Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
About Deviant Ryan Alcock42/Male/Australia Group :icondc2-dc-comic-fan-art: DC2-DC-Comic-Fan-Art
 
Recent Activity
Deviant for 9 Years
Needs Core Membership
Statistics 1,815 Deviations 14,345 Comments 59,322 Pageviews
×

Newest Deviations

Mera by DoctorRy Mera :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 6 0 Elly #1 by DoctorRy Elly #1 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 7 0 Spider-Gwen #1 by DoctorRy Spider-Gwen #1 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 9 1 Ballet Glamour by DoctorRy
Mature content
Ballet Glamour :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 7 0
Project Who: No 271 by DoctorRy Project Who: No 271 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 5 2 Twelfth Doctor Adventures II by DoctorRy Twelfth Doctor Adventures II :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 7 3 It's All Connected by DoctorRy It's All Connected :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 2 2 A New Companion? by DoctorRy A New Companion? :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 6 2 Project Who: No 270 by DoctorRy Project Who: No 270 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 4 0 Candid by DoctorRy Candid :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 5 0 Project Who: No 269 by DoctorRy Project Who: No 269 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 5 0 Project Who: No 268 by DoctorRy Project Who: No 268 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 4 0 Project Who: No 267 by DoctorRy Project Who: No 267 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 5 4 Project Who: No 266 by DoctorRy Project Who: No 266 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 4 0 Project Who: No 265 by DoctorRy Project Who: No 265 :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 7 0 Bill: Project Who by DoctorRy Bill: Project Who :icondoctorry:DoctorRy 4 1

Favourites

Stella by xeneras Stella :iconxeneras:xeneras 229 9 Stella by xeneras Stella :iconxeneras:xeneras 264 17 Doctor Who - The Trial of a Timelord Poster by GrantBattersby Doctor Who - The Trial of a Timelord Poster :icongrantbattersby:GrantBattersby 4 1 Fotini by xeneras
Mature content
Fotini :iconxeneras:xeneras 196 6
Stella by xeneras Stella :iconxeneras:xeneras 215 7 Alexandra by xeneras Alexandra :iconxeneras:xeneras 220 4 Stella by xeneras Stella :iconxeneras:xeneras 141 4 Stella by xeneras Stella :iconxeneras:xeneras 248 5 Kindness is better by fdasuarez Kindness is better :iconfdasuarez:fdasuarez 1,258 43 Xenia Onatopp (GOLDENEYE, 1995) by PaulHanley Xenia Onatopp (GOLDENEYE, 1995) :iconpaulhanley:PaulHanley 32 2 W.I.P Arcade Miss Fortune by LittleCandyGamer W.I.P Arcade Miss Fortune :iconlittlecandygamer:LittleCandyGamer 3 0 Vegeta and Bulma by LittleCandyGamer Vegeta and Bulma :iconlittlecandygamer:LittleCandyGamer 3 0 Always this way by fdasuarez
Mature content
Always this way :iconfdasuarez:fdasuarez 656 43
Flowers by LittleCandyGamer Flowers :iconlittlecandygamer:LittleCandyGamer 1 0 Bulma cosplay - Dragon Ball I. by EnjiNight Bulma cosplay - Dragon Ball I. :iconenjinight:EnjiNight 820 32 Power Girl: Rise from the Ashes by Jeffach Power Girl: Rise from the Ashes :iconjeffach:Jeffach 955 56
SPOILERS

Hmmmm....

Well, let's get the elephant in the room out of the way first. There's some specific aspects of this production that I really didn't like, and was never going to. As such I'm just going to move straight on from them, because ultimately for the majority of viewers it's not going to be an issue. It created a lot of little niggles for me, but I won't dwell on it here.

As for the episode itself...I found it seemed like a non-event, to be honest. The original Doctor being afraid to regenerate makes sense, but the twelfth's decision seemed to have changed from the last story - now he wants a rest, though bizarrely he wants a rest by dying. Couldn't he just regenerate and go into retirement?

I had a lot of questions about this story, to be honest, and most of them seemed to be the obvious - why didn't Bill just say who she was from the outset? Why were the Testimony so coy about everything? At the end of the day, the entire story could have been resolved simply by the Testimony saying what was going on, avoiding the trip to Rusty and the Doctor coming to the conclusion that everything was fine.

But furthermore...surely the Doctor's actions altered time, which was something the Testimony were actively avoiding doing. Were they not upset that the Doctor had changed time? Why did Bill not bother to mention this? Did the Doctor not, therefore, change the Brigadier's timeline? Truthfully, the more I think about the story, the less it adds up.

Touching on performances, Capaldi was on fine form, as usual, though in truth his last speech in the TARDIS seemed forced, and despite the promise of an emotional farewell, I wasn't really moved in the same way I was when Matt Smith left; that regeneration seemed much more emotional to me. Pearl Mackie was fantastic (and the two cameos at the end were delightful), while Mark Gatiss turned in a very nice performance indeed.

The problem with regeneration stories, though, is that the regeneration hangs over the episode. If the story isn't firing (as this one really wasn't), there's an eagerness to get to the change. When it comes, when we get to see Jodie for the first time, she instantly makes a mark, and what happens to her immediately after is exciting and interesting; I really don't want to wait nine months to see her in action. Also...she really suits Capaldi's costume.

But if I was honest, the twelfth Doctor left with a whimper rather than a shout, which was sadly low key for such a brilliant Doctor. Too much of the story happened in order for story to happen, rather than out of any common sense reason. A disappointing end.

deviantID

DoctorRy's Profile Picture
DoctorRy
Ryan Alcock
Australia
What can I say about me? Uh...
husband, father, actor, writer, artist, geek, counsellor, friend, lover, appreciator, fanboy, guru, fashionista, blogger

...to start...

Current Residence: Deception Bay
Favourite genre of music: All...except country
Favourite style of art: Stuff that looks good...
Operating System: Microsoft Vista...so sue me...
MP3 player of choice: iPod Video
Interests

Comments


Add a Comment:
 
:iconwalle1doctor1who:
WALLE1Doctor1Who Featured By Owner May 31, 2018   Digital Artist
Happy Birthday 2 (Profile Picture) by WALLE1Doctor1Who  
(Even if I'm like an hour late saying it)
Reply
:icondoctorry:
DoctorRy Featured By Owner Jul 3, 2018
Thanks so much (even if I'm months late in saying it...and I am...I'm so slack :| )
Reply
:iconwalle1doctor1who:
WALLE1Doctor1Who Featured By Owner Jul 3, 2018   Digital Artist
You're welcome. (I sometimes have that issue too)
Reply
:iconscifiman:
scifiman Featured By Owner May 31, 2018
HAPPY BIRTHDAY !!!!! Clap :happybounce: Singing Headbang! Hi! Airborne Woohooooo! #1 Juggle Have your cake and eat it too Party Handshake Dance! 
Reply
:icondoctorry:
DoctorRy Featured By Owner Jul 3, 2018
Thanks heaps :)

Sorry for being so slack in responding to this... :/
Reply
:iconscifiman:
scifiman Featured By Owner Jul 3, 2018
Hey no problem !!!!! :D (Big Grin)  its all good !
Reply
:icondestroyer77:
Destroyer77 Featured By Owner May 30, 2018
:iconsharknoseplz::iconsharkeyeplz::iconletter-bplz::iconletter-dplz::iconalphabetars::iconletter-yplz:
:iconsmilecakeplz::iconsharkbodyplz::iconsharktailplz:
Reply
:icondoctorry:
DoctorRy Featured By Owner Jul 3, 2018
Thanks heaps :) 

Sorry for being so slack in responding to this... :/
Reply
:icondoctorry:
DoctorRy Featured By Owner Apr 15, 2018
Nice :)
Reply
Add a Comment: