HI HI RINRIN!!
yeah that's how it looks to me too but i never really changed anything... I just visited some random DA profiles and their icons are also very crisp and sharp... I guess it's DA's fault(?) why it's like this or maybe they changed the resolution for the icons?? I honestly dk I was about to find some way to fix it too but I don't have photoshop anymore OTL
(since MAL is not working I will reply your comments here)~
I dunno, maybe I should have made icon 100x100...... then again I uploaded it as my profile ava and it looked fine? Maybe it indeed is DA's fault hmmm. Does my Elliot's icon look crisp too? How mysterious I'm too lazy to remake the icon but I could try to crop it (tho it might not give the same vibe as this icon if you know what I'm talking about :''D)
OMG... I was gonna log in few days ago on MAL but there was an error??? it was annoying :(
Your Elliot looks quite fine but yes, the modifications you made worked already... thank you again so so much!! <3