Site Header
Deviation Actions
Description
Honkai Impact 3rd vs Punishing: Gray Raven
Connections:
Both are powerful female characters from sci-fi, hack-and-slash gacha games made by Chinese game companies (miHoYo and Kuro Games respectively)
Both were created by a massive organization (Schicksal and Babylonia respectively) that deploy superhuman fighters (Valkyries and Constructs respectively) and led by their leaders (Otto Apocalypse and Hassen & Nikola respectively) for different purposes (Otto wanted to create a vessel that can harness the power of the Herrscher of the Void Sirin in the hopes of reviving Kallen Kaslana, while Babylonia created a new Lucia after the original one was infected and was pronounced dead by her former Commandant who betrayed her team)
Both were revealed to have been clones to the original one (Alpha being the original Lucia and Durandal being the original Kiana) whom they fought against several times and lost, though one of their fights ended in a stalemate. Eventually learning to accept their existence as a clone through fighting their "original versions" and to move on from their past, instead fighting for those they love
Both have fought against world-ending threats that exists from a higher plane of existence (The Honkai and the Punishing Virus respectively), in which its able to create various monsters (Honkai Beasts and Corrupted respectively) and capable of infecting people and granting them their powers (Herrschers and Ascendants respectively)
Both also formed a 4-person team (Squad V and Gray Raven respectively) alongside a kind-hearted daughter to a rich family (Raiden Mei and Liv respectively) and a serious and tech-savvy gun user (Bronya Zaychik and Lee respectively) led by a leader they cared for dearly (Himeko Murata and Commandant respectively)
Both also possess various forms (Battlesuits and Omniframes/Uniframes respectively) throughout the story), with one of their forms being white-themed and power over flames as well as having aerial moves (Herrscher of Flamescion and Pyroath respectively). They would also use that same form to defeat a powerful villain (Herrscher of Domination and Kurt Vonnegut respectively) who seeks to manipulate humanity for their own gains
Both are also terrible at being cooks
Additionally Rei Kugimiya, who is Kiana's Japanese VA, also voiced Luna who is the younger sister of Alpha and Lucia
Both their animated shorts (Everlasting Flames and Weaved Vow respectively) also shares many similarities. Both were overpowered and nearly defeated only to gain a new form and defeat the villains who'd create multiple shields only for them to break them effortlessly and ultimately kill them
Both also had music which relates to their past and the pain they go through to protect the ones they love (Moon Halo and Burning Vow respectively). Contrast is that Moon Halo feels triumphant whereas Burning Vow is similar to Nightglow which feels like a goodbye.
I know nothing about the other girl, but how strong is she? Kiana is like Hyperversal nowadays, so Lucia and her verse have to be broken as hell for this to be a compelling debate.







































