Esuka's avatar
S5 E15: Mystery in Red Velvet
By Esuka   |   Watch
152 5 2K (1 Today)
Published: September 19, 2015
© 2015 - 2019 Esuka
Direct episode continuity? Whaaaat?

Short recap this time. The actual plot itself was alright: predictable, but still pretty fun to step through. The classic mystery film elements were spot on, easily my favorite part of the episode. They got so on the nose about it. But what was the most interesting to me was the fact that we seem to have multiple, or even all of the mane 6, finally evolving in their situations in life. All the work of the past seasons is yielding fruit, and it will be interesting to see where that goes.

MLP:FiM is (c) Hasbro
Image size
2372x977px 972.76 KB
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Sign In
0Alfa's avatar
Rarity's hat's made of flexible steel! A weapon! :lol:
SeriousJupiter's avatar

It was pretty good, possibly even one of the best Rarity episodes. All the details and references in the episode were top-notch and we even got to see Sassy again - not that she had a big role, but whatever. I haven't watched many black-and-white movies in my life, but I enjoyed the noir scenes a lot. They really added something to the episode.

The Wonderbolts' comeback was somewhat disappointing - not that I didn't want to see them again, but because they once again acted like jerks. How could they possibly think Rainbow Dash was behind Spitfire's disappearance? What happened to "innocent until proven guilty"? Not even counting all the times RD has helped save Equestria, you'd think that at least Soarin would have remembered everything she's done for the Wonderbolts themselves. Why does Rainbow Dash look up to these guys again? Oh wait, yes, I know - because she's quite the douchebag herself sometimes. That said, I did like her in this episode. All her character development seems to have finally sunk into her thick skull, because she was being incredibly modest and overall not obnoxious in this episode. Heck, I might even say that she's now too GOOD for the Wonderbolts - that is, as long as I'm allowed to pretend that that horrible abomination of an episode, Tanks for the Memories, was just a bad dream.

Back to Rarity, she was great. We learned that she's a fan of detective novels, how about that. I guess we know now what kind of books she likes to read in her silk pyjamas on Sunday mornings. Screw that cake episode, this is how MLP should do detective stories all the time. Of course, we all knew who the real culprit was, but it was still fun to watch Rarity figure the whole thing out. I swear I don't believe in the "unicorn master race", but maybe they really are the smartest ponies in Equstria. Well, at least when compared to the Wonderbolts.

So, basically, I'd say this episode's pros outweigh the cons. My final score is 8.5/10.

timfortune9's avatar
I find that true of most episodes. You can see where they're going by the end of the first act (or sometimes even the pre-credit teaser. And even the more surprising ones you can figure out by middle of Act Two), but it's how they go through it that make them enjoyable. Today's the episode I liked the best first time through since "Slice of Life". Easily within the Top 5 of the season so far for me ("Slice of Life", "Amending Fences", "Cutie Map" and "Make New Friends But Keep Discord" edge it out).
EqDBot's avatar
This Deviation was featured in the following Equestria Daily Post… Thank you for providing pony material for all of us to enjoy :) (This bot is unofficial, it is NOT affiliated with Equestria Daily. If you do not wish to get these notifications anymore, please just block this account.)
ooReiko's avatar
ooReikoStudent Artist
So lovely and beautiful drawing =)=)<3
©2019 DeviantArt
All Rights reserved