Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
Welcome to ProjectComment's Gallery at a Glance! If you sometimes feel a little lost on your artistic journey, if you would like a fresh pair of eyes to help you pinpoint where your strengths and weaknesses are, or if you would just like to know the impression that your art leaves on other viewers, come join us for a round (or two)! :la:

Please Note!


:bulletgreen: This is for Visual Art only.
:bulletgreen: You must give two 100 word comments.
:bulletgreen: You will not be receiving comments on specific pieces, but the ENTIRE gallery folder/page.


Sign Up

  1. Choose a folder or page from your gallery that you would like to have evaluated. There should be a minimum of 5 pieces in the folder you choose.
  2. Reply to this journal with a link to your chosen folder or page.
  3. Include any specific questions you would like to have answered - 5 questions maximum.


How This Works

  1. Once you have signed up, KokoKiero will sort you into a group.
  2. Once your group has 3 members signed up, KokoKiero will send you a note prompting you to constructively comment on each of your two group members' galleries. Any questions your group members have for you will be stated in the note. Click on your group members' names in the note to be brought to their gallery or folder and get started! :la:
  3. Comments must be 100 words of constructive deviation-related content, minimum. Group members' questions and your introduction do not count towards this word limit.
    :note: Your comments will not be accepted if they are under 100 words.
  4. Finished commenting? Reply to this journal with a link to your comment. FAQ #14: How do I create a link to a specific comment?


:note: Deadline: Make your comment within 7 days of receiving your note!

If you need an extension, please note KokoKiero as soon as possible. If you do not comment, you will not be signed up again until these comments are made.


Plain Gray Divider by neripixu Plain Gray Divider by neripixu Plain Gray Divider by neripixu


Constructive Commenting?

While we expect these comments to be constructive in order to help artists' growth, we also want to help artists see what their viewers are seeing. Tell your group members your first impressions, thoughts, and feelings. Look for general strengths, weaknesses and themes, and offer your insight on how you see their art evolving and changing. Take note where the artist is heading, and try to help them improve on the areas that they are working within. Feel free to use specific examples, and refer to pieces and tutorials in order to make sure that the artist knows what you're talking about!

Questions to keep in mind when commenting:
  • What overall impression do I get? What themes do I see? What style do they have?
  • What are they good at? Are they good at telling stories? Are they good at experimentation? Are they good at making one piece flow into another?
  • Are there similar issues in several pieces? What are they and how could the artist improve?
  • Are there similar colour schemes or compositions used throughout the gallery? What other similarities and differences do you notice?
  • What strengths do you notice? How has the artist improved? In what areas?
  • Overall, what do the pieces tell me about the artist?


Still confused?


If you need more inspiration and guidance, be sure to check out these comments!

----
comments.deviantart.com/20/560…

comments.deviantart.com/20/673…

comments.deviantart.com/20/640…
----

----

Active Groups



303.noobpinky, AgentLema, jessatriestodoart ((Started 04/11)

304.Lindariel-Erulasse, Lilia-DeRosso, ToddNTheShiningSword ((Started 04/11)

Completed



296. :bulletpink:EXTENSION - March 4th -StormPawz, jessatriestodoart, Cranky-Tanky ((Started 02/19, Ended 03/06)

297. BlackUranus, ToddNTheShiningSword, :bulletpink:EXTENSION - March 8thHerbyFox ((Started 02/25, Ended 03/06)

298. MsSexyBetsy, :bulletyellow::bulletred:EXTENSION - March 8thCrazyAceking, littledeadybear ((Started 02/26, Ended 03/12)

299. :bulletblue::bulletred:paradoxOX, Indra1408, radijad ((Started 03/04, Ended 03/27)

300. Brotienshake, StormPawz, DragonessAnimations ((Started 03/11, Ended 03/19)

301. Extremely-Soft-Void, radijad, DakotaMarvel ((Started 03/25, Ended 04/03)

302. jessatriestodoart, Ravimishra085, Dj-Edi ((Started 03/30, Ended 04/01)

Archive for older finished groups 1 - 290
Archive for finished groups 290+


Comment helpers: :bulletorange:Vixse, :bulletgreen:EshiSnu:bulletyellow:Dj-Edi, :bulletblue:GiraffeMeow
Add a Comment:
 
:icontoddntheshiningsword:
ToddNTheShiningSword Featured By Owner Edited 23 hours ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I'm sorry, but I'm having a problem... ^^;

Normally, as you might know by now from what I've been doing on here, I give really good Comments to go with my overly specific questions, but this time, I just can't. I'm sorry. :surrender:
I should have tried this earlier, rather than wait until the last minute to tell you, but I've looked again and I'm sorry. I'm gonna have to pull out. :surrender:

I'm in over my head. The artists that I've been paired with are simply too advanced, and their questions are too technical for me to be able to help them. I don't know what to do since I've already received Comments from both of them, but I can't give any back. I need to drop out of this round. I'm sorry.

These Lilia and Lindariel need to be pair with professional artists. Me, if I'm ever allowed to do this again, I really need to be paired with beginners, and will remember to specifically request beginners or people with non-technical questions. 

:surrender: :forgiveme: Maybe I can ask them for more novice-friendly questions, but that won't do either of them a service because they wouldn't be getting the answers they were actually looking for. Forgive me. :forgiveme:

ADDITION: I'm going to cave in differently and try asking them for different questions. Easier ones, as there's no way I can answer the ones they have. Those ones are simple to understand, but they're too hard for me. :cry:
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Apr 11, 2019
Lindariel-Erulasse, Lilia-DeRosso, and ToddNTheShiningSwordyou are group #304! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconlilia-derosso:
Lilia-DeRosso Featured By Owner Apr 11, 2019  Student Traditional Artist
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 6 days ago
Fantastic! Thank you!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Apr 11, 2019
noobpinky, AgentLema, and jessatriestodoart, you are group #303! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconagentlema:
AgentLema Featured By Owner 5 days ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I have finished both of my comments.
Reply
:icontoddntheshiningsword:
ToddNTheShiningSword Featured By Owner Apr 8, 2019  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I'd like to go again.
Same bat time. :batman:
Same bat Folder: :spotlight-left: :www.deviantart.com/toddntheshi… :spotlight-right: :XD:

1. What is the biggest flaw you see in my characters?
2. What is the smallest flaw you see?
A character's coat? A button on the coat? Comment on whatever is easiest for you, but the smaller the detail, the better. Once you've picked a detail to point out, don't forget to look at other drawings of the character so you can see if the flaw is old and cemented, freshly fixed, or a newly introduced flaw.
3. Do you know anyone that teaches character design that I could go to for advice? I have a little bit of money, so I can save up if it isn't free.
4. Which character is your favorite, and why?
5. Are there any specific things you think I should reference to help me improve these characters' designs? Oftentimes I can't find good references because I don't know what the things I'm imagining are called, or know the names of characters or people that wear them, so I don't know what to type into Google to get pictures to study. It took me a long time to realize, for example, that the big guy on the right in all the lineups, who is wearing spiky pants, was supposed to be wearing "aviator pants", and now that I know that, I can stop drawing them weird.
Reply
:iconlilia-derosso:
Lilia-DeRosso Featured By Owner Edited Apr 8, 2019  Student Traditional Artist

I'm interested in hearing:
1. What are the weakest and strongest works in this section? Why would you say so?
2. Which of the styles you can see in my pieces do you think are the best in terms of execution? Which style do I need to work on to improve?
3. What is the overall effect of my pieces, do they look good on display together?
Reply
:iconlindariel-erulasse:
Lindariel-Erulasse Featured By Owner Edited Apr 7, 2019  Student
www.deviantart.com/lindariel-e…

I’d like to know:
• How I can improve
• How I can present my artwork better. (Editing, photography, etc)
• My general strengths and weaknesses 
Reply
:iconjessatriestodoart:
jessatriestodoart Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2019  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I'd like to do another one of these :D

Questions:
General overview?
What would you like to see more of from me?
What are some things you like about my art?
What are some things I could work on?
Reply
:iconagentlema:
AgentLema Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2019  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
My questions
1. I simply want to know what my strengths and weakness are?
2. I would also like some advice on how to improve said weaknesses
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 30, 2019
jessatriestodoart, Ravimishra085, and Dj-Edi, you are group #302! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconravimishra085:
Ravimishra085 Featured By Owner Mar 31, 2019  Student Digital Artist
 hi 

i placed my comment on www.deviantart.com/dj-edi/gall…

but please extend some time for the other...
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Apr 1, 2019
I got the second one from the note you sent, thank you!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Apr 1, 2019
Wonderful, thank you!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Apr 1, 2019
Great, thank you!
Reply
:icondj-edi:
Dj-Edi Featured By Owner Mar 27, 2019  Hobbyist General Artist
I'd like to join if it's okay. 

Here's the folder:
www.deviantart.com/dj-edi/gall…

My questions:

1. What do you think about my art style? Do you like it? If not what can I improve to make it better? If yes what about it you liked the most? 
2. Pick the weakest artwork from this folder. What made you think it's worse than the other?
3. How does my artworks look like next to each other? Is the overall look of my gallery fine or is it too 'messy'?
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2019
Extremely-Soft-Void, radijad, and DakotaMarvel, you are group #301! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconextremely-soft-void:
Extremely-Soft-Void Featured By Owner Apr 2, 2019  New Deviant Hobbyist General Artist
Hey, sorry I was late. My comments are Here and Here
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Apr 3, 2019
No worries, thank you for getting them to me! :D
Reply
:iconradijad:
radijad Featured By Owner Mar 31, 2019  Student Digital Artist
My first comment is here and my second is here. Thanks for waiting!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Apr 1, 2019
Awesome, thank you!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 30, 2019
Great, thank you!
Reply
:iconravimishra085:
Ravimishra085 Featured By Owner Edited Mar 23, 2019  Student Digital Artist
hi i also want to sign up ..  previously i got some nice reviews by this channel .. i hope i can find some more people with similar positive and constructive attitude with my work
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2019
Added to the waiting group!
Reply
:iconravimishra085:
Ravimishra085 Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2019  Student Digital Artist
thank you ...
Reply
:iconjessatriestodoart:
jessatriestodoart Featured By Owner Mar 22, 2019  Hobbyist Digital Artist
www.deviantart.com/jessatriest…
Hey, I'd like to do another one of these :D
Questions:
General evaluation?
What things would you like to see more of from me?
Are you interested in my OCs and my Maggie Olsen comics? Would you want to keep reading (I know I only have 2 episodes out lol)?
Do you think my art is good for my age (14) or am I behind?
Thanks :D
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2019
Added to the waiting group!
Reply
:iconjessatriestodoart:
jessatriestodoart Featured By Owner Mar 26, 2019  Hobbyist Digital Artist
thanks!!
Reply
:icondakotamarvel:
DakotaMarvel Featured By Owner Mar 22, 2019  Student Writer
Which part of the piece did you like the most?
Where could I improve?
How did it make you feel?
Overall, what do the pieces tell you about the me?
What kind of work would you like to see me do in the future?
www.deviantart.com/dakotamarve…
Reply
:iconradijad:
radijad Featured By Owner Mar 21, 2019  Student Digital Artist
I’d like to go again (I am already in an active group but both of my comments have been submitted) the page I’d like evaluated is my gallery here .
my questions are below, (keep in mind when answering them not to worry about hurting my feelings, the truth is more important to me)
1. what do you like and what do you dislike about my art?
2. which of my pieces is my best and which is my worst? Why?
3. what areas can I improve in?
4. what do you think about my use of color? Any suggestions?
5. what do you think about my character designs? Any suggestions?
Reply
:iconnoobpinky:
noobpinky Featured By Owner Mar 21, 2019  Hobbyist General Artist
I'd love to try! 

For the last 5 drawings in my featured gallery: www.deviantart.com/noobpinky/g…, (I also have my recent doodle in scraps, but I'm not sure if that is included ... if it is, please comment on that ><: test doodle ~ girl)

:bulletred: Which 2 drawings are your favorite, and why?
:bulletred: Which techniques should I implement in that art, how can I improve?
:bulletred: What stands out about those drawings, if anything?
:bulletred: Any thing else to comment on?
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2019
If I provide your group with that link, they will be commenting on your entire featured gallery. If you only want the last 5/6 drawings to be reviewed for this group, please make a folder with just those drawings in it to submit to your group members. Otherwise, if you don't mind getting your comments made on the entire folder, I can go ahead and use the link you gave me.
Reply
:iconnoobpinky:
noobpinky Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2019  Hobbyist General Artist
Ah, ok! ;; ^^

Please comment on the deviations this folder ~ www.deviantart.com/noobpinky/g…

Bullet; Red Which 2 drawings are your favorite, and why?
Bullet; Red Which techniques should I implement in that art, how can I improve?
Bullet; Red What stands out about those drawings, if anything?
Bullet; Red Any thing else to comment on?

Thank you!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 30, 2019
Added to the waiting group! :)
Reply
:iconnoobpinky:
noobpinky Featured By Owner Mar 30, 2019  Hobbyist General Artist
^^
Reply
:iconextremely-soft-void:
Extremely-Soft-Void Featured By Owner Mar 21, 2019  New Deviant Hobbyist General Artist
Green Pumpkin I would love to hear some opinions on this

My Gallery: www.deviantart.com/extremely-s…

My Questions:
1) What could I do to improve on detail, rendering, and coloring¿ 
2) What about my art stands out to you and why¿ (good or bad)
3) What can I do to make my art have more originality and thicker atmospheres¿ 
4) What do you think I'm best at¿
5) What do you think I'm worst at¿ 
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 11, 2019
Brotienshake, StormPawz, and DragonessAnimations, you are group #300! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconstormpawz:
StormPawz Featured By Owner Mar 18, 2019  Hobbyist General Artist
Procrastination is my worst enemy but Im glad I got these done because I enjoyed it very much as always, thanks for the chance to get the amazing feedback <3
Brotien: www.deviantart.com/comments/20…
Dragoness: www.deviantart.com/comments/20…
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2019
Wonderful, thank you!!
Reply
:iconbrotienshake:
Brotienshake Featured By Owner Mar 15, 2019  Professional Artisan Crafter
Here are mine! 

DragonessAnimations: 
www.deviantart.com/comments/20…

StormPawz: 

www.deviantart.com/comments/20…
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Mar 18, 2019
Wonderful, thank you!
Reply
:icondragonessanimations:
DragonessAnimations Featured By Owner Mar 12, 2019  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Alright, here's my comments!
Broteinshake:
www.deviantart.com/comments/20…
StormPawz:
www.deviantart.com/comments/20…
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×

:iconprojectcomment: More from ProjectComment


Featured in Collections

Features, journals and poetry by moppiwolf

Journals by Chazing-Dreams

ProjectComment by cholie


More from DeviantArt



Details

Submitted on
June 9, 2016
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
50,007 (1 today)
Favourites
176 (who?)
Comments
4,118