Cancelled Movies - Superman (Hayden Christensen)

Did you know during George Miller's plans for Justice League Mortal, D.J. Cortona wasn't the only name listed to portray Superman?

turns out our lovable sand hating jedi, Hayden Christensen's name was highly considered for the role,

Ken referred to Hayden Christensen as "very wooden and extremely uninteresting" in his review of Jumper, he's apparently now moving on to step on Brandon Routh's toes and assume the role of a younger Superman in Justice League: Mortal Apparently Cinema Blend received a scoop from a woman in British Columbia, Canada who "cornered" a drunken Adam Brody in a bar up there and used her charm to get some details out of him. One of them was this bit about Hayden as Superman. Talk about one hell of a rickety story...

but the rumors were denied. so for Cancelled Movies, I decided to what if that and use the suit I made of D.J. Cortona's Superman and test it on Hayden

so the question remains as always

do you think this would've been a flop or a success?

or more importantly...

is this good or bad casting?