Deviation Actions

PaulHanley's avatar

Ruth Wilson as The Doctor

Everyone's having fun throwing around their casting ideas for the 12th Doctor. Just for fun, I thought I'd go a step further and do a full-blown design for my pick. And to be 100% honest, maybe... just maybe, to get her name in the running along with the other Patterson Josephs, James Nesbitts, Chiwetelu Ejiofors, etc, etc- the people who actually have a chance at being the next Doctor (face it kids, it's not gonna be Colin Firth, Helen Mirren, or Hugh Laurie... and DEFINITELY not Benedict Cumberbatch- Doctor Who don't pay JJ Abrams money).

I remember saying to my buddy Robert Orndoff a couple years ago that I wasn't opposed to the idea of a female Doctor, but aside from some unlikely candidates like Tilda Swinton, I couldn't think of someone who'd just naturally fit the part like a Tom Baker or Matt Smith. He quickly replied "Ruth Wilson". I said, "Who?" So he told me to check out the (great) show LUTHER, and I immediately got what he was talking about. She's a truly strange and quirky screen presence that just screams "Doctor", and the show should get her before lousy Hollywood movies do (she's already in THE LONE RANGER- egads).

And since i'll never get to be the showrunner of Doctor Who myself (because the rest of you are crazy- I'm the only sane one- yes, me), here's a full-blown Wikipedia-style entry for "my" 12th Doctor (at least till this timeline gets erased on December 25th)... ;)


The Twelfth Doctor is the twelfth incarnation of the protagonist of the long-running BBC science fiction series DOCTOR WHO. She was portrayed by Ruth Wilson from 2013-2016. She is generally remembered as the "definitive" doctor of the second run of the series, and one of the most popular Doctors ever (at least until Olive McDonald's 15th Doctor supplanted her as "Favorite Doctor" in a 2042 Doctor Who Magazine poll, and fans started saying things like "Let's face it- everything before the third run was a bit crap.").

Already known for playing the brilliant-but-dangerous Alice Morgan on the BBC detective drama LUTHER (where she co-starred with former Doctor Paul McGann), Wilson's name was suggested by writer Neil Cross to DOCTOR WHO's production team. The 12th Doctor was conceived as being for the "modern" Doctors what Tom Baker 4th had been for the "classic" ones- a more alien, anarchic, and unpredictable take on the character- someone who would "shake things up a bit".

Much like the 11th Doctor was influenced by the 2nd, the character of #12 was something of a mashup of the 4th and 6th- an eccentric incarnation whose very sanity was often in question. She was one of the ruder, less easy-to-love Doctors, but also one of the most formidable ones. Or as The Radio Times described her, "Greg House from space".

The 12th Doctor's first adventure ("The Golden Ones", a story liberally adapted from a comic strip written for Matt Smith's Doctor) saw a battle-damaged TARDIS crash-down in 2014 Tokyo (marking the first time a Doctor's debut story had been filmed abroad since 1996). Battling an Axon invasion alongside Kate Stewart and UNIT, the Doctor crossed paths with Brian, a handsome British college student who was inadvertently caught up in Axos's plot to drain all energy on Earth. Spending much of the story in a "degenerate" state (as she cycled through her previous personalities, shades of the 5th Doctor in "Castrovalva") the unhinged, reckless Doctor seemed to be almost as much of a danger to her allies as the Axons. At the story's end, Brian looked set to join up as the new companion, but the Doctor absentmindedly slammed the TARDIS door in his face. Whispering to the console, "I'm not ready to share you yet," she tore off into the time vortex laughing maniacally (Brian never appeared in the series again).

Though her Doctor managed to have a small number of "solo" adventures (including a brief meeting with a very confused Jamie McCrimmon in the late 18th Century), she soon found herself grudgingly taking on companions again when fate reunited her with K-9 and Clyde Langer (an acquaintance of the 10th and 11th Doctors, and a protégé of former companion Sarah Jane Smith). In the second season, Jenny, the Doctor's long-lost "daughter", joined the TARDIS crew. Though the Doctor often complained about being saddled with responsibility for a family she "never asked for", it slowly become apparent she cared about them just as much as any previous Doctors would have. But the Doctor was clearly preoccupied with larger, secret matters she wouldn't share with the crew, and repeatedly sought to drop them off someplace "safe".

Through the first season the Doctor battled the Howlings, an enigmatic group of immortal (but intangible) beings who sought to "break" the Doctor in order to extract information about the Time War that only she remembered. Led by the mysterious Planck (recurring guest star David Bowie), the Howlings gave assistance to the Doctor's various enemies, including the Axons, the Celestial Toymaker, and "Word Lord" assassin Nothing Impossible (played by gust star Tim Minchin). In later seasons, Rassilon (Pierce Brosnan) became the "Big Bad", as the restored Timelord race (claiming to forsake the meddling that brought about the Time War) renewed the hunt for its renegade members who dared to "meddle" with the rest of creation. Ultimately Rassilon's quest for order caused him to forge an alliance with the Dalek Time Controller and a shadowy "Adversary" with a special interest in the Doctor. (THE REST OF THIS SECTION'S BEEN DELETED FOR SPOLIERS- ed.) ;)

The product of a particularly traumatic regeneration, the 12th Doctor often appeared to be unstable, possibly even a bit insane (even by the Doctor's standards). She was given to acute mood swings- charming one moment, shockingly rude (even misanthropic) the next. She didn't form bonds easily, and had little interest in companionship. Often a bit selfish and always in a rush, the Twelfth Doctor seemed more motivated than her predecessors to put the Universe to rights, and didn't have time for hurt feelings.

In her problem-solving, she was less the "Lonely God" or "Oncoming Storm" that her recent predecessors had been, resembling more a wily con artist who underplays her abilities. Many viewers theorized that her eccentric behavior was largely for show to make her opponents underestimate her - a "drunken boxer" of sorts. Noticeably more pragmatic (and arguably darker) in her handling of situations, she wasn't given to the speechifying of the Tenth and Eleventh Doctors, and seemed less bothered with notions of mercy or offering her opponents chances to recant their wicked ways.

Probably due to her "point of origin" the 12th Doctor had a special fondness for Japanese culture. This might have explained her love of karaoke, and why she installed a dedicated machine (and shipwide public address system) on the TARDIS console at one point (much to her companions' chagrin). Favorite standards included Badfinger's "Without You", The Human League's "Mirror Man", and "Gojira to Jaga-de Punch! Punch! Punch!"(from the 1973 film GODZILLA VS. MEGALON). She also had an enthusiasm for pachinko that seemed similar to the 5th's love of cricket. The Doctor used pachinko balls to sabotage machinery and trip up enemies on more than a few occasions. Possibly confusing her cultures, she also demonstrated a renewed interest in the martial art of Venusian Aikido- though her attempts to use it often garnered mixed results, and she was forced to admit she was "a bit rusty".

The Doctor's sudden change in gender was rarely referenced directly by the Doctor herself (though it was a frequent point of bafflement and awkwardness with old acquaintances). On one occasion when pressed on the matter, she said Timelords tended to "swing one way or the other, or both" from early on and that this sort of development so late in a Timelord's life was rare. She was heard to mutter "probably River's fault", possibly attributing the change to regeneration energy passed to her in her previous incarnation by River Song. She didn't seem to have any regrets about it, appearing instead to relish the chance to experience new things at an advanced age where she thought she'd seen everything.

The 12th Doctor's dress style somewhat recalled the 4th and 6th Doctors (though the production team cited Diane Keaton's title character from ANNIE HALL as the main point of inspiration). "In universe", the costume was influenced by fashions the 12th Doctor encountered in her "birthplace", Tokyo- most obviously in her "Hello Kitty" tie tack.

Claiming the rather large sonic screwdriver of the 11th Doctor didn't suit her new look ("Can you imagine what they'll say if they see this bulging in my vest pocket...? 'CAN'T ACCESSORIZE!'"), the 12th Doctor opted for a smaller "nano" model similar to the 2nd Doctor's original model. Though its functionality was more limited, the Doctor insisted (to her companions' frustration) that it was better because it kept her from "getting lazy and using it for any old rubbish".

Described as "Verity Lambert with a budget" the 12th Doctor's TARDIS had a bright, gleaming, and aggressively retro interior that called back to the Wiliam Hartnell era design (only on a grander scale and incorporating later hallmarks like the floor-to-ceiling time rotor). New rooms included an (inexplicable) opera house and a large pachinko parlor that the Doctor used for "meditation". Also seen on screen for the first time was the "Butterfly Room" originally mentioned in the 8th Doctor novel "Vampire Science"- which became a favorite place of Jenny's. The 8th Season finale also revealed the TARDIS's "catacombs" for the first time- a vast ancient stone labyrinth reminiscent of Piranesi's famous "Prison" etchings. This more ancient section of the TARDIS hid ancient Time lord artifacts and some of the Doctor's most closely-guarded secrets.

"Oh, that's a change. Ginger!" (First line- often used in variations when encountering old friends who comment on a noticeable change: "I know- ginger!" etc.)

"That doesn't work anymore, does it?" (Used in historical settings when deeply-entrenched sexism proves stronger than the persuasiveness of psychic paper.)

"Shut up, Clyde." (Substituted where other Doctors would have said, "I'll explain later.")

"Spack off!" (Frequent.)
Image details
Image size
896x948px 224.46 KB
© 2013 - 2021 PaulHanley
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
zaeemh's avatar

Ruth Wilson has always been 1# choice to play Romana (If she ever came back as long time TARDIS member), either her or Gemma Arterton. My choice for the Doctor is Matthew Goode or Cillian Murphy.

dcfan239's avatar

After the 1966 TV Movie, they'd filmed in Arizona for the Series 6 opening story, Day Of The Moon, Spain for Asylum Of The Daleks and A Town Called Mercy of Series 7A and New York City for Daleks In Manhattan, Evolution Of The Daleks (both from Series 3) and Angels Take Manhattan.

PaulHanley's avatar

"...marking the first time a Doctor's *debut story* had been filmed abroad since 1996..."

EmeraldKalEl268's avatar

Been wondering what you think of the show's own Ruth Doctor compared to your masterpiece? A few similarities after all.

PaulHanley's avatar
Yeah!  Well...the taste in eyewear at least. And that glorious TARDIS design is close to the vague image I had in my head when I wrote the description of her TARDIS (including the JJ-Abrams-esque flaring lights).  

Without getting into a LONG discussion about it, I'm very much onboard w/ whatever the heck this is (I stay far away from spoilers/ fan rumors/ etc, so that ep totally blindsided me). I love how much mystery the Doctor's suddenly gotten back, and it feels like anything could happen now.  
greendalek's avatar
Well, in a roundabout way we DID get a Ruth as the Doctor. :) Well done!
PaulHanley's avatar
RIGHT?  She's even got similar taste in eyewear.
Dim432's avatar
PaulHanley's avatar
Yep- this is why I left the comments on for this one.  Moments like this. :) 
InfoInternet13's avatar
You need to submit this to bbc
MrFireCowboy's avatar
I really wish that they could have alternate regenerations for fan-made doctors, maybe for one-offs in the comics or somewhere, because I would read the dalekanium out of this Doctor's adventures!
PaulHanley's avatar
I doubt the BBC would ever do it, but there's a lot to be said for doing an "unbound" alternate Doctor comic.  A giant problem of licensed spinoff comics is that you often can't do all that much with the characters b/c it has to fit into the TV/movie/whatever continuity.  It limits the moves you can make in a big way (or directs you toward increasingly-predictable courses of action like introducing a new companion and killing them, b/c that's one of the few options open to do something really shocking- that's why so many of the audio adventures companions are dead).  A lot of writers still manage to deliver great stories in those constraints, but at the end of the day... you know where it's mostly going.  

And yeah, I'd write the hell out of some stories for this Doctor.  I've never put that much energy into it (b/c... y'know... it'll almost certainly never happen and thus be a colossal waste of time), but there's a couple adventures for her that are mostly-formed in my head now, just b/c the idea of this Doctor has never quite gone away for me.  There's a cracking Cybermen story for her (with a concept I'm amazed no writer has ever tried with the Cybermen yet- it's something screamingly obvious) and another one that's a love letter to 60s Italian horror.  And I know the broad strokes of a larger three-season style plan for her. :)
MrFireCowboy's avatar
One interesting thing that I noticed is that this Doctor's personality as you described it seems strikingly similar to how Missy would end up. It would be an odd, but doable take to make the Doctor more like the Master, rather than vice versa. Following the adventures of someone completely crazy....well that's just Doctor Who sometimes.
You know what's funny? I'm running a Doctor Who RPG campaign right now, and the player who portrays the Doctor created a custom regeneration (alternative Nr. 13, long before Jodie was announced) that's also female, ginger and quite similar to your version, personality-wise. I really enjoy the fact that your mind wandered in similar directions to hers and I will show this to her so I can see what she says.
Kudos to you, and thanks for the wonderful art!
the doctor can be a girl!
PaulHanley's avatar
mambasnake's avatar
God, I hope the next Doctor is female. We need a change. And there's no reason it can't happen. 
PaulHanley's avatar
And now it has! :)
mambasnake's avatar
Yeah. How do you feel about that? It's been hinted at for years now, but people are so unfair to Jodie Whittaker. 
PaulHanley's avatar
Well... sadly I can't say it's surprising.  You'd expect a little better, given that it's one of the most open-minded, "progressive" and tolerant characters in modern fiction and there's literally no reason "in universe" that this wasn't an eventual near-inevitability.  When you look back at some old clips of folks like Troughton and Baker discussing regeneration in the 80s (when the Doctor was still relatively early in his regeneration cycle), they seemed to take it for granted that of course there would eventually be Doctors who weren't male and/ or white.  The obligation was on the naysayers to produce reasons why not- not the other way around.  So the idea that this is some recent "progressive" push is just, um... total rubbish. 

And the thing that's frustrating is it shouldn't even be a discussion about politics- it's an obvious giant area of potential stories that's been deemed off limits (btw... this is exactly how I feel about more Valeyard stories, too).  Well goddammit, just speaking as a writer- I want those levels unlocked! :D  Our show's tough- it doesn't break easily. 

I want them to take some real chances with the character.  I was so disappointed when Twelve's blindness was cured- a Doctor who was left permanently blind would be such an interesting thing!  Or bring back Jenny as a companion and let's see the Doctor deal with being a mom/ dad again!  Take some chances!  I feel a big reason the ratings have steadily declined is because the show keeps reverting to a "default" mode every few years where very little permanently changes (or if it does, they shy away from really examining the consequences).  I'm ready for one of those no-turning-back game changers like the first regeneration in '66 or when the Time Lords made their true debut in '69.  And the good news is that's happened now- the goalposts are permanently moved. And before she's even uttered a line of dialogue, Whittaker has my respect for just stepping up to do it in a time where we've seen how the internet handled things like the Ghostbusters reboot.
mambasnake's avatar
Diversity is a good thing when it comes to Doctor Who, and you're right - regeneration is a lottery where anything can happen. I mean, Lenny Henry was in a Doctor Who spoof, and he is a good actor who's capable of playing put upon characters who're down to Earth, or to whatever planet he's on. It's interesting that so early in its time actors like Tom Baker and Patrick Troughton discussed the diversity, but were basically shouted down by people who said the pattern should stay where it is. 
You're right that this is one of those no turning back moments, and we haven't seen one of this magnitude for a while - the Doctor receiving a new regeneration cycle was a basic one, but the potential for him becoming a woman and or black or another color was clear. I do respect Jodie Whittaker, and the BBC had just shot down those stupid complaints about how she couldn't be the Doctor because she's not a bloke.   
BoneSatellite's avatar
Great, you're one of those types. The Internet responded justly to the Ghostbusters reboot...and we all would've seen that response (criticizing the quality of the trailer, not the gender) if Sony hadn't deleted most of the comments that didn't fit their agenda, then stirred up more controversy via their marketing campaign. You know that, right?
PaulHanley's avatar
Calling Leslie Jones the n-word, sending her death threats and hacking her personal data was "responding justly"?

I wasn't a fan of the Ghostbusters reboot, but Christ on a bike it's only a fucking movie.  No wonder you hide behind an alias. Grow up.
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In