Since my beloved fandom is very disappointed with the newest Slenderman movie, I'd like to introduce you guys to the horror movies that aren't necesserily based on creepypastas but, in my opinion, they feel like they could be.
1. The Mothman Prophecies 2002
Based on real events from 60's, that took place in West Virginia, USA. (google it) The atmosphere is so on point, I love this movie, deserves a numero uno place on the list. Cryptid Movie, creepy andunsetteling
Also there are plenty of Creepypasta's written about Mothman so yeach :v
2. The Tall Man 2012
Highly referencing Slender Man, though the plot is more deeper than that.
3. The Ritual 2018
Woods? Ancient Evil? Occult? Let's say no more
4. The Dyaltov Pass Incident
Lowkey trashy, but hey, it's a creepypasta-like movie list!
^The Dyaltov Incident happened and is left