My thoughts on digital vs traditional. (2018)
|2 min read
Recommended Journals
NEW ART School - Digital Artists join now!
Hey all! I'm super excited to finally announce my latest mega project - "Digital ART School" 🎉 I've been gathering various art school curriculums over the last year with the hopes of putting together a massive program teaching you the same content you would find in a traditional art school, but specially made with digital arts in mind and at a fraction of the cost charged by institutions. I'm finally ready to launch it :D I've never been a fan of traditional art schools since aside from being big ripoffs, there's always a significant portion of the classes that are pretty much useless or simply missing. Hopefully this addresses all th
F.A.Q
so i wanted to write everything in here better than answering the same questions every time :") what Tablet do you use? i use cintiq companion 2 i bought it last year from Ubuy and it costed me 460 KWD ( im not sure how much is it in the usd) it doesn't need a computer cuz its like a computer and a tablet in one device. what program do you use and where can i download it? i use paint tool sai and you can download it from this site ( its not free btw) https://www.systemax.jp/en/sai/ my version is 1.1.0 do you draw traditionally too? no, i prefer to work digitally, i only doodle on paper when i have a class lol what are your settings for yo
Features of March 2018
Welcome to the feature journal of March! We have some stunning work to showcase this time! And hopefully the journal won't glitch out and abduct some entries XD Don't forget to leave some love to these artists! :D
longestdistance's avatar
By longestdistance   |   Watch
20 27 1K (1 Today)
Published: August 5, 2018
Last year I made a journal discussing the differences between traditional and digital drawing. Drawing traditionally vs digitally

Since then, I've been focusing a lot more on drawing traditionally and I think I've made a lot of progress since last summer. It's not that I considered digital as an inferior medium to traditional, but I made the mistake of believing my true artistic skill was reflected in how well I could draw on paper. (Since I was looking at a bunch of amazing traditional artists on Instagram) The truth is that digital and traditional are two completely different skill sets. Some people are amazing at drawing on paper but their digital coloring skills aren't up to par, and vice versa.

My personal opinion is that you should do a lot of both traditional and digital art (if you are able to) because the skills you learn in one medium will transfer over to the other medium in an interesting way. Drawing traditionally has made me more conscious of each line stroke and has trained me to better make artistic decisions I won't regret. Drawing digitally has made me better at picking out colors when I do traditional paintings, and I try to imitate digital techniques on the paper/canvas but it comes out in its own unique way. It's fun to make mockups on the computer that I later transfer to a canvas or paper. It's like the paper and screen are having a conversation with each other.

A few months ago I wrote a long research paper for one of my art history courses on how digital art is a worthy equal to the traditional mediums. I still think about it all the time and what I could have added to the essay. It's just always on my mind. I just think it's great to be well-rounded in both mediums, because it opens up a lot of new possibilities.

I would love to hear your thoughts and experiences on the matter!
Recommended Journals
NEW ART School - Digital Artists join now!
Hey all! I'm super excited to finally announce my latest mega project - "Digital ART School" 🎉 I've been gathering various art school curriculums over the last year with the hopes of putting together a massive program teaching you the same content you would find in a traditional art school, but specially made with digital arts in mind and at a fraction of the cost charged by institutions. I'm finally ready to launch it :D I've never been a fan of traditional art schools since aside from being big ripoffs, there's always a significant portion of the classes that are pretty much useless or simply missing. Hopefully this addresses all th
F.A.Q
so i wanted to write everything in here better than answering the same questions every time :") what Tablet do you use? i use cintiq companion 2 i bought it last year from Ubuy and it costed me 460 KWD ( im not sure how much is it in the usd) it doesn't need a computer cuz its like a computer and a tablet in one device. what program do you use and where can i download it? i use paint tool sai and you can download it from this site ( its not free btw) https://www.systemax.jp/en/sai/ my version is 1.1.0 do you draw traditionally too? no, i prefer to work digitally, i only doodle on paper when i have a class lol what are your settings for yo
Features of March 2018
Welcome to the feature journal of March! We have some stunning work to showcase this time! And hopefully the journal won't glitch out and abduct some entries XD Don't forget to leave some love to these artists! :D
Comments27
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Sign In
cottoncritter's avatar
cottoncritterHobbyist Traditional Artist
I've dabbled in both over the years and I think my most creative time was when I was playing with pixels, digital art, and also things like acrylic painted rocks, perler beads, watercolors etc. 

These past years I didn't have access to digital art programs and been focusing on things like colored pencil art. I'm worried though that traditional art will become less and less desirable (certainly seems that way on DA sometimes) and wonder if I should be getting back into digital too. I'm curious about pursuing pixel art like I used to anyways. (Icons, character scenes, landscapes etc)
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
It's definitely true that art communities have their biases. Do you post your traditional art on Instagram? I feel like I see more traditional than digital art posted there (especially since they love their Instagram shots with all the tools they used haha)

Pixel art sounds like fun! Especially since you mentioned experimenting with perler beads. I have so much respect for pixel artists considering how much patience and attention to detail it requires. Truly an art form suited for the digital age! ;p
Nerun0san's avatar
And people still saying "DigITaL iS nOt aRt" ...
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
Man, those people just don't get it. :x
Khasdannyanlord's avatar
KhasdannyanlordStudent Traditional Artist
well i try to do the same at the same rate my conclusion is digital is the same difficult only you need the right tool to work!
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
Yep!
antelopelim's avatar
antelopelimStudent General Artist
After years of doing art digitally because I'm bad at coloring on paper, I've just realized that coloring digitally isn't going to help improve my handling of a real paint brush.

Therefore, I've been thinking of trying coloring traditionally as well, as I still believe it is a fundamental thing to improve my coloring skills.
Having experiences on both media is just going to help you way lot more than being skillful in either one. One can discover a more diverse way of painting when they have the skills on both, producing something extraordinary.

Traditional painting, is hard to correct mistakes. In a way, it can help reduce your mistakes when drawing digitally, that's what I think.

Yeah, my main problem isn't drawing on paper but coloring on paper. :(
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
I agree with you there! Coloring traditionally isn't easy, especially if you don't have the right materials and it can be frustrating and physically tiring in some cases. I think that's what makes digital art so great because it allows you to experiment with color as much as possible and you don't have to worry about "wasting" anything.
antelopelim's avatar
antelopelimStudent General Artist
EXACTLY!!!
toedeledoki's avatar
Can relate! Especially the ability to pick out and mix colours better after having done digital art for some years really surprised me initially. 

I've no preferences personally. I've found that both media types are great and unforgiving in their own way. The permanence of it was what really daunted me from starting traditional pieces at first. To achieve a certain result requires a solid understanding of one's tools and how say paper, water and paint respond to one another. You have to be mindful of every stroke, line and splotch, because it will colour the final result indefinitely. It's also what tends to give your pieces instant character, but it doesn't give you anything to hide behind either. If you suck, your piece will suck. Then there's the infinite malleability of digital artworks. Nothing is final and you can endlessly add, subtract, refine and rework to your hearts content. It can be comforting if you can trust yourself to know when things 'look bad'. I'd say it's arguably easier to create a pretty illustration with digital art than traditional art. However, it requires always having to consciously decide when and how a piece should and will be finished. For me, it can often be frustrating how stiffling that freedom can be. 

But ultimately the skills that truly matter in art are unrelated to the medium that you choose to express your creativity with. Sometimes I receive the best feedback from people who couldn't draw a tea pot if their life depended on it. They might not have an active understanding of how to visualize what's in their mind's eye, or how mix paint to put on a canvas, take a picture of a city skyline at night with a DLSR or mold clay. But they do understand or at least unconsciously recognize form, light, composition and colour. Learning the tools of the trade and all the specific advantages or disavantages of other art mediums is incredibly important, but in my opinion comes second to the foundational knowledge of how to look at the world and understand how it interacts with itself as well as how it affects us. Practicing a particular medium of your choice is just one of many ways to further that understanding. Be aware of the pros and cons of any medium you try and there's no 'right' or 'wrong' one to be practicing is what I feel ;)


longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
Thanks for commenting! You have a lot of great insight. Especially in regards to being given too much freedom with digital to the point where it can be overwhelming. It makes you wonder how much of digital artists' art block just comes from having too many options in which case I'd say step back and focus on something else for a bit. I've definitely been there and I'm sure you and many others can relate as well. And I agree- learning the fundamentals is SO important. Some people believe that having a unique style is more important than having the fundamental art skills, but I disagree-- if an artist's style lacks the proper foundation then it will all fall apart especially if the fundamental issues are never addressed. (I speak from personal experience on that one!)
toedeledoki's avatar
I'm glad you didn't mind that wall of text haha. Totally agree on that last part. I'm speaking from personal experience too! Too long have I been able to hide away some clear gaps in my knowledge of perspective and anatomy using Photoshop tricks (transform/warp/liquify). Eventually you just run into a wall. Plus it's an inefficient way of working too, having to constantly 'fix' proportions at multiple stages of painting. Anyway, I've got some ways to go but going traditional has been a real eye-opener so it's back to basics for me. I've been enjoying it though! 
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
Yes!! Exactly all of that. It feels so liberating learning new skills that makes the overall process quicker and more efficient instead of spending 2 hours fixing everything from the bottom up. It's a good investment. And of course, I think you've got the painting thing down pretty dang well!
VioletCascade's avatar
VioletCascade Digital Artist
I used to love to draw traditionally before I got my tablet but since then I realized how much strain I was putting on my back bending over because when I'm drawing digitally my hand is on the page and I'm looking up and sitting up more also I can use both my hands with digital being left handed I can scroll with my right hand and draw with my left xD
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
As a rightie I always wondered what it's like to use a computer mouse as a leftie. I guess you're probably used to it right? (no pun intended) Tho I guess there's alwyas the option of switching the mouse to the other side.  Just something random I've always wondered about. XD
VioletCascade's avatar
VioletCascade Digital Artist
yea i've always just had the mouse on my right side it'd be awfully strange to switch it now haha :'3 i can't even imagine but lefties are usually fairly good at using both hands for tasks 
the biggest issue i've run into is using scissors they're just awful xD
my teachers would always ask why i didn't cut out something or why it's taking so long and usually i'd have to ask a friend to cut things out for me
Prinnia's avatar
PrinniaProfessional Digital Artist
I agree that both are very valuable things to practice!  And your skills in one definitely won't directly reflect your skills in the other, although they do contribute to one another in a meaningful way. I find that I'm much better at being loose and experimental in traditional because I always had a very sketchy way of drawing, whereas my digital art is much cleaner and brighter.  It's definitely easier to experiment with colors and layers of things digitally.
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
Yes!! Exactly this. It's interesting to see how your skills from different mediums carry over to the others, for better or for worse. Definitely helps to be well rounded in general I say!
wotawota's avatar
Hmm... there are various points of view or the ways how to judge it...
IMHO, in simple terms:

First, technically speaking, I think, traditional drawing (process!) is somewhat superior to digital one. Please don't get me wrong - I really don't underestimate digital creation hard work, but in digital world you can use for example many clever labor-saving automated program modules (etc.), then, without electricity you cannot do anything.... While if you draw "traditionally" all you have are your hands (with particular drawing tools)... plus you can create wherever, far from civilization.
Second, from the point of view of the inspiration and creative imagination, I am sure that both ways are totally equal.
I'm sorry ... I'm not good at explaining the things...
*
Well, I also agree that ideally (if possible) it's the best to practice both.
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
You bring up a great point! That is one of the big advantages traditional has over digital. When the power goes out, I can't do digital art until the power comes back, but I can always draw or paint (provided I have a light source!)
Kuragari1988's avatar
Kuragari1988Hobbyist Digital Artist
Well I started traditionally, later I tried with mouse. And I like digital with graphic tablet most. Because I tend to mess up the line art and that made me furious x_x I have no patience and shakey hands...
longestdistance's avatar
longestdistanceProfessional Digital Artist
I get what you mean! Digital line tools are definitely a life saver. It can be really aggravating on paper sometimes.
KobutaNori's avatar
KobutaNoriHobbyist Digital Artist
I started drawing mainly digital but recently I've been doing more traditional art.  Traditional drawing made me realize a lot of bad habits that I developed because of digital drawing.  For instance, I completely abuse the undo button and transform tool, I draw too fast, not actually thinking about line placement which actually slows down my work flow tremendously.  Drawing traditionally is great because of its unforgiving setting.  Rather then drawing mindlessly and erasing the countless mistakes in digital, I was forced to think about how I wanted something to look and then carefully, slowly, try to draw that.  I think while its okay to prefer one medium over another (i still prefer digital) I think it is incredibly beneficial to practice both mediums. Llama Emoji-09 (Drinking Tea) [V1] 
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Sign In
©2019 DeviantArt
All Rights reserved