Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login

:iconsbibb:
Overall, the components of this cover have been blended quite well. The colors complement each other, the lighting is beautiful and draws attention to the main figure (though I feel like the back of the model's shirt looks a bit flat), and the use of depth of field in the bush at front adds a really nice touch. The hair itself is drawn beautifully, and the overall feel of the artwork has a painterly quality.

On that note, I do feel that the rocks the model is facing seem almost too sharp/realistic in comparison to the rest of the image. I also find the lightning strike distracting, and I wonder if different placement might have helped alleviate the distraction, or if having the strike be not so bright (which draws the eye to it) and also that it looks like it's running through the main figure's head-- possibly because the sharp quality of the lightning matches the sharpness of the figure, compared to the blurred quality of the rest of the background.

However, the text is beautifully rendered. Easy to read, immediately noticeable... and the lighting and color of the text sits it right in with the rest of the image.

Reasons for my ratings:

Vision: It fits very nicely around a theme. 4 Stars

Originality: Unfortunately, this cover does feel like other covers I've seen. However, it does so in a way that is still appealing, so 3.5 out of 5 stars.

Technique: 4 stars, for all the reasons I mentioned above (and especially the use of depth of field. Had the rocks also had a bit more blur, I might have given this 4.5 stars).

Impact: This caught my attention well enough that I decided to write my first Deviant Art critique. I'm not sure how memorable it will be once I move on to working on something else, but we'll see. So... 3.5 out of 5 stars. (Technically, this might be higher).

Overall, I think this is a beautiful book cover. :-)
The Artist thought this was FAIR
1 out of 1 deviants thought this was fair.

Comments


:icontriziana:
TriZiana Featured By Owner Jan 20, 2015  Professional Digital Artist
Hi there :wave:

Thanks so much for the awesome critique. You bring up valid points, and it's something I well keep in mind in my future covers. Thanks so much for taking the time to do this! I really appreciate it!
Reply
:iconsbibb:
SBibb Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2015  Professional Photographer
You're welcome. It attracted my attention, so I thought I'd give critiquing a shot. Glad I could help. :-)
Reply
Add a Comment: