Retro vs Modern - Choose the Next Heroine

The nominees are in.

From cult sci-fi icons to modern live-action warriors, each candidate represents a different era of superhero storytelling.

To keep the selection focused, the competition will be divided into two elimination rounds:

Retro Heroines and Modern Heroines.

The top three from each era will advance to the final round, where the community will decide which heroine will be featured in the next Watchers Only Gallery.

🔶 Round 1a — Retro Heroines (vote here now!)

Classic icons from earlier decades.

• Barbarella — Jane Fonda

• Batgirl — Yvonne Craig

• Batgirl — Alicia Silverstone

• Darna — Nanette Medved

• Wilma Deering — Erin Gray

• Wonder Girl — Debra Winger

Top 3 advance to the Final Round.

🔷 Round 1b — Modern Heroines (vote here now!)

More recent live-action versions.

• Black Scorpion — Michelle Lintel

• Darna — Angel Locsin

• Darna — Jane de Leon

• Donna Troy — Conor Leslie

• White Canary — Caity Lotz

Top 3 advance to the Final Round.

🏆 Final Round

The best from each era will face each other.

Retro vs Modern.
Six finalists.

Only one heroine will be selected for the next Watchers Only Gallery.

Note on the nominations

Two interesting suggestions were left out of this poll to keep the theme focused on existing live-action portrayals:

• Wonder Woman (cape variant) — Lynda Carter

• She-Ra (live-action concept)

Both ideas may appear in future polls dedicated to alternate designs or hypothetical live-action versions.