Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login

WE NEED AN UPVOTE SYSTEM FOR COMMENTS

Journal Entry: Thu Aug 23, 2018, 7:44 AM





You know what we need? (Well I already wrote it in the title of this journal so that ruined it but..) AN UPVOTE SYSTEM FOR COMMENTS! Sometimes I see someone's comment and I want to just 'Like' it or give them a 'lol' emoji, without actually leaving a reply. I dont want to be that guy who goes and reply to everyone's comment... it kinda messes up with the fung shui of the page. Its nothing new, Facebook has been doing it, instagram you can give the comment a 'heart' emoji, Youtube has it. So if there's any Deviantart staff reading this who has the ability to add this feature, that would be so cool! Its just an easier way to give someone a thumbs up rather than think of something to say for every single comment. Mostly cos I dont want to use my brain

So yeah please upvote this journal so it gets more notice... oh wait thats right, YOU CANT DO THAT YET! XD

Facebook Thumbs Up Icon Natsu and Happy (Thumbs Up) [V1] Kyungsoo : Thumbs Up thumbsup Milo thumbs up (MML Emoticon) Tajima so cool Thumbs up parrot Thumbs up lady 

.





  • Watching: Ragnar Lothbrok
  • Eating: Beyond Burger at LOTF (It got me emotional)
Add a Comment:
 
:iconpinkpeppersjam:
PinkPeppersJam Featured By Owner Sep 2, 2018  Hobbyist Digital Artist
You're asking them while even deleting comments isn't possible :^( But hopefully this will be a feature in dA in the future!
Reply
:icondeleca-7755:
Deleca-7755 Featured By Owner Aug 27, 2018  Hobbyist Digital Artist
"So yeah please upvote this journal so it gets more notice... oh wait thats right, YOU CANT DO THAT YET! XD"

hysterical laughter
Reply
:iconartreall:
artReall Featured By Owner Aug 26, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
agree 100%!:D
Reply
:iconlizlovestoons12:
Lizlovestoons12 Featured By Owner Aug 25, 2018  Hobbyist Artist
That would be nice. :nod:
Reply
:iconthomasvandijk:
thomasVanDijk Featured By Owner Aug 24, 2018
You can submit suggestions for improving deviant ar here: deviantart.zendesk.com/hc/en-u…
Reply
:iconjoeyjazz:
JoeyJazz Featured By Owner Aug 24, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
Only if I could turn this crap off on my profile and in my whole gallery - I'm glad this travesty has remained off dA for so long. Next you'll want to add new 'comment' category among artworks.
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 24, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
let me just downvote this comment.

Facebook Thumbs Down Icon 
Reply
:iconjoeyjazz:
JoeyJazz Featured By Owner Aug 24, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:D suit yourself ;)
Reply
:icontigerlion101:
TigerLion101 Featured By Owner Aug 24, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
so many times this is needed
Reply
:iconalilloli:
ALilLoli Featured By Owner Aug 24, 2018  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Upvoted
Reply
:iconkanoeshirota:
KanoeShirota Featured By Owner Aug 24, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
Well, yes that would truly be awesome! :)
I thought about often as well. It's great that DA is different and unique, but when it comes to 'Likes' it would be great to have some
more 'Insta or FB' functions.
Reply
:iconwystthewyk:
WystTheWyk Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist
Thumbs Up [F2U] 
Reply
:iconspamcrackers:
SpamCrackers Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
As long as we can downvote too to even it out, I love the idea. 
Reply
:iconmariana-souza:
Mariana-Souza Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Student Digital Artist
Something simple like 9gag's upvoting and downvoting system on comments would be cool :XD:

Totally agree with the idea Facebook Thumbs Up Icon
Reply
:iconbloodredkit:
BloodRedKit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
as long as it doesnt like, auto feature or move most liked comments up tot he top or something, that would get annoying fast

also tbh an option to turn off notifications for it if it is added would be NECESSARY. pls no like spams DX
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
Yaaa have it as an option to see the most upvotrd comment would be good
Reply
:iconuzu-no-kaze:
Uzu-no-Kaze Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
The privacy-crazy guy inside me will tell you "H-E-double hockeystick NO", because that would lead to tracking a lot more user interactions, blah blah blah, that someone could be interested in selling that data to better shoot ads at you, etc.

However, my standard personality says "Screw that, up and down vote systems are too mainstream. Let's do a point based system, going from -10 to +10!Woohooooo!" (points not related to the DA points that are used as some sort of currency here)
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
Mayb whenever somone gives me a point I get $1. But if somone downvotes me I get robbed $1. Damn that would make people super careful about what they say
Reply
:iconinsanepayne:
Insanepayne Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
The only reason I would not want this is because of line webtoons. Comments that get a lot of likes or whatever get a little green lable that says "top" and a good 80% or so of the time you'll also see "Edit: omg thanks for my first ever top comment!" or something like that and it's hella annoying. Takes away from the awesomeness of the comment in the first place and especially annoying on the mobile app because you're forced to scroll past the comments in order to get to the next chapter thing. Pc it's not so bad because you can just avoid the comments section altogether.But imo I used to like the comments section because you could go there to vent about sad stuff in the comic or mention lols and just connect and relate with fellow readers but with the top comment thing it's just.. not that anymore. 

Anyway, could be cool. As long as it doesn't turn into what webtoon has. Because that's lame.
Reply
:iconyueyuetan:
yueyuetan Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018   General Artist
Thank you, this is exactly what annoys me about the comments on Webtoons.
Reply
:iconcomputermeltdown:
ComputerMeltdown Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Personally I'd like to make a new version of dA and add things people have been asking for and fixing a few other things
Reply
:iconmurlem:
murlem Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
Reply
:iconsydvc:
SydVC Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Student General Artist
Facebook Thumbs Up IconFacebook Thumbs Up IconFacebook Thumbs Up IconFacebook Thumbs Up IconFacebook Thumbs Up Icon
Reply
:iconspitestar:
Spitestar Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist Digital Artist
AGREED! Thumbs Up [F2U] Also a delete comment option.
Reply
:iconvt2000:
vt2000 Featured By Owner Edited Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconrelyon:
relyon Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
Yes! jackspecticeye [Two Thumbs UP! V.1] THE BEST LAID   
Reply
:iconlil-lewlew:
Lil-Lewlew Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Thumbs up okay 
Reply
:iconheavenbunny95:
HeavenBunny95 Featured By Owner Edited Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
I’ve actually thought about this several times.

:iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconhearsegurl:
HearseGurl Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
I don't do any other social media but sounds cool and you want something like this for every comment or only certain types of comments?
I ask because we love interacting with you and you always have something witty and silly to reply. :nod:
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconpapierowyszczur:
PapierowySzczur Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
System from Imgur could be nice. You can give upvotes and favourite especially nice works. I'm not sure if downvotes would be a good idea though.
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconblue-eternal-laser:
BLUE-eternal-laser Featured By Owner Edited Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist Photographer
TOTALY AGREE . that way , more usefull comment/corectly formated stuff  can get enanced visibility.

are you gonna go hahead and suggest it to the devlopers ?
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconreyes2410:
Reyes2410 Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
It's actually A good idea
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconshadowisker:
Shadowisker Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
They’d also have to decide if the want a downvote system and several other things.
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconshadowisker:
Shadowisker Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Oh gosh-
Reply
:iconcelestialshimmer:
CelestialShimmer Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018
YESSS!!!! THANK YOU!!!!!
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconcrystalmeteor:
CrystalMeteor Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Could be useful indeed to find more relevant comments at the top. I like it! :clap:
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz::iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconsifriyah:
Sifriyah Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Big Fool Emoji-1 (Thumbs Up) [V2]  
Reply
:iconry-spirit:
Ry-Spirit Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz:
Reply
:iconsifriyah:
Sifriyah Featured By Owner Aug 23, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
:iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: :iconfacebooklikeplz: 
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×

:iconry-spirit: More from Ry-Spirit


Featured in Collections

journals by AgnosticDragon


More from DeviantArt



Details

Submitted on
August 23
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
2,714 (2 today)
Favourites
55 (who?)
Comments
46