We have many projects that encourage our awesome members to give and get comments. These projects involve workshops, features, contests, and, more importantly, systems that rely on interchange, inclusion and interaction.
It's not easy to give and get comments, but, with the many projects we have here, we hope you find something that works best for you.
If you have any questions, concerns, suggestions, or anything else, please do not hesitate to contact us!
Our amazing admins and members give comments and get comments with the following values in mind:
…to restore balance – comment for comment, positive and negative, give and take.
…to accept all – every commenter, every art, regardless of skill or artist.
…to nurture together – educate, engage, elevate.
Click the links below to reach the relevant section:
- Joining ProjectComment
- I'm new! Where do I start? What do I do?
- ProjectComment "Projects"
- ProjectComment Rules
- What is a Constructive Comment?
- What is not a Constructive Comment?
- Examples of Constructive Comments
- Submitting to the Gallery
- Submitting Literature
- Giving & Getting Comments
- Getting Comments, Without Giving
- Interacting & Supporting Commenters
- Comment Support
- Supporting ProjectComment
If you cannot find what you are looking for, please note us!
Joining ProjectComment [^]
ProjectComment membership is automatically approved. We accept every kind of artist and all kinds of art. We don’t care if you are an expert, or a complete n00b, at commenting!
To join, you do not have to be an amazing artist or commenter. We believe everyone can write a constructive comment if they are willing to try and learn.
So, what are you waiting for?
I'm new! Where do I start? What do I do? [^]
Welcome to ProjectComment! Where you start and what you do is entirely up to you! There are many places for you to start, and many things for you to do. No one way is right or wrong.
ProjectComment encourages you to ask yourself what you really want from the group. Do you want comments? Do you want to give comments? Do you want support for your comments?
These are just some of the questions that you could be asking yourself. Once you have your answer, check out our visual help guide for new members to find where you can start and what you can do.
As a group, we encourage you to join us whenever you can. We understand that commenting takes time - you may not have a lot of time, or be active. That is completely fine with us! Many of our projects allow you to come and go as you please, but some of our projects do require more commitment, such as Gallery at a Glance, Comment Tag, etc.
ProjectComment "Projects" [^]
ProjectComment’s projects can range from workshops, features, contests, actual projects and much more! Everything we have is to encourage you to give and get the comments you deserve, as well as aid you in your commenting.
Each project has its own rules, guidelines and information, as well as its own ‘Project Manager’. The Project Manager is the person to go to with any questions, suggestions or concerns about anything related to the project, as they, essentially, manage the project. If you are not comfortable talking to the Project Manager, please note the group instead.
ProjectComment Rules [^]
ProjectComment’s rules and group standards ensure the efficiency and fairness of our projects for everyone. Your understanding of our rules and group standards is very much appreciated.
Comments made on behalf of ProjectComment should be constructive. What is a Constructive Comment?
For the comment to really help an artist, a rough measurement is a comment of around 7 consecutive lines as seen on a desktop computer. 7 consecutive lines is around 200 words. If you are using a mobile or tablet device, this translates to more than 14 consecutive lines.
Please do not interpret lines as ‘sentences’ or lines that should be broken up.
7 consecutive lines means that the lines should follow on from each other - one after the other.
7 consecutive lines means that the lines should follow on from each other - one after the other.
To really help an artist, we also expect constructive comments to use What is a Constructive Comment? as a guide and basic foundation for your comment, not to be used or interpreted as the bare minimum required by ProjectComment. For further support, please review our Constructive Commenting: Guiding Questions (questions to consider when writing constructive comments) and Comment Hall of Fame (examples of constructive comments).
To distinguish between comments made on behalf of our group, and comments made on behalf of other groups, please indicate you are a member of ProjectComment in your constructive comment.
You can use one (of three) ways to indicate your membership:
- Use of Emoticons -
Please note that emoticons will not show in Critiques written on the Critique Platform.
- Use of Signature - Please edit your Settings and put
:in your Signature.
- Use of Group Links -
Please take note that Comment Tag enforces a 100-word minimum on deviation-related content. If you intend to sign up to Comment Tag, please be committed to giving a comment.
What is a Constructive Comment? [^]
A constructive comment is a comment that serves a useful purpose. For many artists, constructive comments help them improve their artwork. For others, constructive comments offer insight, depth, new perspective and more. Ultimately, constructive comments encourage critical thinking of both the artist and the commenter, and they embody our values as a group.
A constructive comment is...
- Tailored to the artist and the art.
- Precise in summarizing your interpretation of the piece regarding the concept, meaning and more.
- Well-rounded and balanced in content, including things done well and not done well, things you like and not like, positive and negative, etc.
- Targeted for artistic improvement, with suggestions of what to improve, how to improve and why the artist should improve in this specific area.
- Justified with specific examples, evidence and explanations. This is done through 'why', 'how', 'what', etc.
For example, what does this particular element create in / add to / contributes to...the piece, the subject, the concept, etc.? How and why does the element or artist do this?
Please take note that the above is to be used as a guide and basic foundation for your comment, not to be used or interpreted as the bare minimum required by ProjectComment. The above should help you expand upon your own comment. For further support, please review our Constructive Commenting: Guiding Questions (questions to consider when writing constructive comments) and Comment Hall of Fame (examples of constructive comments).
What is not a Constructive Comment? [^]
A constructive comment is not…
A line or a few lines - it is difficult to be constructive when writing so little.
An Itemized List - or any list at all.
Generic - feedback that could be applied to any artist or any art.
Useless - no insight, no depth, no improvement suggestions, no justification, etc.
Rude / Offensive / Insulting - constructive comments can be given (i.e. phrased) constructively.
Examples of Constructive Comments [^]
The different parts (or 'structure') of the comment for both 6-7 Lines and 7+ Lines are as follows:
- Brief Introduction - first impressions and feelings over the artwork.
- The well-done elements – main idea, examples and explanation of what was done well.
- The points to improve - what elements could be improved and how to do so.
- Brief Conclusion – supporting message and encouragement to the artist, thus ending the comment on a positive or hopeful note.
RED: The main idea of each point for further development later; something general to introduce your point and what you will say.
GREEN: Examples used as 'evidence' of the main idea, thus helping the artist to spot different elements or areas of improvement. No 'evidence' can cause confusion for the artist.
BLUE: Further guidance by suggesting ways to improve, specifically focusing on how. Simply stating what needs to be improved is not enough to help the artist.
PURPLE: Justification and explanation of the effect on you (the commenter/audience) by the different elements (red) and examples (green). This is important in highlighting whether the audience (you) was able to understand the artwork in terms of meaning and concept.
*Many thanks to Tuntalm for the examples.
Check out our Comment Hall of Fame, which features amazing constructive comments!
Submitting to the Gallery [^]
ProjectComment guarantees constructive comments for every piece in our Gallery, but to get constructive comments, you must first give constructive comments on pieces from our Gallery! This ensures the system keeps running, that comments are being given so that others get comments. (Submission Limit: 7/week.)
If you would like to submit Literature, we would really appreciate it if you could comment on Literature so that it is fair. Submitting Literature?
For ProjectComment to approve your submission to our Gallery, please do the following:
- Give a constructive comment on a deviation in our Gallery, preferably from the same folder you would like to submit to yourself.
- Once you have commented, please give us a link to your comment as seen here OR post on our front page OR note the group with a link to the deviation you would like to submit to the group.
- We will review your comment. If the comment is constructive, your submission will be accepted into the group and will not be moved until you get a constructive comment back.
Please note it takes 48 hours (maximum) to receive a response from ProjectComment regarding your Gallery Submissions
Our Gallery System
Folders open to our members:
Give & Get 1 Comment, 6-7 Lines
Give & Get 1 Comment, 7+ Lines
Give & Get 2 Comments, 6-7 Lines
Give & Get 2 Comments, 7+ Lines
What do our folders mean?
- Give & Get - If you submit to Give & Get 1, you will give 1 comment and get 1 comment. If you submit to Give & Get 2, you will give 2 comments and get 2 comments.
- Lines - If you submit to 6-7 Lines, you will give 6-7 Lines and get 6-7 Lines. If you submit to 7+ Lines, you will give 7+ Lines and get 7+ Lines.
- Please respect our system. For example, if you are commenting on a deviation in the 7+ Lines folders, please post a comment of 7+ Lines.
- If you have made and linked us to two constructive comments, you will, of course, get two constructive comments back.
- Comments must be constructive. What is a Constructive Comment?
Submitting Literature [^]
You may submit literature to ProjectComment, but we do have specific rules…
- If you would like to submit Literature to our Gallery, we would really appreciate it if you could comment on Literature so that it is fair.
- Our members will not be commenting on more than two standard pages of Literature. Therefore, we ask that you refrain from submitting more than two pages or, if you insist on submitting, please do not expect our commenters to comment, fully, on the entire piece.
- Our members cannot comment on any chapter after the first (e.g. Chapter 2 or 22) with understanding of happenings that occurred in previous chapters. Therefore, if you would like a comment on a piece that comes after the first chapter, it will be approached as a standalone piece.
- Our members may not know the fandom of a fanfiction piece. Therefore, please bear in mind that our members may not be able to comment on the content.
Giving & Getting Comments [^]
If you want to get comments by giving comments, that is awesome! ProjectComment tries to foster an environment of reciprocity, of fair exchange and balance, so that those that give comments get comments back of the same caliber.
How does it work to get comments by giving comments? Well, we have projects that encourage you to give comments first. Once you have commented and linked us to your comments, your piece will be commented on by other members – just like what you did for someone else.
- Our Gallery - ProjectComment’s main system. Submitting to the Gallery
- Gallery at a Glance - If you sometimes feel a little lost on your artistic journey, if you would like a fresh pair of eyes to help you pinpoint where your strengths and weaknesses are, or if you would just like to know the impression that your art leaves on other viewers, come join us for a round (or two)!
- Comment Tag - This is the only project where you get a comment first, prompting you to give a comment to the next person. Comment Tag is a fun game where every comment given means a comment received (or every comment received means a comment given).
- Weekly Commenting - We bring the commenting to you (via Notes), once a week, every week, so that you can submit unlimited deviations to our Gallery.
Please note that Give & Get Comment Projects guarantee you comments.
Getting Comments, Without Giving [^]
Commenting takes time, especially if you are posting constructive comments. Therefore, we understand if you just want to get comments without giving any (although, we would like you to pay the kindness forward by giving comments too).
- More Exposure - Not exactly a ‘Comment Project’, this project aims to bring you more exposure by featuring you on our front page and in a news article.
(Submission Limit: 1/week.)
- No Constructive Comments - We guarantee one constructive comment for deviations with no constructive comments. (Submission Limit: 1/week.)
- Points/Comment Exchange - We accept in exchange of comments. To do so, please donate here and ensure you link the deviations you would like to get comments on. Our prices:
- 100 = 2 Constructive Comments of 6-7 Lines each.
- 150 = 2 Constructive Comments of 7+ Lines each.
Please note that some Get Comment Projects do not guarantee you comments.
Interacting & Supporting Commenters [^]
Without our awesome commenters, ProjectComment wouldn't be the group it is today. It is with that belief that we have initiatives for you all to interact and support one another as commenters, but also as artists and members of the DeviantArt community.
- Nominate a Commenter + Win 100 Points! - Awarding one awesome member 100 every two weeks, with art features of other great commenters.
Comment Support [^]
You have come to the right place if you would like support for your comments and/or commenting in general! If you are open and willing to learn, we are more than willing to help and guide you through the realm of commenting.
- Note Us - Not sure whether a comment is ‘constructive’? Don’t want to offend anyone with your comment? Stumped at what to say? Note us! If you are interested in improving your commenting to help others, consider contacting us for suggestions, advice and more.
- Our Constructive Commenting: Guiding Questions should help you in writing constructive comments by providing you with guiding questions for you to answer. Our Comment Hall of Fame also provides examples of constructive comments we value in the group.
- Comment Support Group Sessions:
- #1 - Lack of Artistic Experience & Follow-Up
#1.2 - Lack of Artistic Experience (additional challenge)
- #2 - Knowing Something is Off & Follow-Up
- #3 - Constructive Praise & Follow-Up
- #4 - Structuring Comments & Follow-Up
- Finding Confidence #5.1 & #5.2 & Follow-Up
- #6 - What and How to Comment & Follow-Up
- Workshops & Guides – We have the following workshops: Guidance, Balance, Resources, Research, Tone, Praise, Connection and guides to help you with your comments, as indicated below:
- Constructively Comment in 5 Quick Steps
- How to Format your Comments
- Improvement and Critique
- A Guide to Commenting
- A Guide on (Offending) Comments
- Why Comment in the First Place
- How to Write an Artist's (or Author's) Description
- How to Receive Feedback and Critique
- Getting Comments
Supporting ProjectComment [^]
We appreciate every and any support to help artists on DeviantArt get the constructive comments they deserve. As they say, the more, the merrier!
You can support ProjectComment in many different ways:
- Post a Journal, Status Update and more about ProjectComment. Invite and encourage others to join in on the commenting fun!
- Use our Comment Emoticons in your journals, artist descriptions and anywhere else you see fit!
- If you see someone stating they want comments, mention ProjectComment to them and invite them to participate!
- and comment on our journals, create discussions, share your thoughts and opinions!
- Link to ProjectComment in your Signature!
- Donate here, where every received goes back to our members and the community in the form of contests, projects and other events.
Become an Admin
If you would like to go one step further than a commenter or member, consider becoming an admin at ProjectComment.
We are in need of volunteers to help us manage the group behind-the-scenes. Those who are interested in our open positions should send us a note with the position you are interested in and an explanation for your interest.
- Writing and Posting Commenting Workshops/Tutorials (once a month)
- Hosting Chat Events (once a month)
- Commenting Officially (once a week)
- Managing a Project (ongoing)
Please ensure that you can demonstrate activity within the group before application. We will not be accepting applications from people who do not have a history of making a difference in ProjectComment.