No, I don't think that is fair. I don't know how I would choose which one, plus, I don't expect people to watch my scraps just to be able to get updates. If I rely on them to remember, they won't remember. People just don't remember stuff unless you put it in front of them. I'd likely make a folder for each and submit each version to each folder and leave it out of the featured section.
I have to be fair to both groups of people. Plus with the comments, I have them stacked in my message center, so I know which comments go where. I'm not worried about the amount of comments I'll get. That's the least of my worries.