Deviation Actions

ABronyAccount's avatar

The Pinkie Pie-lemma

Published:
59 Comments
8K Views
Get it? Like dilemma, but with "pie" in it...
So around 8:30 last night I was brainstorming something fierce for :iconmlp-atg-alumni:'s week 188 theme: An Indecisive pony Suddenly this idea came to me our of nowhere, a riff on that old Spot the Impostor cliche, with a patented Pinkie Pie twist!

I only got the sketch done by the deadline last night, but really wanted to finish this one. So here's the sketch, followed by the inks I thought were done but which looked too empty
PIEHER(SketchWIP)
PIEHERInks1small
The fine lines for a background texture really help bring this final version to life. I knew early on that it wouldn't look right without something to set the characters apart from each other and the blank BG.
Image details
Image size
851x1200px 278.07 KB
© 2015 - 2022 ABronyAccount
Comments59
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
BJDazzle's avatar
Clearly the obvious solution is to just eat the pie, splitting it 3 ways, and befriend the potential imposters because Friendship is Magic.

Maybe she can even get their help entertaining the Cake twins.
ABronyAccount's avatar
THERE CAN BE ONLY ONE!
BJDazzle's avatar
You are a FOOL! YOU CANNOT CONTAIN THE PINK ONE TO A SINGLE VESSEL!
SFaccountant's avatar
Left Pinkie makes a very compelling case.
ABronyAccount's avatar
Pinkie's left, or Pinkie's left?
SFaccountant's avatar
My left.
Although I think that's reversed if you live South of the Equator.
ABronyAccount's avatar
My south or your south?
SFaccountant's avatar
Your South appears to be up, judging by your profile picture, soooo...
Left Pinkie.
ABronyAccount's avatar
My left or her left?
SFaccountant's avatar
Uh... her left.
Wait, which her? There are several hers.
And where are you, for that matter?
Where am I?

(Gets lost in the internet and is never heard from again)
UltraTheHedgetoaster's avatar
:iconwhynotbothplz: "Why not both?"
:iconpinkiepiethinkplz: "Hmmm... I never thought of it that way before. Maybe there is no singular 'real' Pinkie Pie?"

ABronyAccount's avatar
:iconpinkiepiethinkplz::iconsaysplz: "But that would mean..."

:iconmakeitstoppinkieplz::iconsaysplz: "I'M ONE OF THE TOMATOES"

:icontomatopieplz::iconsaysplz: "Tomato Pie!" *giggle*
The-Holy-Avacado-97's avatar
This is really coming along, can't wait to see it colored! (You were making a color version, right?)
False-Promise's avatar
ABronyAccount's avatar
GOOD.

I'M GLAD


GLAD, YOU HEAR???
False-Promise's avatar
.. Uh yes, I hear?
ABronyAccount's avatar
GOOD.

How about now?
ABronyAccount's avatar
How... about... now?
False-Promise's avatar
I really do not understand
ABronyAccount's avatar
And... how about now?
View all replies
ChaosDrgon's avatar
XD I see what you did there.
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In