Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
An opinion on those overhated Nintendo Games by SuperNicolas1234 An opinion on those overhated Nintendo Games by SuperNicolas1234
Most people bashed these games because of biased nostalgia.
There are far worse games out there such as Hotel Mario, Educational Mario Games, The Unholy Triforce (CD-i Zelda Games), most of the games for the Virtual Boy console, etc.

Mario, Metroid, & Star Fox © Nintendo
Stamp Template © Kencho
Add a Comment:
 
:iconcorvus-the-snark:
Corvus-the-Snark Featured By Owner May 22, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
This is probably the most prevalent problem amongst gamers today: they exaggerate the badness of a lot of games both recent and old. The worst game shown on this stamp is Sticker Star and that one is just below average at worst.
Reply
:iconiclubbabyseals:
iClubBabySeals Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2018
Really? I thought Super Mario Sunshine was pretty good.
Reply
:iconcrick-crick:
crick-crick Featured By Owner Feb 3, 2018
Wait... people thought Mario Sunshine and Starfox Adventures were bad games? I can understand the criticism of adventures for being a zelda clone and the fact that they essentially shoehorned starfox into it since the original game was going to be called Dinosaur Planet and have a different plot, but why mario? Sunshine is probably the most fun mario game I've ever played along with Super mario 64
Reply
:iconsupernicolas1234:
SuperNicolas1234 Featured By Owner Feb 3, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
It's ironic to label Starfox Adventures a Zelda clone because both Zelda & Starfox are created & own by Nintendo. (Plus, Zelda isn't the first dungeon crawler adventure ever made.)

You obviously not looking into the right places for certain opinions on Super Mario Sunshine.
Reply
:iconcrick-crick:
crick-crick Featured By Owner Feb 4, 2018
I didn't mean I personally see it as a zelda clone but a lot of people do
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner Jan 2, 2018
So which game do you personally like better, Super Mario Sunshine, or Paper Mario: Color Splash?
Reply
:iconbubbles46853:
bubbles46853 Featured By Owner Dec 15, 2017
You should add Fire Emblem Fates to this stamp.
Reply
:iconluna-runa:
Luna-Runa Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
Tell me about it. That game gets too much hate on GameFAQs forums. And some of the users bash you if you like Fates over the older titles.
Reply
:iconbubbles46853:
bubbles46853 Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2017
I know I sure have. I also get bashed for thinking Peri is one of my favorites.
Reply
:iconluna-runa:
Luna-Runa Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
I got called shit taste for not having a switch and owning fates instead.
Reply
:iconbubbles46853:
bubbles46853 Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2017
Well, I hope you get one this Christmas!
Reply
:iconluna-runa:
Luna-Runa Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
I don’t celebrate Xmas and I just got a new phone so unlikely I would get a switch. I am getting a job next month, and will save a lot.
Reply
:iconbubbles46853:
bubbles46853 Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2017
Oh, you don't? What do you celebrate? Regardless, I hope it goes well this season.
Reply
:iconluna-runa:
Luna-Runa Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
Yep. And I actually like Corrin.
Reply
(1 Reply)
:iconkimmyun:
kimmyun Featured By Owner Dec 7, 2017
How is Super Mario Sunshine Hated? I see a lot of people are praising on it.
Reply
:iconbronyvideogamer:
BronyVideoGamer Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2018   Writer
Three words: Super Mario Odyssey.
Reply
:iconmotherfan142:
motherfan142 Featured By Owner Sep 30, 2017  Student General Artist
*COUGH COUGH* almost every indie rpg maker games *COUGH COUGH*
Reply
:iconbronyvideogamer:
BronyVideoGamer Featured By Owner Sep 24, 2017   Writer
Tell me about it. I still see people bash Sticker Star and Color Splash to this day. Along with the Sonic series.
Reply
:iconasrielneedshugs:
asrielneedshugs Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2017  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
How in the fuck, could anyone hate Super Mario Sunshine?!
Reply
:icongood-boi:
good-boi Featured By Owner Jun 21, 2017  Student Digital Artist
Super Mario Sunshine is like the best game in the world how do people actually hate it
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2017
I think you might need to watch this video to find out: m.youtube.com/watch?v=O6WwtmDK…
Reply
:iconrock-raider:
Rock-Raider Featured By Owner May 28, 2017
I played some of the games mentioned.  I played...

1.Super Mario Sunshine.
2.Starfox Adventures: Dinosaur Planet.
3.Metroid Other M (I rented the game).

I bought Federation Force, but I haven't played it yet.  And I WANT to play Color Splash.
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner Edited May 11, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Well, in regards of the games that you put in the description: What can you expect of games like the CD-i Zelda and Educational Mario games that either were made by their creators or having this kind of terrible ideas? they were going to be shit anyway.

Now with the games you have mentioned in the stamps (except for Sunshine since that game actually is amazing), unlike people who defend them, people who hate/dislike them have valid reasons. Federation Force because it had very little resemblance to an actual Metroid game, and fans expressed frustration at Nintendo for developing a spin-off instead of a main-series title like a new Metroid Prime or another Metroidvania, as the series had been on hiatus for 5 years. (8 for most of the fans, considering that they hated Other M), Sticker Star because it abandonded what made Paper Mario so special like the RPG elements, partners, stories, original characters, etc. And with Color Splash, it was expected to recieve extremely negative reception upon getting announced for it's similarities with Sticker Star and once again, fans expressed frustration at Nintendo for not contining the PM64 and TTYD formula they love so much instead since it's been 13 since a Paper Mario RPG came out. As for Star Fox Adventures, you should have put Zero instead since that game got much more hate than Adventures and even Assault for being a reharsh of Star Fox 64 with shitty motions controls.

Also, saying that people bashed all these games because of biased nostalgia is as fake as Half-Life 3 being officially confirmed because if we go by your logic, then people who defend all these games would be super newfags because they can't stand the fact that people are going to bash their game, no matter how valid their point are. Denying this would make yourself (and pretty much everybody who defended those games) nothing but a close-minded hypocrite.

Now to finish this, did you know that the last year was the Metroid 30th anniversary and Paper Mario 15th anniversary? With something like that, fans were expecting that Nintendo would make games of their respective series to honour those beloved series kinda like how they did with Kid Icarus 25th anniversary with Kid Icarus: Uprising. And why did Nintendo do? 
They paid no attention to let alone respects.
Reply
:iconsupernicolas1234:
SuperNicolas1234 Featured By Owner Jul 16, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
Those games are all I can think of for my statement.

Sunshine being amazing is an opinion not a fact. Just because they have valid reasons, doesn't mean that they have the right to bully other people for having an opinion that differs from theirs. Federation Force is obviously not your cup of tea. TTYD looks like a rehash of the first Paper Mario game just with a few cosmetic changes. The old Paper Mario formula isn't perfect because there are flaws that the purists have overlooked. I think both Adventures & Zero are overhated. Planet Robobot is just a rehash of Triple Deluxe but with a mech gimmick. It's possible to master Zero's motion controls according to some people.

The reason why I said that is because they think that change is "objectively" bad along with treating the old games like it's religion & bullying people for not liking them. Not all people who liked the games that you hate are fanbrats. Same can be said for certain haters depending on a situation.

I think the reason why they don't respect your favorite franchises is because they don't make ton of profit compared to their 3 major cash cow franchises.
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner Jul 18, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Federation Force is okay. However, I think Prime Hunters is way more underrated.
How it's a TTYD a reharsh of the first Paper Mario? It's a sequel just like how Banjo Tooie, Donkey Kong Country 2, Majora's Mask, Pikmin 2, Metroid Prime 2, etc. are sequels of their respective games. Or are you going to call these beloved games reharshes just because of their similitaries of their prequels?
No games are perfect but those formulas really made the first two Paper Mario games so beloved. Not only the battle system was really loved, but also the characters that you wouldn't find in your typical Mario game, the environments, the humor according to the situations, etc.

I don't think they think change is objetively bad, like Arlo said once "We love when you try new things Nintendo, we really do. But not when these new things replaces every old thing we love".

I sometimes likes to pretends that franchises that are not cash cows (Metroid, Pikmin, F-Zero, etc.) tends to be the bestest. Always original, never getting milked, taking their time to have some new ideas and most of all, ambitious.
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner May 27, 2017
So what Nintendo games are simply hated for Nostaligia?
Reply
:iconbronyvideogamer:
BronyVideoGamer Featured By Owner Sep 24, 2017   Writer
Paper Mario: Sticker Star, Color Splash, Mario Party 9, 10, Advance, Island Tour, the Sonic series from Sonic Adventure onwards, and Federation Force.
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner Edited May 27, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Nope. They are hated by Nintendo's terrible treatment of both series and their fanbases, including things like changing for the sake of changing with no good result, slapping the name of a beloved series in a completely unrelated game just to boost sales, or ignoring the massive criticism of both series' current direction, which unsurprisingly led to the lastest entries tanking massively in terms of sales figures.
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner Jun 5, 2017
So would Mr. Enter give, Paper Mario: Sticker Star/Color Splash, Metroid: Other M/Federation Force, and Star Fox Zero positive reviews seeing as he gave the Powerpuff Girls/Teen Titans Go! crossover a positive review, which indicates he's one of those sane people who knows not everything from the 2010s sucks?
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner Jun 5, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Eh, his lack of objetivity makes all his reviews unvalid.
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner Nov 26, 2017
And it's not just on the animated atrocities?
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner Jun 5, 2017
So who are some more sane reviewers out there?
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner May 27, 2017
No I was asking WHAT Nintendo games are hated simply because of nostaligia?
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner May 27, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
No one. They all had their respective reasons.
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner May 27, 2017
What about Super Mario Odyssey as insane fans are making stupid excuses to hate the game, such as Mario being in a realistic city with realistic humans?
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner May 27, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
The only thing I saw about them is calling it a Sonic 2006 clone. But i don't care about what they think.
Odyssey will be an amazing game.
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner May 27, 2017
Yesh those kind of Mario fans are absolutely Cuckoo.
Reply
(1 Reply)
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner May 22, 2017
Well you know Super Mario Sinshine was hated for being a rushed game with more than half of it's content being cut out and being riddled with glitches much like Spyro: Enter the Dragonfly, and also Nintendo has made worse games then any of the ones mentioned here back in the 80s such as Ice Climber, Urban Champion, Earthbound Beginnings and Zelda Adventure of Link, and did mention their are people out there who blindly hate every 2010s Nintendo game because of games like Color Splash being made, much like the Sonic fans who bash ever modern Sonic game weather good or bad?
Reply
:iconasia-catdog-blue:
asia-catdog-blue Featured By Owner Jul 27, 2018
Also, its content looked lame compared to 64.
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner May 22, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Sadly I have never played the Spyro series so I can't say anything about that. I have never seen anyone hating Ice Climber, Urban Champion, Earthbound Beginnings and Zelda Adventure of Link (which could be due to the difficulty spike), in that aspect, then they would hate the NES as a whole for having extremely hard games like Megaman 2 or Battletoads. Their "hate" isn't blind because most of them are justified with games like Color Splash and Star Fox Zero, those are perfect examples at how unambitious Nintendo was being nowadays.
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner May 22, 2017
Urban Champion got terrible reviews for critics, Ice Climber is extremely repetitive and boring complete with an awkward jumping control, Earthbound Beginnings is considered the worst in the MOTHER series due form a big case of early installment weirdness, and you should see the Angry Video Game Nerds review of Adventure of Link.
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner May 22, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I think they consider Earthbound Beginnings their least favorite of the Mother series because of the difficulty spike.
Reply
:icontoxicisland:
ToxicIsland Featured By Owner May 23, 2017
I heard MOTHER 3 was so hated in Japan (the country that actually played the game) it makes the games mentioned in this stamp look like sacred cows in comparison, implying that people only assume MOTHER 3 is the best in the series due for it being published by Nintendo.
Reply
:iconsupernicolas1234:
SuperNicolas1234 Featured By Owner May 12, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
Have you met SonicTeam765 a.k.a. DarkSonic180 before?

Not only he attacks people who ships Sonic with Amy & various other pairings he doesn't like, he also attacks people who likes Sticker Star/Color Splash & various other overhated Nintendo games as well.

Don't believe me? Here's some examples of his bigotry.

(You can find him in the comment section on some Sticker Star/Color Splash related videos.)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDWkHe…
www.youtube.com/watch?v=eFU9Q7…
www.youtube.com/watch?v=p0N5oo…
Reply
:iconviviareena:
viviareena Featured By Owner Edited May 12, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That doesn't reply my comment.

PS: The guy you mentionet has already apologized for everything like 5 months Ok. I got something to say to everyone who hates m
Reply
:iconsupernicolas1234:
SuperNicolas1234 Featured By Owner May 12, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
I doubt that he's changed. I think he just made that apology journal just to get sympathy.
Reply
:iconsonicthedeviant:
SonicTheDeviant Featured By Owner May 9, 2017
I DONT SEE SONIC 06
Reply
:iconsupernicolas1234:
SuperNicolas1234 Featured By Owner May 9, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
Sonic is own by Sega not Nintendo.
Reply
:iconsonicthedeviant:
SonicTheDeviant Featured By Owner May 9, 2017
o

should be overhated games in general
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×




Details

Submitted on
May 18, 2016
Image Size
31.1 KB
Resolution
99×56
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
1,611 (2 today)
Favourites
66 (who?)
Comments
92
Downloads
1