jackhopeart

"Celebdumb" and "Celebsmarts" are two pages on the Miraheze wikis, Terrible TV Shows & Episodes and Best Shows & Episodes Wikis respectively. Both of these articles list certain celebrities and other famous people on deeds they did right and things they did wrong, claiming that their deeds revolve around "common sense". While it is fair to criticize/praise certain people based on certain deeds, these two pages have become two of the most controversial reception wiki pages for certain reasons. Here are the top 5 reasons why "Celebdumb" and "Celebsmarts" are NOT smart pages to create: #5: It's Not "Criticism" MRW users say that "criticism is supposed to help improve people's behavior". So is this what fair criticism is? Putting people that are controversial on a list of shame? It's egregious at best and overall not a fair way of giving criticism. Additionally, it's just a pointless page to "criticize" or "praise" certain celebrities. Why should there be a page listing every celebrity as