Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
About Other / Hobbyist Noelle SorensenFemale/United States Group :iconjob-offers: Job-offers
 
Recent Activity
Deviant for 8 Years
Needs Core Membership
Statistics 17 Deviations 16 Comments 1,325 Pageviews
×

Newest Deviations

Trumpsigns by noellecampbell Trumpsigns :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Rindbo by noellecampbell Rindbo :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Whenhoneymetlemonrind1 by noellecampbell Whenhoneymetlemonrind1 :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Narnia Panorama open and detail by noellecampbell Narnia Panorama open and detail :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Narnia Panorama by noellecampbell Narnia Panorama :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Armies of Helaman by noellecampbell Armies of Helaman :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 1 0 ModernMayan by noellecampbell ModernMayan :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Faith by noellecampbell Faith :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Swampfaye by noellecampbell Swampfaye :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 1 0 Mayan Heiroglyph by noellecampbell Mayan Heiroglyph :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Mayanwarrior1 by noellecampbell Mayanwarrior1 :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 1 0 Grecian Urn by noellecampbell Grecian Urn :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Where your treasure is... by noellecampbell Where your treasure is... :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Ye shall be changed by noellecampbell Ye shall be changed :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Gangsta Fae is down wit dat by noellecampbell Gangsta Fae is down wit dat :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0 Send Me An Angel by noellecampbell Send Me An Angel :iconnoellecampbell:noellecampbell 0 0

Favourites

Shadowcat by Tarzman Shadowcat :icontarzman:Tarzman 312 32 +if i had a boat by against-stars +if i had a boat :iconagainst-stars:against-stars 282 22 Batlle Chasers Gully by Sandrotrs Batlle Chasers Gully :iconsandrotrs:Sandrotrs 5 0 Finished poster! by Loopydave Finished poster! :iconloopydave:Loopydave 846 264 Muad'Dib by mamasaurus Muad'Dib :iconmamasaurus:mamasaurus 60 25 Yokai Boy Paperchild by graffiti-blaze Yokai Boy Paperchild :icongraffiti-blaze:graffiti-blaze 83 48 Mayan Jaguar by FireKat Mayan Jaguar :iconfirekat:FireKat 97 20

Groups

Watchers

Activity


(cross posted at www.noellecampbell.com)

Here is what I don't get:

People will mock and ridicule women for reading romance novels and lets face it, a man would be run out of town for admitting to reading romance. I myself have been guilty of this. I don't think I read any Romance regularly until I was introduced to Julia Quinn. If I agree that some romance is pretty shallow, most are somewhat formulaic, there is a huge and obvious double standard going on among literature critics that I can point out very easily with one genre and one name: Fantasy Fiction/George RR Martin.

If you think the formula of a romance novel is bad, you should be gagging at the copious amounts of "cock" and "cunt" you see in "Song of Fire and Ice" by people who apparently have no religious system, religious leaders, stern mothers or even disapproving Paladins (which would necessitate a God, I suppose) at all. Ever. This world is completely without the foundations so vital to Western Civilization.

You could excuse the Greeks their womanizing given their mythology and the well known proclivities of the King of the Gods, but if you think Romance Novels give women unrealistic expectations of real relationships, you should be insisting that the world in Fire and Ice show the lowest expectations of the male half of the species available of relationships with rape, attempted rape, incest, and the treatment of disabled and special needs people the norm. At least the rogues in Romance Novels get 'reformed.'

If at the same time you claim this is 'realism' so more valid in today's world then men should be outraged at the level of lechery, deceit, brutality and debauchery that is expected from them by this well known fantasy author and the thousands of people that read him. Aragorn stayed true to Arwen, even though he could have had Eowyn and let her die in the battle before the Gates of Gondor. Maybe Tolkien would have balanced that that, but today's crowd certainly wouldn't have thought it wrong, or that Aragorn was less than a man for letting Eowyn feel like he loved her while pining for another woman. Surely Tolkien knew men who did this sort of thing in the war. Romanced an Italian, German, African while still writing the wife/girlfriend at home. But he didn't write his story that way because… well…Is that what we want from fantasy? Realism?

As for a historical realism, take a step back and look at the genre you are reading. This isn't realistic at all. Song of Fire and Ice isn't a portrayal of the everyday life, everyday men, or everyday women. It's fantasy. We expect it to be unreal. This fantasy doesn't say it's "historical fantasy" like Historical Romance, which is actually based in history and portrays actual elements of history.

For "reality" we turn to history and biography. As long as you are going to include dragons, magic creatures, and a system of government largely dependent on these items and a great deal of wishful thinking and imagination (there's no way *someone* wouldn't have killed Tyrion before he became an adult or relegated him to an existence of ridicule in a 'realistic' family like Lannister in any time period similar to feudal Europe), you have to agree that Romance Novels are comparable–compatible– literature or consider yourself a hypocrite.

If we can agree that entertainment is the point of fiction, then you have to give kudos to the people who write novels that millions of women want to read AND that millions of men want to read. If dark, gritty fantasy is your thing, so be it, but leave the girls their space too and if you can't say something nice about the authors of Romance (who have studied as much classical/Victorian/dark age history as George RR Martin and actually USE it IN CONTEXT of their story), then don't say anything at all.

M'Kay?

:)

deviantID

noellecampbell's Profile Picture
noellecampbell
Noelle Sorensen
Artist | Hobbyist | Other
United States
Noelle confesses she was a 'tomboy that loved pink frilly things,' and claims to have always been 'a good Mormon girl.' She wrote for Space.com's entertainment section in the 90's and with her experience there, developed a deep interest in Mars and the idea of terraforming the red planet. This interest is reflected in a series of short stories about Mars available on Kindle ebook. Married to a deaf-blind craftsman, Noelle now incorporates much of her knowledge of ASL, Deaf Culture and the many experiences she has had into her writing as can be seen in her Superstition series. Currently studying to be a Master Gardener in Harris County, Texas, she has turned this knowledge into an article on Provident Living/Container Gardening for Ensign Magazine in March 2011. She thinks the world is full of magic, and her writing likes to reflect it in positive, uplifting stories she calls 'modern mythology.'
Interests

Comments