Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
Welcome to ProjectComment's Gallery at a Glance! If you sometimes feel a little lost on your artistic journey, if you would like a fresh pair of eyes to help you pinpoint where your strengths and weaknesses are, or if you would just like to know the impression that your art leaves on other viewers, come join us for a round (or two)! :la:

Please Note!


:bulletgreen: This is for Visual Art only.
:bulletgreen: You must give two 100 word comments.
:bulletgreen: You will not be receiving comments on specific pieces, but the ENTIRE gallery folder/page.


Sign Up

  1. Choose a folder or page from your gallery that you would like to have evaluated. There should be a minimum of 5 pieces in the folder you choose.
  2. Reply to this journal with a link to your chosen folder or page.
  3. Include any specific questions you would like to have answered - 5 questions maximum.


How This Works

  1. Once you have signed up, KokoKiero will sort you into a group.
  2. Once your group has 3 members signed up, KokoKiero will send you a note prompting you to constructively comment on each of your two group members' galleries. Any questions your group members have for you will be stated in the note. Click on your group members' names in the note to be brought to their gallery or folder and get started! :la:
  3. Comments must be 100 words of constructive deviation-related content, minimum. Group members' questions and your introduction do not count towards this word limit.
    :note: Your comments will not be accepted if they are under 100 words.
  4. Finished commenting? Reply to this journal with a link to your comment. FAQ #14: How do I create a link to a specific comment?


:note: Deadline: Make your comment within 7 days of receiving your note!

If you need an extension, please note KokoKiero as soon as possible. If you do not comment, you will not be signed up again until these comments are made.


Plain Gray Divider by neripixu Plain Gray Divider by neripixu Plain Gray Divider by neripixu


Constructive Commenting?

While we expect these comments to be constructive in order to help artists' growth, we also want to help artists see what their viewers are seeing. Tell your group members your first impressions, thoughts, and feelings. Look for general strengths, weaknesses and themes, and offer your insight on how you see their art evolving and changing. Take note where the artist is heading, and try to help them improve on the areas that they are working within. Feel free to use specific examples, and refer to pieces and tutorials in order to make sure that the artist knows what you're talking about!

Questions to keep in mind when commenting:
  • How has the artist improved? In what areas?
  • What overall impression do I get? What themes do I see?
  • What are they good at? Are they good at telling stories? Are they good at experimentation? Are they good at making one piece flow into another?
  • Are there similar issues in several pieces? What are they and how could the artist improve?
  • Are there similar colour schemes or compositions used throughout the gallery? What other similarities and differences do you notice?
  • Overall, what do the pieces tell me about the artist?


Still confused?


If you need more inspiration and guidance, be sure to check out these comments!

----
comments.deviantart.com/20/560…

comments.deviantart.com/20/673…

comments.deviantart.com/20/640…
----


Active Groups



266. Imdraproc, :bulletred:RiceCakies, MooncatsAndSparrows (Started 10/25)

270. sketchkeepr6, :bulletpink: EXTENSION - November 20th -BellaGBear, AgentLema (Started 11/09)

271. Sukikmu, frankly-art, ToddNTheShiningSword (Started 11/09)

272. HeiwaMegami, Bunieo, AlexandraDahl (Started 11/10)

273. ArteNazrd

Completed



261. TheWizardAlchemist, :bulletpink: EXTENSION - Oct 17 NekoMaon, :bulletred:EXTENSION - Oct 6 incrediblekat619 (Started 09/26, Ended 10/18)

262. Giganotosaur314, ToddNTheShiningSword, 99SamPanda99 (Started 09/29, Ended 10/06)

263. Frogabond, soft-boyo-annyoin, HerbyFox (Started 10/5, Ended 10/13)

264. ScienceWithSteve, Bigmix505, frankly-art (Started 10/5, Ended 10/06)

265. artmyheart12, CatFace2405, Jorgipie (Started 10/11, Ended 10/15)

267. HaveFaithHopeLoveArt, starlit-kitten, ForeverEryn (Started 10/29, Ended 11/11)

268. NathaAmore, Thensil, AKira1189 (Started 10/29, Ended 11/04)

269. frankly-art, JubeiSpiegel, Animale38 (Started 10/29, Ended 11/01)


Archive for older finished groups


Comment helpers: Vixtri, Indra1408
Add a Comment:
 
:icontoddntheshiningsword:
ToddNTheShiningSword Featured By Owner 17 hours ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I wanna ride again already, :XD: so whenever the next batch of folks comes on, I'm game. :D

Again, the Character Lineups Folder . :)

1. I was surprised when I found out that my characters generally get a lot of negative reactions from people. Why do you think they do?
2. Which characters do you think are worst, and why?
3. Which characters are the most boring, and what would you do to make them a little more interesting?
4. Please pick one or more details from one of my newer character lineups that you notice and tell me about it. Please be specific. Examples, a character's hair, the top of their boots, an odd shaped forearm, eyes, etc.
5. Besides anatomy and coloring, what do I need to be studying and what cartoons should I look at for influence? 
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 3 days ago
HeiwaMegami, Bunieo, and AlexandraDahl, you are group #272! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are done.
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 4 days ago
Sukikmu, frankly-art, and ToddNTheShiningSword, you are group #271! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconfrankly-art:
frankly-art Featured By Owner 2 days ago  Hobbyist General Artist
Here are my comments! Thanks again for organizing this!

ToddNTheShiningSword
Sukikmu
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 3 days ago
Great, thank you!
Reply
:icontoddntheshiningsword:
ToddNTheShiningSword Featured By Owner 4 days ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I'm a little disappointed that I got somebody I already did, as I thought I'd get somebody at the top of the list, but it works out because I "did" that person informally so now I get to do them officially. :dummy: 
They were really cool, so this actually turns out really good, now that I think of it! :XD: :D 
I don't know how you worked that out. :iconyourockplz:
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 3 days ago
Ah, glad it worked out in the end! :D I only check over the list I have in this journal to make sure group members aren't repeating. 
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Edited 4 days ago
sketchkeepr6, BellaGBear, and AgentLema, you are group #270! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconsketchkeepr6:
sketchkeepr6 Featured By Owner 17 hours ago  New Deviant Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Here are links to my comments :
comments.deviantart.com/20/635…
comments.deviantart.com/20/659…

Thanks for organising it. :)
Reply
:iconagentlema:
AgentLema Featured By Owner 3 days ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Second comment reply. 

www.deviantart.com/sketchkeepr…
Reply
:iconagentlema:
AgentLema Featured By Owner 3 days ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Here is the link to my first comment. 

www.deviantart.com/bellagbear/…
Reply
:iconartenazrd:
ArteNazrd Featured By Owner 5 days ago  Professional General Artist
i join
question1 what do you think about my art?
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 4 days ago
It looks like your comment got cut off. Did you only have the one question (what do you think about my art) to submit?
Reply
:iconartenazrd:
ArteNazrd Featured By Owner 4 days ago  Professional General Artist
yes i only have one question
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 3 days ago
Added to the waiting group!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 3 days ago
Okiedokie, just making sure! :D
Reply
:iconartenazrd:
ArteNazrd Featured By Owner 3 days ago  Professional General Artist
okay
Reply
:iconthetwowteam:
TheTWOWTeam Featured By Owner 6 days ago  New Deviant Hobbyist Digital Artist
I join.
RFTF - Fan Art by TheTWOWTeam
Questions:
1. What do you think of this?
2. How does this compare to other stuff you seen?
3. How have I improved?
4. How does the technique look?
5. How should I improve
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Edited 4 days ago
For this project, you don't submit just one piece of art. If you'd like to sign up for Gallery at a Glance, I need a folder or your gallery page. If you want comments on this piece you would have to go to one of the other events (like Comment Tag) or the general gallery. 
Reply
:iconthetwowteam:
TheTWOWTeam Featured By Owner 4 days ago  New Deviant Hobbyist Digital Artist
Ok
Reply
:icontoddntheshiningsword:
ToddNTheShiningSword Featured By Owner 6 days ago  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
MY FOLDER : www.deviantart.com/toddntheshi…

1. For as many of the individual characters in my big character lineup drawings as you're willing to do this for, please describe my characters to me.
What do you think about each one?

2. What, exactly, makes you think each one has the traits you think they do, and how could I make each character's purpose or personality more clear?

3. Some parts of some of these designs are lacking because I didn't know what to type into google to get references. Are there any hairstyles, clothing types, design techniques, specific characters or other things that I don't seem know the names of that you could name for me so I know what to look up?

4. If any of my characters (in the character lineups) remind you of a character from media or another artist, please tell me the character! 

5. If you were in charge of some of these characters, what specific changes would you, personally make to them to improve them, or how would you have designed them differently?
Reply
:iconheiwamegami:
HeiwaMegami Featured By Owner 6 days ago  Hobbyist General Artist
I would absolutely love to join!

Link: www.deviantart.com/heiwamegami…

Questions:
1. What do I need to improve on the most?
2. What aspects have been executed well within the piece?
3. What sets my art apart from others?
4. Which piece do you dislike the most and why?
5. Which piece do you like the most and why?
Reply
:iconalexandradahl:
AlexandraDahl Featured By Owner 6 days ago  Hobbyist General Artist
I'd love to join!
My art folder: www.deviantart.com/alexandrada…
My gallery: www.deviantart.com/alexandrada…

Questions: 
1. How appealing is my art?
2. Which is your most/least favorite artwork, and why?
3. What is the biggest issue you have with my art?
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 4 days ago
Quick question, would you like to use the 'just art' folder to sign up or your general gallery page?
Reply
:iconalexandradahl:
AlexandraDahl Featured By Owner 4 days ago  Hobbyist General Artist
Just art, please!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 3 days ago
Sounds good!
Reply
:iconstrenget:
strenget Featured By Owner Nov 7, 2018  New Deviant Student Artist
Hi all! I  am beginner of art. 
My gallery: www.deviantart.com/strenget/ga…

Questions:
1. Do you like my style?
2. What should I improve on?
3. You know the name of this style?

Thank you for your feedback! 
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner 4 days ago
2 pieces isn't quite enough for this event, there isn't really enough for your group members to get a grasp on your artwork. I'd ask for around 4-5, minimum. If you'd like to submit these for comments, you can always try the Quick Comments, Comment Tag, or our general gallery.
Reply
:iconsukikmu:
Sukikmu Featured By Owner Nov 7, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
I'll join as well if you don't mind ^^

Gallery: www.deviantart.com/sukikmu/gal…
(I thought of doing another, but this is the one I'm most active in so...)

Questions;
1. What do I need to work on the most?
2. What can I do to improve on that or in my general faults?
3. What's my art's trademart? Or in another words, what's the thing that makes it recognizable as my style unlike others?
4. Is there an overall repetitive theme in my art? Like what's your impression of it?
5. What's your favorite and least fav artwork in there and why?
Reply
:iconbunieo:
Bunieo Featured By Owner Nov 7, 2018  Student General Artist
I would like to see mine as well!

www.deviantart.com/bunieo/gall…

Questions:
1)How appealing is my art?
2)What should I improve on?
3)What is your most fave and least fave?
4)What am I good at?
5)How do my characters(OC's) look?
Reply
:iconfrankly-art:
frankly-art Featured By Owner Nov 7, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
I'd love to get some more feedback on my featured folder!

Questions:
1. What are some predominant features and themes you notice in my works?
2. Are there any areas that need improvement (e.g. in composition, color/shading, anatomy, etc.)?
3. Which piece is your least favorite and why?
4. Which piece is your favorite and why?
5. Given the subject matter of my artworks, what sorts of things would you like to see more of or expanded upon in my future works?
Reply
:iconagentlema:
AgentLema Featured By Owner Nov 7, 2018  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I would like to participate as well

Gallery: www.deviantart.com/agentlema/g…

Questions
1. Where is my biggest problem (Perspective, anatomy, dynamism, etc.)? 
2. How should I work to improve the problems in the last question?
3. How can I make my drawing more appealing?
4. What do I do well on my drawings? 
Reply
:iconbellagbear:
BellaGBear Featured By Owner Nov 5, 2018  Student Artisan Crafter
Hello! I would love to participate! This sounds like a great project.

My gallery is: www.deviantart.com/bellagbear/…

And specific questions:

1. What can I do to make this gallery more appealing for non-quilters? 

2. Do you see an overal theme / style element in my works?
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Nov 5, 2018
Added to the waiting group!
Reply
:iconbellagbear:
BellaGBear Featured By Owner Nov 5, 2018  Student Artisan Crafter
awesome thanks :D :highfive: 
Reply
:iconsketchkeepr6:
sketchkeepr6 Featured By Owner Oct 31, 2018  New Deviant Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Hello, I'd like to signup.

Link to my gallery is:
www.deviantart.com/sketchkeepr…

The questions are:
1.What kind of impression do you get from my art?

2.What is something I should improve on?

3. Do you have a favourite piece and what do you like in it?
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2018
Added to the waiting group!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Oct 29, 2018
frankly-art, JubeiSpiegel, and Animale38, you are group #269! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconfrankly-art:
frankly-art Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
All done! Thanks for linking me with a great group of artists!

JubeiSpiegel
Animale38
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2018
Wonderful, thank you! And I'm glad you enjoyed your group! :D
Reply
:iconjubeispiegel:
JubeiSpiegel Featured By Owner Oct 31, 2018   Digital Artist
Done!

comments.deviantart.com/20/673…
comments.deviantart.com/20/640…

Another great group, thanks again for the lovely experience! :dance:
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2018
You're very welcome, glad you had a good time. :D Always a pleasure!
Reply
:iconanimale38:
Animale38 Featured By Owner Oct 30, 2018  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
KokoKiero,
I've responded to and tried my best to comment on and critique, according to their questions, my group members. Not sure how to link to a specific comment, but, here are the galleries I replied to:
Hope this works and thanks for the opportunity!
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2018
Fantastic, thank you kindly! 
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Oct 29, 2018
NathaAmore, Thensil, and AKira1189 you are group #268! Please reply to this comment with links to your comments once you are finished.
Reply
:iconkokokiero:
KokoKiero Featured By Owner Nov 4, 2018
Wonderful, thank you!
Reply
:iconakira1189:
AKira1189 Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2018  Professional Digital Artist
Okay, so here are my comments as well ^^

NathaAmore  
Thensil
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×

:iconprojectcomment: More from ProjectComment


Featured in Collections

Features, journals and poetry by moppiwolf

Journals by Chazing-Dreams

ProjectComment by cholie


More from DeviantArt



Details

Submitted on
June 9, 2016
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
43,095 (7 today)
Favourites
162 (who?)
Comments
3,661