Esuka's avatar
S5 E23: War of the Pumpkins
By Esuka   |   Watch
128 6 2K (1 Today)
Published: November 14, 2015
© 2015 - 2019 Esuka
Pumpkins for days. This episode was a lot of fun, mostly for all the crazy yokel characters we got from the two families. Granted, only two of them spoke in most cases, but they were great, and the designs overall were great. The designs of the two hills were a lot of fun as well, showcasing their strengths and weaknesses. The plot was nothing spectacular, but still had some fun beats, and was well executed scene by scene.

I think my main issue would be Twilight and Fluttershy, but more Twilight. Fluttershy was, well, being herself, so ok she gets a pass. But Twilight is supposed to be the Princess of Friendship(tm). I get that she's a nerd, and that organizing and analyzing is her natural way to attacking problems. But shouldn't she have, by now, intuited that not everything is empirically solved, especially matters of friendship? It seems too late in her arc for her to be having problems like this. Don't get me wrong, it was humorous, but it felt out of place.

Still, I'd call it one of the better episodes of the season. If nothing else, we got to see more of Equestria and its colorful characters. And that's always a plus.
Image size
2000x1400px 1.39 MB
Comments6
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Sign In
reihpmal's avatar
There's no reason why a friendship problem can't be solved Twilight's way, it's just that until she knew what the underlying issue was she couldn't really do anything. The map sent Fluttershy because it knew Twilight would need her animal speaking abilities to find out that underlying issue. Overall I had no issues with the episode at all.
0Alfa's avatar
Now this made me think, would it be more interesting if our Mane characters prefer to choose one side over the other, and Fluttershy ended up brokering the truce? Hmm, that happened before already, right? :hmm:
saturdaymorningproj's avatar
Well, let's face it, season 4 was REALLY light on Twilight episodes (I don't mean two-parters), so it's more like the writers have tackled her arc now, while it could/would/should be done earlier. I guess since season 3 was supposed to be the last season, they didn't had initial concept for episodes with her in focus until now. That's how I understand it. Plus time in Equestria seems kind of wonky, we don't exactly know how much time passed over things. Maybe it's sort of like comic book time pace in the meaning that in many ongoing serieses what take years IRL, take months or days in comics :P

Anyway, fantastic artwork ;)
EqDBot's avatar
This Deviation was featured in the following Equestria Daily Post www.equestriadaily.com/2015/11… Thank you for providing pony material for all of us to enjoy :)
(This bot is unofficial, it is NOT affiliated with Equestria Daily. If you do not wish to get these notifications anymore, please just block this account.)
Darth-Silas's avatar
Michael Colt: Hooffield and McColt continue their heated rivalry tonight on Monday Night Mayhem. Who will emerge victorious? That match…is next.
SeriousJupiter's avatar
It was hilarious. I could write a long review like I usually do, but I honestly think there's no need. I'll just say that I enjoyed pretty much everything in the episode and that it might actually be my favorite map episode. This is exactly what cartoons are supposed to be like - silly and cute parodies of the real world. It being the first Twilight/Fluttershy episode since season one certainly didn't hurt either. 9.5/10.
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Sign In
©2019 DeviantArt
All Rights reserved