Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
Draw Over Critique by brandimillerart Draw Over Critique by brandimillerart
I was critiquing a work by *Grey-Memories and ended up doing a draw over to show more clearly what I was talking about. She said she was thrilled that I did that for her, and we got to thinking about it, and decided it would be awesome if deviantART implemented a way to do a draw over (or "redlining") in critiques!

The first picture is by :icongrey-memories:
The other is by :iconhi-my-name-is-light:
They graciously let me use their deviations as examples. Thank you very much guys! (You should go look at their works!)

I was also inspired by by :iconradiatr: which has some really great ideas, too! I think all of these could be extremely useful!

Featured: [link] [link] [link] [link]
Add a Comment:
 
:iconscottidoggg:
Scottidoggg Featured By Owner Jul 12, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
WE NEED THIS!!!!!!!
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 13, 2012  Professional General Artist
I agree!
Reply
:iconblueyellowred:
BlueYellowRed Featured By Owner Feb 1, 2012  Student General Artist
Good idea :D
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Feb 1, 2012  Professional General Artist
Thank you!
Reply
:iconarichy:
Arichy Featured By Owner Aug 28, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
oh it's really great!!!
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Aug 28, 2011  Professional General Artist
Thanks! I think I'd use it a lot!
Reply
:iconarichy:
Arichy Featured By Owner Aug 28, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
i have another idea about Critique, if you want, i can send you link with idea!
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Aug 28, 2011  Professional General Artist
Sure!
Reply
:iconarichy:
Arichy Featured By Owner Aug 28, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Aug 28, 2011  Professional General Artist
Nice! I left a comment on it.
Reply
:iconbartpinnock:
BartPinnock Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Hmm, this is indeed really interesting! Have you heard anything that they are willing to use this idea or something alike?
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Professional General Artist
Thank y ou!

Well, it was featured here: [link] and my post in the suggestions forum had a lot of people saying they like the idea, but no, I haven't heard any official information on it.
Reply
:iconbartpinnock:
BartPinnock Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Well, it's common for the DA-management to first let grow a need for the option. Since when did you submit this awesome idea?
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Professional General Artist
Yeah, I imagine if they want to do it, it'll take a while for them to think about it and get things going.

I submitted it on July 15th. I don't know if they actually even read every suggestion, but I do hope they see it. =)
Reply
:iconbartpinnock:
BartPinnock Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I'm pretty sure that when it gets a DD, they'll have seen it. Perhaps in a few months they install it? I do hope so! I'll be looking forward to it :)
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Professional General Artist
But I don't have a DD. =P
Reply
:iconbartpinnock:
BartPinnock Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
How strange, I was sure I read that :D
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 30, 2011  Professional General Artist
It was featured in a group called #deviantART-Related. Currently there isn't a GM to do DD features on this category anymore.
Reply
:iconjester-of-the-clown:
Jester-of-the-Clown Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011  Student Traditional Artist
Interesting. I like the idea...
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011  Professional General Artist
Thank you! I'm glad you like it!
Reply
:iconjester-of-the-clown:
Jester-of-the-Clown Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011  Student Traditional Artist
Yus I do.

You submit the most out of all the member of the group. Henceforth, I will compete to contribute :iconmoarplz:
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011  Professional General Artist
Haha sorry. I usually upload a new deviation almost once a day, so I have lots to submit. XD

Sounds like a fun competition, though! Let's do it! hehe
Reply
:iconjester-of-the-clown:
Jester-of-the-Clown Featured By Owner Jul 25, 2011  Student Traditional Artist
:iconevilgrinplz: LETS
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 25, 2011  Professional General Artist
Haha!
Reply
:iconjester-of-the-clown:
Jester-of-the-Clown Featured By Owner Jul 25, 2011  Student Traditional Artist
:iconhurrplz:
Reply
:icondawonderer:
DaWonderer Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011
I like the idea of a Deviation-Reply in that way!
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011  Professional General Artist
I'm glad you like it! Thank you!
Reply
:iconreptonic:
Reptonic Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011  Student Filmographer
This need to be coming true. >:C
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 24, 2011  Professional General Artist
Thanks! I agree!
Reply
:iconnamenotrequired:
namenotrequired Featured By Owner Jul 18, 2011  Professional Interface Designer
I've featured this as Daily Feature in the blog of #deviantART-Related :clap:

#deviantART-Related is the unofficial group for the dA related gallery, and our Daily Feature is a private initiative to serve as an alternative to DDs while there's no GM for the gallery :)

We featured your piece for today with the following description;
This suggestion would help critics and artists a lot to communicate and understand each other. Thus it would also encourage people to critique. It would simply be a reat addition to dA!


Given 2011-07-18
Suggested by =im-not-sana
Featured by `namenotrequired

Keep it up :highfive:
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 18, 2011  Professional General Artist
Wow, thanks so much! I really appreciate it!
Reply
:iconlightybug:
Lightybug Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2011  Hobbyist Photographer
Whoaaa 8O
I would critique WAYYYY more often if this were possible! Great idea and thanks for using my picture! I just might crop it now! :D
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2011  Professional General Artist
I agree! I feel like it would be a lot easier to critique this way!

Thanks! I'm glad you let me use it!
Reply
:iconsketchedexistence:
SketchedExistence Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2011  Student General Artist
:love: Looks great! Would you mind if I featured this in my journal?
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2011  Professional General Artist
Thanks! Of course you can feature it in your journal! ^_^
Reply
:iconsketchedexistence:
SketchedExistence Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2011  Student General Artist
You're welcome! I'll make an entry about it shortly. :)
Reply
:iconbrandimillerart:
brandimillerart Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2011  Professional General Artist
Awesome!
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×




Details

Submitted on
July 15, 2011
Image Size
1.6 MB
Resolution
864×3803
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
1,732
Favourites
35 (who?)
Comments
37
Downloads
18