ScottHartman's avatar
How big is your favorite dinosaur?
By ScottHartman   |   Watch
284 189 16K (1 Today)
Published: April 19, 2013
© 2013 - 2019 ScottHartman
Now before you start freaking out, note that the T. rex specimen is Sue (i.e. the largest T. rex) while the Triceratops and Stegosaurus specimens that I restored are one the smaller side. For that reason I included silhouettes of known larger specimens to provide a better estimate of the overall size range. I couldn't do this with Apatosaurus or else everything else would have gotten too small.

Finally, note that Velociraptor is the actual skeletal, while the gray silhouetted dromaeosaur is Deinonychus, not some giant specimen of Velociraptor.

Enjoy, and if you have some good ideas for other comparisons let me know, I'm officially taking suggestions right now.
Image size
4488x2512px 2.26 MB
IMAGE DETAILS
Software
Adobe Photoshop CS6 (Windows)
Comments181
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Sign In
Hater3D's avatar
Hater3DStudent General Artist
it those sizes 100% accurate?but of course not,tyrannosaurus were a lot shorter
ScottHartman's avatar
ScottHartmanProfessional Digital Artist
Let's go with 98% accurate? There's always a little bit of slop around individual pixels, but they should be pretty close.
Dinosaurguy10's avatar
Dinosaurguy10 General Artist
what if mine isnt there D:
Archanubis's avatar
Add in a Pteranodon and take out the raptors, and you have all the classic Dinobots from the original Transformers series (though, if Sludge were a real Apatosaurus/Brontosaurus, he'd seriously dwarf the others).  =P Yes, I know Pteranodon is not a dinosaur, but that's never stopped the media from including it in with the other "stock" dinosaurs.
vasix's avatar
vasixHobbyist Digital Artist
Guess there wasn't much space for the OMNH mega-Apatosaurus, was there? 
ScottHartman's avatar
ScottHartmanProfessional Digital Artist
Then all the non-apatosaur skeletals would have looked like ants.
vasix's avatar
vasixHobbyist Digital Artist
Yikes...
SpinoInWonderland's avatar
And that one wasn't even mature yet. An SVPCA 2013 abstract implies that a hypothetical adult Apatosaurus would probably have been twice as massive.
vasix's avatar
vasixHobbyist Digital Artist
Really? That's quite incredible. 
SpinoInWonderland's avatar
Yeah, if you read that abstract (I posted in on my journal entry here: fav.me/d6rvw8d), it implies that through the notion that the fusion of the cervical ribs comes after neurocentral fusion, along with comparisons with Diplodocus and Giraffatitan.

Assuming that CM3018 would have had a mass of ~25 tonnes, then, based on the implications of the abstract, the Oklahoma Apatosaurus would have massed in at ~50 tonnes, and a hypothetical mature Apatosaurus would be at ~100 tonnes omfg


And yet, the JPW site depicts Tyrannosaurus as larger than Apatosaurus :facepalm:
But I guess that with their kaiju mosasaur thing, a kaiju tyrannosaur isn't too far off...
vasix's avatar
vasixHobbyist Digital Artist
Haha oh yes I saw that on the site...so many kaiju-sized monsters to up the cheese factor and extremely outdated Knightian sauropods to boot with all the marks of perfect phylotardation!
Jdailey1991's avatar
If Deinonychus was the grey silhouette alongside Velociraptor, then who are the other two?
ScottHartman's avatar
ScottHartmanProfessional Digital Artist
Just the largest known specimens (vs the specimens I actually restored).
Dark-Rivals's avatar
Dark-RivalsStudent Digital Artist
cant wait for stomping lands t-rex this thanks giving
NeilRyan's avatar
suddenly the notion of Tyrannosaurus crunching/munching on adult Triceratops makes more sense.
DinoLover09's avatar
DinoLover09Hobbyist General Artist
Looks like Triceratops was over two meters.
Likosaurus's avatar
LikosaurusProfessional Filmographer
Don't know if you still take suggestions, but what about Aucasaurus garridoi?
olofmoleman's avatar
olofmoleman Digital Artist
No love for Parasaurolophus? D:
ScottHartman's avatar
ScottHartmanProfessional Digital Artist
No, to heck with Parasaurolophus! Just kidding, I just didn't think to include it. When I get around to doing faunal-level ones it'll get some love.
olofmoleman's avatar
olofmoleman Digital Artist
Yay!
SpinoInWonderland's avatar
A question:

Is a comparison of individual bones from two taxa that's only distantly related(like a comparison of an Albertosaurus D5 and a Baryonyx D5) really a good method for estimating the relative/comparative body masses?
ScottHartman's avatar
ScottHartmanProfessional Digital Artist
Not particularly, although you could potentially use them to scale up more complete specimens, which wouldn't be the end of the world.
SpinoInWonderland's avatar
Ok. But those extrapolations would have monster error bars then, and thus should only be used if closer relatives aren't available. Thanks!
TheSangson's avatar
TheSangsonProfessional General Artist
No Brachiosaurus.
:iconroyalphasenplz::iconroyalphaseoplz::iconroyalphasetplz:   :iconroyalphasecplz::iconroyalphaseoplz::iconroyalphaseoplz::iconroyalphaselplz:.
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Sign In
©2019 DeviantArt
All Rights reserved