Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
Group Info Group Founded 9 Years ago Statistics 27,281 Members
717,297 Pageviews23,352 Watchers

Welcome to ProjectComment!

✔ We accept all artists and art! :love:

✔ Send your art to over 27,000+ members! :deviation:

✔ Get guaranteed constructive comments! :typerhappy:

✔ Don't need to be active, 24/7. :#1:

Support us and comment, comment, comment! :heart:

:note: How to Submit to Our Gallery

1. Give a constructive comment on deviation(s) in these folders:
2. Tell the artist how you found their art and why you are commenting!3. Link us to the deviation(s) you commented on here or here (private).

:lightbulb: Don't want to be notified of new submissions, but still want to comment? Join Weekly Commenting -- We bring the commenting to you (via Notes) once a week, every week!

Click here to view everything ProjectComment!
Visual Guide to ProjectComment by 3wyl ProjectComment InformationProjectComment has been an active comment group for 9+ years to give you the constructive comments you deserve!
We have many projects that encourage our awesome members to give and get comments. These projects involve workshops, features, contests, and, more importantly, systems that rely on interchange, inclusion and interaction.
It's not easy to give and get comments, but, with the many projects we have here, we hope you find something that works best for you.
If you have any questions, concerns, suggestions, or anything else, please do not hesitate to contact us!
Our Values
Our amazing admins and members give comments and get comments with the following values in mind:
…to restore balance – comment for comment, positive and negative, give and take.
…to accept all – every commenter, every art, regardless of skill or artist.

Make Mistakes! We're Happy to Help!

It's not easy to give and get comments, but, with the many projects we have here, we hope you find something that works best for you.

If you have any questions, concerns, suggestions, or anything else, please do not hesitate to contact us! :la:

July : Golden Words Award!

ProjectComment's Award: Golden Words
~ For July ~

Congratulations Funny-arts!

Funny-arts' contributions to the group have not gone unnoticed as members of ProjectComment and DeviantArt overall benefit from Funny-arts' thoughtful commentary and advice. Frequently featured in our series of Great Commenters articles, and as an awesome participant of our projects, we'd like to award this month to Funny-arts!

Thank you UszatyArbuz for creating this award for ProjectComment.

Random from Featured

Little Dew by Funny-arts Little Dew :iconfunny-arts:Funny-arts 15 12 Finished YCH: Trotting In The Forest by Funny-arts Finished YCH: Trotting In The Forest :iconfunny-arts:Funny-arts 7 4 Toybox`s New Life [Contest Entry + Collab] by Funny-arts Toybox`s New Life [Contest Entry + Collab] :iconfunny-arts:Funny-arts 10 5 Cookie by Funny-arts Cookie :iconfunny-arts:Funny-arts 7 2 Dare To Dream by Funny-arts Dare To Dream :iconfunny-arts:Funny-arts 7 8

More Exposure!

More Exposure #70

Consider commenting on these pieces as you may discover new favorite artists!

Clay Dinosaur Skull Sculpture by Gecko998
.:Battle of the Supers:. by Yoshifan1219
Arche' new model by Medral
Taemin- The Story of Light by cosmicbouquets
meet the artist by valentine135

Mature Content

The Death of Dia by MythDraws

Fiends by RavenLunae
[DCM Task] Divergent Timeline - Ribbon by arcane-alchymist
Flame by Nickelnicker
Friend OC Tag team by AbelothOfAzarath
mindfuck by Okkhe
Rodney by RoughArrowArtist
~Summertime~ by AtypicalParadigm
Welcome to Spacetime by A-D-R
LT-127 aka Light by monkeyfan250
Tom Nook Animal Crossing by kerobyx
Of Specters and Sorrows pg3 by Geist19
Buizle by VinnyComix
Sky -(-Fanart-)- by ITS-ALL-MY-ART
Big Boss - Metal Gear Solid Peace Walker by DarkIceXMK

Submit your deviations to our More Exposure folder for more exposure on our front page and a featured news article!
:pointr: Submission limit: 1 deviation/week

Past Articles: {#1, #2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #12 , #13, #14, #15, #16, #17, #18, #19, #20, #21, #22, #23, #24, #25, #26, #27, #28, #29, #30, #31, #32, #33, #34, #35, #36, #37, #38, #39, #40, #41, #42, #43, #44, #45, #46, #47, #48, #49, #50, #51, #52, #53, #54, #55, #56, #57, #58, #59, #60, #61, #62, #63, #64, #65, #66, #67, #68, #69, #70 }


Little Dew by Funny-arts
Finished YCH: Trotting In The Forest by Funny-arts
Toybox`s New Life [Contest Entry + Collab] by Funny-arts
Cookie by Funny-arts
No Constructive Comments
Character sheet - Cornelia Serpensius by Hikatsuke
Unity Zero doodle dump by Over-Zero
Ender Dragon - Minecraft by kerobyx
(Ascension Veil) Sekrai Teniba by Veryek
More Exposure
Neon by kolgarave
Mogel Filioro (REQUEST) by Multiple-Titlez
[G] Crazy = genius - SPEEDPAINT by Tolondraws
DEJ III - lack of self confidence by Hikatsuke
Thematic Commenting - Perspective
Demontiger by GuardianOfDawn
Spirit of nature by FlatObelisk
Rolling Sky by SkyImmortal
The Chess Fairy, page 9 by BrendanRizzo
Comment Guides
Questions Answered
Comment Memes
Past No Constructive Comments
Shizuko [OC] by Kayle1592
Glory by Amanmir
Past More Exposure
Big Boss - Metal Gear Solid Peace Walker by DarkIceXMK
Sky -(-Fanart-)- by ITS-ALL-MY-ART
Buizle by VinnyComix
Of Specters and Sorrows pg3 by Geist19
Comment and Art Contest - dAhub and PComment
Because 'Black and White' Is So Mainstream by Tuntalm

Gallery Folders

Visual Guide to ProjectComment by 3wyl
Give and Get 1 Comment, 6-7 Lines
Popity Topity you've been Deceivety by Shamanique
Old Redraw by 3Circles
Courage the Cowardly Dog by NinjaWoodpeckers91
Milkshake Mermaid by Tinkalila
Give and Get 2 Comments, 6-7 Lines
Outside the cup by ForsThenebriss
Full Armor 3 by Kayserend
Standard Line Reverse by ToddNTheShiningSword
There's Something In The Water by Seeeks
Give and Get 1 Comment, 7+ Lines
Milo-Element of Fire by LoftyDreams
Remembrance pg 25 by Untraceablemystic

Mature Content

Small Jeyawue Contest by AdventVoice
Miku Miku Starry Day by Momo-The-Unknown
Give and Get 2 Comments, 7+ Lines
Req - Lady Skyla by Frozen-Sol
Req - Lady Sabrina by Frozen-Sol

Mature Content

Train scene: Posing for the boss by Enerla
Standard Line Reverse by ToddNTheShiningSword
:constructive: by a-kid-at-heart
Lil'comment by Amarantheans
Constructivecomment by Amarantheans
:Constructive: by stuck-in-suburbia
Other Submissions
Something Epic is coming this way by Cupric
Danny x Sam Love Quote by ShadowxKukiku
Ryu-sei by Dracocanust
Past Shorter, 1 Comment
The Kaiser by ProtoTEnterprise
Sandra reads ebook by lionclaw1
Cereza Mapleseed by UndeadSentinel
Hamburger Girl by mchoi14
Past Longer, 1 Comment
Argenta the White/the Seer by TeamStormbow
Eyeball Kid by CivilianNo867
Study based on Araki, Johnny Joestar (colored) by GiraffeMeow

Mature Content

Maggie McNeill in  the Goldfinch State by AdventVoice
Past Shorter, 2 Comments
Steve (kinda redraw/ref sheet) by StarSketchMEH
Nier Automata 2B by DarkmoonOtaku21
Demon Girl -- Annabeth by kmkibble75
The Last Guardian Trico (custom art doll) by Tedimo
Past Longer, 2 Comments
When you got to sneeze... by DoubleDandE
Past Submissions - 2016
Crossbow Taser by Charlene-Art
Past Submissions - Prior 2016
FREE dA logo Avatar by SirCassie
Give one (or many) constructive comment(s) today and you may be the winner of some awesome prizes, including thousands of :points: up for grabs!

Contest Begins: Saturday 14th July
Contest Ends: Tuesday 31st July, Midnight Pacific Time
:dalove: Help spread the word of our Big Comment Contest and the 3000 :points: up for grabs!

Comments must be constructive and relevant to the artist:
  • Constructive: Useful comments to help artists improve! Don't just focus on the positive or negative, strengths or weaknesses - include both, expand your reasons on the why and how, offer suggestions for improvement, guide the artist!
  • Relevant: Specific details, specific to the artist, their skill level and artwork overall!


:bulletgreen: Constructive and relevant comments must only be made on the pieces featured in this article to count.

:bulletgreen: We are looking for quality and quantity to determine the winners of this contest. It's in your best interest to post brilliant comments, as many comments as you can!

:bulletgreen: Mention you are commenting on behalf of this contest / ProjectComment in your comments. To do so...
  • Use our emoticons ~ During commenting, Add Media Button, Type ProjectComment
    :Constructive: by stuck-in-suburbia Supportcomment by Amarantheans :constructive: by a-kid-at-heart
  • Use Group Links - : devprojectcomment: (without the space in front of the colon)

:bulletgreen: Given loads of comments? Copy and paste the link to each deviation you've commented on in a reply to this journal! Batches of links are preferred.

Only Comment on Artwork Featured Here!

10 Points

Genesis According to the Lir, Part TwoCHAPTER THREE: The Fall
Now in this time the World had come to be fully explored, save for one small island, upon which stood a lone tree. And God had made it clear to His Children that the fruit of this Tree was forbidden to them, for its’ potential was beyond their understanding and would bring them harm. And there was a sadness behind His words which they could not understand.
Their curiosity and desire to learn kept them coming back to look upon the Tree and study its fruits, even so far as to climb upon the island and peer closely at the fruits thereon. But they kept God’s counsel and touched it not. And Lucian looked upon them with fire in his soul.
For many a year had Lucian held his own counsel. But in the fullness of time he sought the thoughts of his equals: Michael, Gabriel and Uriel. And he made his argument, but was rejected. For the other angels had come to love the Seven and would see them prosper.
But not all. And Lucian found in them his followers bu
Fever in the Fire Chapter 1: Welcome to Astola     Cynthia stepped gingerly inside the cave, wincing every time a footstep was loud enough to echo. No other noises reached her ears save her own, but she wasn't taking any chances. Reports had reached her town that a dragon was living in the nearby Riryoku mountains, and she'd volunteered to deal with it, peacefully or otherwise.
    Though Heaven knew they'd have preferred it, coexistence with a dragon was utterly impossible. People that lived too near to their resting places had reported as much. Livestock went missing. Convoys were attacked. Villages and towns burned down without warning. And there was nothing anyone could do about it. The dragons were simply too powerful. Yet to her dismay, the progress of humanity depended on keeping them docile. It was an eternal Damocles Sword hanging over their heads. After all, what did morality and empathy matter when you could fell a forest with a single roar?
    She shook her head and went fu
The Nation of Mystery Chapter 2The Galley known as the Swift Maiden swifty cut through the waves of the Great Sea. Its three massive sails billowing with the southern winds that took it back to New Trisos. It was was the flagship of the Madrilian Fleet stationed in Pinowa, so it only made sense for General Diego Legazpi to use it as his unofficial command center on the return trip from the island of Aterb.
He hunched down on his desk, frowning deeply as he started to write down his reports of the recent campaign. He didn't bother glancing up from the paper as the other pens and papers started to slide off his desk. Instead he only reached out only to grab the bottle of ink which nearly tipped over as the ship tilted from the waves and placed it on them as a paper weight
He wrinkled his face in annoyance as he wiped sweat from his bros and continued to work on his reports. Diego sighed and rubbed his eye together. Each word that came out from his pen fanned the frustration burning inside of him. Judging by the loud t
Nation of Mystery Chapter 1Juan Sevilla leaned forward on the deck rail of the ferry. He tried to peer around the horizon for any sign of land. Despite the morning mist that crept over the water like a bride's veil, he was able to make out the silhouettes of the white rock cliffs of the Bravatinian coast.
He turned his gaze down towards his suitcase to make sure that the briefcase that contained his entire life savings and other personal effects was still at his side.
A gust of cold wind caused him to pull his frock coat tighter. He wished that he had brought his woolen greatcoat with him, but that was probably still sitting on his bed back in New Trisos. Juan knew the northern kingdom would be colder than the tropical town he grew up in, but not this cold. But such was the cost when the harbor was an hour carriage ride and you overslept.
Juan let out a few brisk breaths, seeing a white cloud blow out of his lips caused him to tug at his coat. He failed to notice another passenger making his way towards him.
The Wolf, the Machine, and the Child part 1
A steel hook thrust into the icy cliffside wall held the bearer safe from falling. Perilous winds beat at his thick cloak as he contorted his body, enabling him to reach upward and stick the other metal tool in the ice, far above the past tool’s mark.
A strong howling blizzard raged through the mountain range, creating a difficult climb up the cliffside ice. The climb was too early. In any other circumstance he would have waited it out, but the broken hull of a crashed ship couldn’t provide enough protection, nor would be a good place to set up a warm flame. The cave entrance above had proved a promising sight before the storm hit.
The cloaked figure turned to attempt a view of the surface below, the ship he had come from, or even anything for that matter. An odd sense had struck him, as if there was something else climbing the mountain. But nothing was visible except the air, rent with millions of little white flecks of ice passing by at dangerous speeds, and his white pan
Star Wars: The Old Republic - Mysterious Ways CH1
Disclaimer: It goes without saying, but I'm saying it because I have to: I do not and probably never will own Star Wars. Credit to Lucas and his team- plus all the book writers. I only own my own characters (for now: Darth Logaar, Darth Quienne, Captain Cavi Mieha, Colonel Canderode Lorick, Kajtie Fysyr, Agent Haraldt, Thuly, Master Lao'na Lalyr) which are based on the already existing universe.
Star Wars: The Old Republic
Mysterious Ways
Chapter I: Rivals
A long time ago in a galaxy far,
far away…
The Emperor is dead! After the successful assassination, done by a handful of Republic heroes, the Empire lies in ruins. Disorder reigns among the Sith. The news about the death of their unifying leader strengthened their already tense internal struggles, drifting their Order to the edge of chaos. The Dark Council is trying to maintain the semblance of a stable leadership, b

Mature Content

ego logistics by delphifilm
Ahlacia and Rowan, first meeting (I.S.O.A) He could smell it, the fresh meat roasting way back in the kitchens. The scent was like some giant animal pushing its way through a crowded street, carelessly shunting all the rivals who vied for space on the cramped battlefield. Its effort's not withstanding, Rowan could smell the other things it so forcefully suppressed, a variety of secondary foods as well as numerous drinks. Lastly and most prominently, he could smell a strange, spiced scent that arose from various dispensers scattered around the room. What he did not smell were the scents he'd expected to find upon entering this rather disreputable building, namely sour sweat, stagnant air and spilled beer that belonged to the exceptionally cheap variety.
  Rowan sighed and sat back in his chair, once again searching the dinning room for the unsavory men he felt certain lurked in some back corner just waiting to spring out and start fighting, possibly hard enough to kill someone. As before, however, the most dangerous t
By Brendan Rizzo
Yomi entered the classroom and stood in front of the students. He had just transferred schools, and thus had to stand there for a few minutes while the teacher introduced him to the class. He resisted the urge to just stare off into space. The room was boring, the teacher’s voice just droned on and on, and none of the students he could see in front of him had any features to distinguish them from one another, not counting gender. It was as if they were all bit characters in an anime, who served no purpose except to fill out the room in the background. So he let his mind wander, while still taking care to make it look like he was paying attention. That crack on the back wall looked interesting; it would be a good way to keep his focus on one place while at the same time ignoring what was being said. How much more time could the teacher possibly spend on introducing him?
“…and anyway, it looks like you can have a seat over there, right in fro
[ENG] UT minicomic - Lunch time by Thelightsmen WIP background previews PART 2 by Thelightsmen There's Always Time to Antagonize Papyrus by StephOBrien The Best-Laid Plans (Undertale genocide spoilers) by StephOBrien Commission: Naruto finds the Mask part 5 by EduartBoudewijn Commission: Naruto finds the Mask part 3 by EduartBoudewijn Undertale Wallpaper: Lightning Ninja Alphys by StephOBrien Rising Dusk Reference Sheet (Commission) by MagerBlutooth Commission: Hermione gets mad part 3 by EduartBoudewijn Commission: Hermione gets mad part 2 by EduartBoudewijn Collaboration: Asami Horse TF part 4 by EduartBoudewijn Art Trade: Fan Meet by DoubleDandE Morning Armadillo (Commission) by DoubleDandE Sketch Commission: Cherry and Cheona Selfie Time by DoubleDandE Print-On-Demand: Abstract Threads, Rainbow Series by StephOBrien Volunteers needed by Peace-In-Violence Birthday 4 Dazzle by MagerBlutooth Sho's Journey (non-canon): A Mother's Love by dviouslecunning Art Trade: Amooora meets the Mangog by EduartBoudewijn Ross And Greta V2 by Seeeks Miguel- character development by FelicityAnnora The spider in the sky by Glowingcandies Animation Stills! by ghostlyCavalier Howie by AlecxHound   Call me ''Your Majesty'' by Black-Chimaera Sketch Commission: Kayla and F'waiya in Leather by DoubleDandE Denied by DoubleDandE Mentalism by Aya-DNA Regret - navigation by ArtOfJuly Afternoon Sunbathing by KokoKiero Julie by littledeadybear [AT] Look, I caught it ! by Funny-arts Terminator Bear 2: Judgement Day by DoubleDandE Evil Queen by DoubleDandE [AT] Ride all day long by Funny-arts Sunset Shimmer PageDoll by Funny-arts Taking time to relax by Mountny Experiment in Ink Wash: Algernon and Ishuram by Hestia-Edwards

Mature Content

Rage2.0 by AdventVoice
You Shouldn't Have! No, Really, You Shouldn't Have by StephOBrien Comic Test by Indra1408 Grimwag by MaggiefromSpace Jellyfish by R3M3DY1215 Death and Pain by MiniDemons  Brull by Mmatt0904

5 Points

Even Small Creatures Dream by Indra1408 The Elephant by ThePurpleGriffin Healthy Foods-In My Style by Indra1408 Sorey and Mikleo Tales of Zestiria Fanart by GiraffeMeow I don't wanna leave by BDOG375 Characters by SilverMuttt BACK TO SCHOOL 02 03 by kikoeart The Grotto by ArtlessDesigns X Shadow Armor by Thelightsmen Gunner glitch by Alexavier870 Sho's Journey: Making Friends? by dviouslecunning Undertale height chart by Thelightsmen Twilight by Indra1408 Profile: Kressa by Mountny Curious Little Thing by dviouslecunning Demonette Maeve by Alexavier870 Cavetown - Meteor Shower (SPEEDPAINT) by ghostchiryou [Houseki no kuni] Transformation by ColorfullyMonotone

Scoring & Judging

Pieces for you to comment on are grouped under separate point headings. So, if you post an amazing comment on a piece of art under the "10 Points" heading, you will get up to 10 points maximum! If you post an amazing comment on a piece of art under the "5 Points" heading, you will get up to 5 Points maximum!

Please note, this is a sliding scale. Those who comment with little/no effort will only get 1 point, not 5 / 10 points.

At the end, all points will be tallied up to determine the winners of this contest.


As you know, we have 3000 :points: up for grabs! Winners will receive a minimum of 1000 :points: each, while those who put in great effort may find themselves the recipients of some :points: too!

:note: Want to donate a prize?
Note ProjectComment now. We appreciate any and every support given! :la:

Final Note

  • :+devwatch: ProjectComment for updates on this contest.
  • This article is regularly updated with artwork! Once a piece has received a constructive comment, it will be removed from this article.
  • Comments made on behalf of this contest can't be used for group gallery submissions, but can be used for Nominate a Commenter + Win 100 Points!

Don't forget to link us to the deviations you've commented on in a reply to this journal!

We wish you all the best of luck and hope you have fun! If you have any questions, concerns, or anything else, please do not hesitate to contact us.

Thank you! :love:

More Journal Entries


Add a Comment:
DarkmoonOtaku21 Featured By Owner 1 hour ago  New Deviant Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Commented on this  Milkshake Mermaid by Tinkalila

I would like to submit  Lucy (Elfen Lied) by DarkmoonOtaku21   
BrendanRizzo Featured By Owner 9 hours ago  Hobbyist
Commented on  Milkshake Mermaid by Tinkalila  to submit  The Impractical Jokers by BrendanRizzo .
mirajanne00007 Featured By Owner Edited 10 hours ago  Student Traditional Artist
Commented on Sad Butterfly by RasheruSuzie
I would like to sumbit img090 - Copie by mirajanne00007   
Rebecca1208 Featured By Owner Edited 12 hours ago  Hobbyist General Artist
Thank you very much for the invitation! This does look like quite the interesting and helpful group. I will be checking this out in full detail tomorrow :)
(1 Reply)
xLeah7x Featured By Owner 13 hours ago  Hobbyist Interface Designer
Submitting Nothing, Commented On:
Milkshake Mermaid by Tinkalila

Full Armor 3 by Kayserend

Hamburger Girl by mchoi14
(1 Reply)
Add a Comment: