Joker's School Uniform Texture Enhancement

I don't know if you can tell but the one on the left is the former way that I do textures but it took away

the detail, so I enhanced the texture on the right by letting the lighting on the suit shin through.

Tell me what you think and I'll change it according to the answers.

It didn't dull out the color however it does look overly saturated...

I don't know and that's why I'm asking you, which one do you like?