I certainly want to thank you for the in depth assessment. Vision: I'm certainly glad you noted the elements you did in this section. They were the very ones I was paying special attention to. Originality: I understand what you are saying here, but do watch your wording. This is certainly my picture, even if it's not my concept. As for the new perspective, it demonstrates what I love doing best - putting a new spin on very familiar scenes. Following categories: Thank you for your comments in these areas. They are quite insightful.
I thank you greatly for taking the time to generate this critique. I am most glad that you mentioned the lighting - with the source material being as modern as it was, it seemed lighting was one of the only places that could be improved upon. In particular, I'm glad to see you mention Eggman's saw - that took quite a few attempts to get right, and I really toyed around with the idea of what material I wanted conveyed. It was conveyed properly.
Thank you for your input, and I am glad you like the result.
Thank you greatly for generating this critique. Indeed this boss really put your knowledge of the game's physics to the test. It's so satisfying to stay balanced on the Doc's head for those first 16 hits and watch him fruitlessly shoot straight forward again and again.
I'm certainly glad I could bring this piece to dA, and I'm certainly glad you like it as well.
I thank you greatly for taking the time to develop this critique. If I had to peg Mecha Knuckles' action, it would be falling out of a glide, and Sonic's trying to capitalize on it with a well placed spin dash. I thank you for taking the time to notice many of the finer details others might hastily overlook. I certainly appreciate critiques like yours; ones that remind me of the areas that I must continue to improve upon. Although I've grown as an artist since drawing this piece, it is always a delight to be reminded of those areas that I must continue to improve upon/keep in mind as I create new pieces. It is through the continued diligence of commenters like yourself that I am reminded of what needs more attention, and thus what I need to do to bring better art to dA.