Let's Talk about DDs!

8 min read

Deviation Actions

Astralseed's avatar
By
Published:
1.4K Views
Hey everyone,
the other day I posted a poll asking your opinion on whether or not you'd prefer it if I replied to all of my DD suggestions with a generic thank you.  
I have to say that the responses I got were not quite what I was expecting (I really thought the masses would scream YES PLEASE SEND ME NOTES BACK YAYAYAYA)..  So I thought it might be a good idea to open up discussion about DD Suggestions and DDs in general. 

Before I open the floor, I wanted to discuss some of my personal thoughts in regards to DDs as I experience things as a CV who accepts suggestions from the community and is able to feature art as DDs. 

A few months back I posted a journal expressing that I am not so busy that anyone should worry that they are wasting my time/overwhelming me/being a bother etc by sending me DD suggestions.  The reality is that there are days when I get 0 (zero) suggestions at all, and on a really good day I may get 10 (ten).  This means that I spend very little time each day looking at and selecting DDs based on the suggestions being sent to me.  I actually spend far more time (2 -3 hours to find one or two pieces to DD) browsing the galleries on my own in order to find those hidden gems.  Granted me browsing the galleries is definitely not a bad thing, but I always feel like I am selecting based on my personal tastes more than what the community wishes to see when I am left to my own devices D:.  Anyway, the point of this is, I am not too busy and I appreciate every single suggestion I receive so by all means, keep suggesting, suggest more, or simply start suggesting :D 
The more eyes we have looking at magnificent art, the easier it is to find and share the gems! 

Alright, so taking a step back to the poll I'd posted.. I posted it to try and feel out if replies to suggestions would make a difference.  I feel like people are discouraged from suggesting DDs and if a simple reply to each note can help keep people from feeling discouraged than I am definitely open to that!  
Naturally, if that is not where the disconnect is coming from, I'd like to talk about where the issues are and see if we can all work together to find a solution.

 The next thing I'd like to discuss is my detailed DD Suggestion guidelines.  I realize that I have a lot to take in in them as well as a handful of generalized restrictions (which I'm always willing to break if the piece is amazing)... What I'd like to know here is do you think my guidelines are too restrictive?  Do you feel like having those general guidelines in place affects the quality of works being selected as DDs?  Is there anything you feel I should change in them, and why?  

So, let's discuss DDs!  

Tell me what you think of what I've written here so far, tell me what you think of DDs in general.  Are there things you like or don't like about them?  Would you like to see any changes?  Let's discuss this!

For anyone who wants to learn more about DDs, we've had two wonderful DD weeks through projecteducate and you can read all of the articles here:

Daily Deviation Week I


Daily Deviation Week II



© 2014 - 2026 Astralseed
Comments98
anonymous's avatar
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
DanielaIvanova's avatar
Personally I find your guidelines absolutely reasonable (except the same suggester one! :shakefish:). As far as replies go, I have to admit I'm personally put off when CVs don't reply at all. A generic thank-you is a bit better than no reply but still doesn't quite cut it. As far as replies go (mind you I realise you all already spend a whole lot of time trying to please and interest the community so you should by no means feel obliged to reply to every note) if there is one, I'd rather it be a yes/no type of reply and if no - why. That would help the suggester understand that CV's taste better as well as improve at analysing art. In fact seeing a yes-reply is a surprise in itself and it's never spoilt anything for me, let alone for the artist because I never tell them (and in any case I think it's selfish to go to the artist waving the see-I-suggested-your-stuff-for-a-DD-and-it-got-accepted flag). So a simple yes or no plus a warning not to tell the artist would be great imo. In fact I've stopped suggesting to some CVs exactly because they don't reply and they've never featured anything I've suggested which makes me think I've totally missed what they like/dislike and after a few tries I no longer feel like bothering. :shrug: Everyone who has suggested or browsed dA for gems knows how time-consuming that can be as well as all the hassle of checking the artist's DDs, activity, etc, finding the right CV, re-reading their guidelines, writing why you like the piece (which never gets even featured anymore) so no reply can be extremely discouraging. If it wasn't for the few awesome CVs who always leave such heart-warming replies I'd have probably quit that whole business by now.
On another note, a Suggest for a DD button doesn't sound like the greatest idea for a couple reasons: first it will encourage people to suggest TOO much and not always pieces that are up to par. Imo that effort involved with the suggesting process ensures that the piece really has the wow-factor for the viewer. Also visiting the CVs' pages is always nice because they have all sorts of features and events going on there. It'd be a pity to lose that.