gangster Zodiac Beauty. Lovely package and a delicious premise reminiscent of some lost Kaori Yuki manga. My favorite part was "her faithful valet, Calypso."

Cyborg Fashion Bakery. Completely adorable story, from a ninja whose name translates as "Shadow of the Eggplant" to the wholehearted enthusiasm with which the premise is embraced. What to do when androids and ninja are forbidden to associate? Run away together in your flying cake shop/boutique, and battle attack monkeys, pirates, and vampires on the side! (What, no zombies?)

Snowy Rose. Pretty art and a very solid story.

Floating Peach Dagger. This had me at the Hana to Yume mock-up, before I even learned that the heroine is a blind courtesan.


=====================================


wintersweet's Honorable Mentions

I really regretted not having infinite prizes so we could award prizes to several more, including...

Land of Scrapped Shinigami, which had possibly my favorite cover art and a great hook line on the back, and is another one I would really read.

Sky Battle Cocoa, which does a lovely job with magical girl cliches (and manages to make brown look cute).

Cute Sugar Petshop, which made my teeth ache with its cuteness but also has a really clever story to go with it.

#1 Rhythm Pirates, another one that nails the cel look and also incorporates more Autoshoujo titles as episodes, along with an interesting sf plot that's different from any of the others. (He is My Sweet Tea has a cute story and also used multiple titles--awesome! Since I wrote the generator, of course I love this.)

I love libraries and library-themed manga is practically a subgenre of its own, so I would actually pick up both There Can Be Only One Library Tale and Silent Whisper Library if I saw them in a store, because their stories were intriguing.

The art on Passionate Shadow Happiness was really striking (um, no pun intended) and really fit the story.

I enjoyed the detailed art, such as the sinister three-headed shadow on the cute puppy, and the story summary on My Shinigami Secretary.

There were even more, but I have to stop! Thank you so much to everyone who participated!


=====================================


telophase's Honorable Mentions

I loved the entries that Rachel and wintersweet feature above, but I shall use my space to point out a few I thought were great that did not appear on their lists.


100% Whispers.  I love the setup here, with a voiceless heroine holding an apparently impossible dream of becoming a singer. If I found this in a bookstore, I'd definitely buy a copy to see if and how the heroine achieves her ambition.

Heaven's Pet Gods.  Dramatic cover, and short but intriguing cover copy. I would have to grab a copy if I saw it in the store! (This is a case where more text about the story would be far less effective - the artist nailed it here.)

Bitter Angel Hearts.  OK, I'm a sucker for the good/evil pairings. This one looks promising!

Rose of Marshmallow Tomorrow.  Our very first entry, and the one that made me realize how daunting a task we had ahead of us, if all the entries were even half as good!  A tough, fierce heroine on the front cover, and ... a bunny in coat and glasses on the back. I'd have to pick that up to see what it's about!

Hell Heartbeat Moon.  I enjoy darker, grittier manga and I love the setup in this one.

I was stunned by how fantastic all the entries were, and I'm not exagerrating when I say I'd pick any one of these off a shelf and take a look at it if I saw it in a a book or video store. Congratulations to all!


=====================================


ALL AUTOSHOUJO COVER CONTEST ENTRIES

There was one non-DA entry, Will La Puerta's My Shinigami Secretary.  Below, find the rest of the entries posted on DA.

Absolute World-Class Childhood by Achiru-et-al Welcome to Misty Road by AdventureAddict :thumb133337460: The Portrait of Secret Roses f by ayuICHI The Portrait of Secret Roses b by ayuICHI Dokidoki Lucky Mermaid front by ayuICHI Dokidoki Lucky Mermaid back by ayuICHI Never Secret Airship by Ayuna-chan :thumb130123921: :thumb130124183: ::Land of Scrapped Shinigami by cerine Delinquent Shadow Road Front by Chaos2112 Delinquent Shadow Road Back by Chaos2112 Society of no Flower by claes-gascogne :thumb128637623: :thumb128678167: :thumb128679558: :thumb128692197: :thumb128678937: :thumb128679196: Crazy Crazy Rainbow by Denna The Melancholy of Fun Life by Denna Memory of Tomorrow Splendor by Draw4life Auto ShOjo Cover 1 of ? by Elkian :thumb130786067: :thumb131146518: Autoshoujo Cover Contest SCE by hiei14 :thumb127695158: :thumb133562167: He Is My Sweet Tea pg 1 by kana-kana He Is My Sweet Tea pg 2 by kana-kana Pastel Secret Girlfriend pg 1 by kana-kana Pastel Secret Girlfriend pg 2 by kana-kana X Bittersweet Knight pg 1 by kana-kana X Bittersweet Knight pg 2 by kana-kana :thumb133653461: :thumb133429855: Bitter_Angel_Hearts by Sprucie Heaven's Pet Gods by Sprucie :thumb129195570: :thumb129195723: :thumb130819486: Celestial Lies by NatAliDenton Passionate Shadow Happiness by m3ru Contest: Moonlight Tea Club by NekoNamiCosplay   Contest: Peach Spirit Maid by NekoNamiCosplay 100 Percent Whispers by Naka-ko Please Save My Whisper Shadows by Naka-ko Contest: Sky Battle Cocoa by nekomukuro La Petit Amnesiac Boyfriend by NotoriousZilo Cyborg Fashion Bakery by OverChasm I'm Attack Blues by OverChasm La Petit Clumsy Present: Front by KnotInTheCoffin La Petit Clumsy Present: Back by KnotInTheCoffin Broken Tangerine by Rekslare :thumb133472988: :thumb133590789: :thumb128818345: :thumb128818625: Clockwork Boyfriend Tomorrow by Shira-chan Sword of the Judo Mages by Shira-chan Magical Kitten Empress by silverluna Society of Sweet Apocalypse by silverluna :thumb131176989: Cute Sugar Petshop by sjf9687 Hell Code Mystery by sKETCHII-mop Divine Costume Kiss by Sozzi-Pierogi :thumb130399082:   :thumb128547102: :thumb133391982: Number One Gentlemen by invertings AutoShoujo Cover Contest Entry by x-GreenTeaMochi-x :thumb128579723:

=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=


DEVIANTS ACCEPTING COMMISSIONS:

(In alphabetical order)

Cacodaemonia cacodaemonia.deviantart.com/jo…
Elizabeth-EvilChibi
FallenSiren fallensiren.deviantart.com/jou…
fleetfoot
Ilenora www.serpentinemoon.com/eternit…
Kauritsuo
Linake linake.deviantart.com/journal/…
Miyukitty miyukitty.deviantart.com/journ…
neogio neogio.deviantart.com/art/3000…
nightambre
pchaness
Phaiyle phaiyle.deviantart.com/journal…
QuantumEldrAg quantumeldrag.deviantart.com/j…
Salahare www.freewebs.com/salahare/cont…
ScorpionOcean scorpionocean.deviantart.com/j…
shinkamalei shinkamalei.deviantart.com/jou… ($5 lineart special! shinkamalei.deviantart.com/jou…)
Shira-chan shira-chan.deviantart.com/jour…
Sydia
TalentlessAssassin
wind-hime-kaze wind-hime-kaze.deviantart.com/…
Wolverina
wyndstar wyndstar.deviantart.com/journa…
Oribuu

(Wanna be on this list? Drop a comment letting me know, and if you've got a page or journal entry with commission info on it, link me!)

=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=

:iconnaruto-madness::iconirukar0x0rz::iconjiraiya-club::iconclubsaiyuki::icondeathnotefan::iconhella-toes:

=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=


My MangaBullet page - mind clicking on it to increase my click-through stats? :D If you create an MB account after clicking through, I might get a prize, but you don't have to do that.


  • Listening to: keyboards clicking and servers whirring
  • Reading: About a million books
  • Watching: Mythbusters!
  • Playing: Okami
  • Eating: pork chops!
Add a Comment:
 
:iconnekomukuro:
nekomukuro Featured By Owner Sep 11, 2009  Hobbyist Digital Artist
*lol I notice 10 days late*
Cool, I got two honorable mentions! :o thanks! :heart:
I'm glad the entry I was rooting for won the first place :) Congrats to all the three winners! Overall it has been a great contest, it produced a lot of inspiring and creative stuff <3
Reply
:iconprettyism:
prettyism Featured By Owner Sep 4, 2009  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I couldn't enter but these entries are all so great and inspiring. I did actually write a story based on the title I generated so that was fun :D
Reply
:icontelophase:
telophase Featured By Owner Sep 8, 2009  Hobbyist Digital Artist
All right! XD Then it's served its purpose well.
Reply
:iconsprucie:
Sprucie Featured By Owner Sep 3, 2009  Student Filmographer
Wow _ what a turn over. SO many entries :iconvictorydanceplz:

Congrats to the winners!
and thanks for the mentions telophase :iconlovecuddleplz:
Reply
:icontelophase:
telophase Featured By Owner Sep 8, 2009  Hobbyist Digital Artist
You're welcome! :)
Reply
:iconoverchasm:
OverChasm Featured By Owner Sep 2, 2009  Hobbyist
Cool, I received an honorable mention! XD

Flying zombies would have been a good idea~
Reply
:iconm3ru:
m3ru Featured By Owner Sep 2, 2009  Professional Filmographer
Thanks for the honorable mention, wintersweet n 3n
Reply
:iconwintersweet:
wintersweet Featured By Owner Sep 1, 2009
Thanks so much everyone! I loved seeing your entries!
Reply
:icontelophase:
telophase Featured By Owner Sep 2, 2009  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Me, too! I was so encouraged by all the entries that I want to do another contest of some ilk ...




... but not in the near future. XD
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×

:icontelophase: More from telophase


More from DeviantArt



Details

Submitted on
September 1, 2009
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
3,051
Favourites
0
Comments
9