Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
:iconmydoggycatmadi:MyDoggyCatMadi posted a status
So let me know if I should make a journal about this: 

Let’s talk about Ashley x Ash for a minute 

Ash is 10-12 right? I want to discuss if what Ashley’s doing is sexualizing him or a minor. I’ve always said it is but now I’m not so sure. I want my commentary on her to be really good and I’m kinda playing with Fire with these points. And I just want to be sure

Repeating myself Ash is considered a minor in US jurisdiction. And Ashley is 18 I don’t think much debate is needed with this but this is Technically a pedophillic ship if I’m not mistaken. It was established in 2003 it doesn’t matter if the age if the character is bumped. But is that SEXUALIZING him or just putting him a pedophillic relationship? 

I want to say that the sexual situations that she’s putting Ash in is indirectly sexualizing him. But I think back to Soul 
and Blair’s relationship in Soul Eater. Now Soul did NOT want to be with Blair by any means. Some people may say he did because he got nose bleeds. But he always was able rock resist Blair the only time he didn’t was to trick her. And they still had jokes... Ash seems willing to be sexually aroused.... that’s not a healthy nor functional relationship. 

And here’s the big thing: Is it incest? 




maybe? I mean I looked at some forums and people say it still counts its just metaphorical. Like I’ve been saying. 

but its really up for debate i think I might cut that portion from the video 

but tell me your thoughts

im sorry the videos taking so long relivancy is not a huge factor to me I just want to get it out before summer break tbh.

Devious Comments

:iconxxcreepyhoodxx:
XxcreepyhoodxX Featured By Owner Mar 15, 2018  Professional Traditional Artist
She could've made her character somewhere around 10-12 and probably changed the last name to keep the idea of incest away from her character so that way it is a pure and romantic relationship.
Reply
:iconmydoggycatmadi:
MyDoggyCatMadi Featured By Owner Mar 15, 2018   Digital Artist
And maybe not make it so sexual.... like
new more bikini shit and nudes 
plz 
Reply
:iconxxcreepyhoodxx:
XxcreepyhoodxX Featured By Owner Mar 15, 2018  Professional Traditional Artist
Exactly
Reply
:iconmydoggycatmadi:
MyDoggyCatMadi Featured By Owner Mar 15, 2018   Digital Artist
yes
Reply
:iconxxcreepyhoodxx:
XxcreepyhoodxX Featured By Owner Mar 15, 2018  Professional Traditional Artist
yus
Reply
:iconheavensbeautiful:
HeavensBeautiful Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Looked it up to make sure yeeeppppp it is uvu 
Reply
:iconmydoggycatmadi:
MyDoggyCatMadi Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018   Digital Artist
Thanks maybe send me a few articles plz 
Reply
:iconheavensbeautiful:
HeavensBeautiful Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Sure thing uvu 
Reply
:iconmydoggycatmadi:
MyDoggyCatMadi Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018   Digital Artist
Yey thank you 
Reply
:iconheavensbeautiful:
HeavensBeautiful Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
No problem~
I hope they helped you~
Reply
:iconheavensbeautiful:
HeavensBeautiful Featured By Owner Edited Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
It’s both illegal. Aging up is too if it’s not you’re oc.
DA goes by us rules and no where is incest is legal uvu

A best Friend of mine could go into detail about this better 
Reply
:iconpokeprincess93:
PokePrincess93 Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Do AUs count with that too?
Reply
:iconheavensbeautiful:
HeavensBeautiful Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
As far as I see it’s fine as long as their is no Sexual themes 
Reply
:iconpokeprincess93:
PokePrincess93 Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Okay because I made an AU where ash and the others are grown up and doing their own thing. I partnered him up with an oc mostly to show Ashley how to do it right. Its mostly cutie things like sneaking a kiss or hand holding but that's kind of it ^^; I didn't know there was a law about this XDDD
Reply
:iconlittlemiszoruaart:
LittleMisZoruaArt Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
I'd say it's okay to age up a character if the intent isn't for shipping or sexual purproses.
Reply
:iconheavensbeautiful:
HeavensBeautiful Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
So far it is okay ^^
Aging up is definitely illegal ah I like that law. It’s a big issue because it fuels fantasy and what not.
Same with incest though anyone is sick if they like that.
Reply
:iconlittlemiszoruaart:
LittleMisZoruaArt Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Oh, I'm well aware incest is illegal. But it's illegal to have an AU where the Pokémon characters are adults and wondering what they're doing with their lives? Oh no, Misty took over the gym and had matured into that role! Someone call the popo
Reply
:iconheavensbeautiful:
HeavensBeautiful Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
Honestly I’d look it up more as long as it isn’t sexual the articles ive clicked doesn’t say anything against it. It was kinda hard to find an accurate thing on the incest thing I would have linked The Wikipedia since it was one of the first but idk if ya would belive it since it is the Wikipedia.

I know it’s illegal but it is good to know it’s extremely rare
Reply
:iconlittlemiszoruaart:
LittleMisZoruaArt Featured By Owner Mar 14, 2018  Hobbyist General Artist
That's what I'm saying: as long as the aging up/down of a character isn't to fulfill someone's sexual desire, it's okay.

As for incest, based on the results of incest relationships (ie: the offspring is deformed or born with deadly genetic mutations), it's easy to see why it's messed up. When it comes to being in a relationship with a step-sibling, I see it as something wrong because it feels as though someone's banging their cousin. That's just... no.
Reply
Add a Comment: