I'm a weirdo! I like both!
If I had to choose what to live with on an island stranded alone for the rest of my life, I would choose Star Wars mainly for the little reasons and I mean the little ones, the Ewoks, R2D2, those little cloaked figures, the robots, the creatures, YODA, etc. The old unedited version and probably not the 'new' first three, I like Leah and Luke and Han.
But I love the new Star Trek movies, the space ships, the sounds, the lights, the looks on Kirk's face (much like the looks on Han Solo's face but better sometimes) and who can't love the old Spock? So I like both.