Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login
The Commenter System is supported through a group of "Commenters", those who have offered to give feedback so that others can directly request a constructive comment.


How To Request a Comment

Find a commenter from the list below and send them a note with subject, "Project Comment - Comment Please!", linking the deviation(s) you would like comments on. Feel free to include any questions that may help the commenter in their comments!

Each Commenter is listed under the category of art they are wiling to comment on, along with -
  • The amount of deviations, per week, that each deviant can send.
  • Their specialities, exceptions, and preferences on the art they will critique.
  • SAMPLE : (hover over each element for more information) Username 5/w [Except] [Only] [Prefers] [Specialty]
Unsure which commenter to request a comment from? Note 3wyl with your piece and we'll suggest someone for you!

Besides the restrictions each Commenter states, there are no limitations on the deviations you send them. It doesn't matter how many comments it has already received or how many groups it's a part of -  the only important thing is that it follows DeviantArt's rules and that it is your own work.

For a visual tutorial on requesting a comment, please click here!


How To Become a Commenter

Send us a note with subject, "Commenter", containing the following:
  • Categories of art you would like to comment on.
  • The amount of comments, per user, that you can make, per week.
  • Any exceptions, preferences, specializations you may have.
  • Whether you would like to receive weekly notes containing deviations that need commenting (commenting on one piece a week is compulsory).
  • A link to one constructive comment on a deviation listed in our Targeted Commenting blog.

Every little bit helps, so even if you only sign up for one sub-category and can only comment on a single deviation per week, we would really appreciate your contribution!

To show how much we are thankful of your efforts, we will be featuring those commenters that spend the most effort commenting via our Spotlight Commenters features. :la:



All Categories
affectionateTea 1/w [Except] [Prefers]
ContraSprite 1/w [Except] [Prefers] [Specialty]
deatharms2009 [Except] [Prefers]
Iduna-Haya 1/w [Except]
MelodyGlow 1/w [Except]
mocking-titanium 1/w [Specialty]
Nocturnaliss 1/w
phoenixleo 1/w [Except]
pinballwitch 1/w
Laughe 1/w [Except] [Specialty]
IncognitoArtist 2/w [Except] [Specialty]
lolitartheist 3/w [Except] [Prefers]
Sky0wl 3/w [Except] [Prefers] [Only]
Tirius99 3/w  [Except] [Specialty]
Jam2370 5/w [Except] [Prefers] [Specialty]
AzureGriffin 5/w
I-mpavidus 5/w
laurentiusmark93 5/w [Except] [Prefers]
HummingHare 5/w [Except] [Prefers] [Only]

Digital Art
Lady-Compassion 1/w [Only]
RetSamys 1/w [Except] [Prefers] [Specialty]
Mythiril 1/w [Only]
Zarashi99 1/w [Except] [Prefers]
apples-ishness 2/w
Elvarnya 2/w [Except] [Specialty]
lu--24 2/w [Except]
Miracat 2/w [Except] [Prefers]
Pianocanival 2/w [Except]
RoyceN 2/w [Except]
aslix 3/w
DTKinetic 3/w [Except] [Specialty]
LaviniaChu 3/w [Except] [Prefers] [Specialty]
MjaxMajoran 3/w [Except]
TheClassyDinoBat 3/w [Except]
Tomboy1403 3/w [Prefers] [Specialty]
Alidriver 5/w [Only]
BornToDoStuff 5/w [Except] [Prefers]
theAllex 5/w [Only] [Specialty]
drawign 5/w
LanaDelKing ∞ [Only]

Traditional Art
sciencevsart 1/w [Specialty]
Wyntry 1/w [Prefers] [Specialty]
Tudalia 1/w
Unihaks 1/w [Except]
Zarashi99 1/w [Except] [Prefers]
Elvarnya 2/w [Except] [Specialty]
lu--24 2/w [Except] [Prefers] [Specialty]
aslix 3/w
MjaxMajoran 3/w [Except]
TheClassyDinoBat 3/w [Except]
auana-art 5/w [Except]
drawign 5/w
DracoDesigns ∞ [Except]
Kaotic-Cass
LanaDelKing ∞ [Only]

Photography
deer-o 1/w [Only]
inacom 1/w [Specialty]
Zarashi99 1/w [Except] [Prefers]
LaviniaChu 3/w [Except] [Prefers]
BornToDoStuff 5/w [Except] [Prefers]
Skysofdreams 5/w  [Specialty]
StrigiFormsFear 5/w
LanaDelKing ∞ [Only] [Specialty]

Literature
Rachel-Ruth28 1/w [Prefers]
RetSamys 1/w [Only]
Mythiril 1/w [Except] [Only]
MagicalJoey 1/w [Only]
Pianocanival 2/w [Specialty]
MjaxMajoran 3/w [Except] [Specialty]
drawign 5/w
Phisisturae 5/week [Except] [Only] [Prefers]
JoshBeta1 ∞ [Only]
MabusTheDark ∞ [Except] [Only]

Manga/Anime
Kaotic-Cass 1/w
Lady-Compassion 1/w [Only]
Wyntry 1/w [Prefers] [Specialty]
phob00 1/w [Except] [Prefers]
Unihaks 1/w [Except]
Zarashi99 1/w [Except] [Prefers]
apples-ishness 2/w
blekimaru 2/w
lu--24 2/w [Except] [Prefers]
Jimnotaco 3/w [Except] [Prefers] [Specialty]
drawign 5/w
JoshBeta1 ∞ [Except] [Specialty]
Sonikkudrawings

Fan Art
Kaotic-Cass 1/w
Unihaks 1/w [Except]
apples-ishness 2/w
illeity 2/w [Specialty]
Arasteia 3/w [Except] [Prefers]
Jimnotaco 3/w [Except] [Prefers] [Specialty]
MjaxMajoran 3/w [Except]
TheClassyDinoBat 3/w [Except]
Sonikkudrawings

Cartoons & Comics
Kaotic-Cass 1/w
Unihaks 1/w [Except]
apples-ishness 2/w
illeity 2/w [Specialty]
MjaxMajoran 3/w [Except]
TheClassyDinoBat 3/w [Except]
LanaDelKing ∞ [Except]



Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
  • Can I request more than one comment on the same deviation?
    You may send a note to each commenter from whom you would like a comment. Please do not request more than five comments per deviation.
  • I have been waiting a while for my comment, what do I do?
    Commenting takes time, please be patient. We advise commenters to give their comments within a week of receiving the request, but this is not a requirement. In the meantime we encourage you to request a comment from a different user. If you have waited an excessive amount of time, please contact us.
  • I signed up as a commenter, but my name hasn't appeared on the list, what do I do?
    Please give us at least a week to update the list. Contact us if your name is still missing after a week has passed.
  • I need to update/remove my commenter list entry, how do I make these changes?
    Please contact us with the edits that need to be made (give us a week or two to update the list).
  • How long do I have to deliver a comment?
    We advise you to give your comments within a week of receiving the request.
  • I can't comment on [...], what do I do?
    Please contact the requester and let them know why you will not be able to comment on a piece. If the piece requested does not follow the specifications you have listed next to your name, you are not obligated to comment.

    If you feel that you cannot give a comment within a reasonable amount of time (but would otherwise be able to comment a piece), consider lowering the quantity of requests you accept (see above for how to request an update to the list).
Add a Comment:
 
:iconfelizias:
Felizias Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Psst, I have noticed Mr-Pugly deactivated.
Maybe we should take this name off the list...
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Done, thank you!
Reply
:iconkaotic-cass:
Kaotic-Cass Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2015  Student Traditional Artist
Can I change my status on here? I have it set as 1 a week, but I'd like to offer unlimited comments. :) I've been trying to be more active helping others on the site.
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
I will change it! Apologies that it's taken me a while. :hug:
Reply
:iconkaotic-cass:
Kaotic-Cass Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2015  Student Traditional Artist
No problem. :D And thank you!
Reply
:iconfireytika:
fireytika Featured By Owner Sep 20, 2015  Professional General Artist
Is it okay to ask comment for a sketch? I wanna know if there are mistakes on the anatomy, since i'm still practicing at pose. So i can continue coloring it without worried about the anatomy. ^^
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Sep 21, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Of course! We have no restrictions were artwork is concerned. Just be careful who you choose as they may not comment on sketches. :nod:
Reply
:icongeorgexvii:
GeorgeXVII Featured By Owner Jun 25, 2015  Professional Traditional Artist
VEry interesting ideea , who can showcase a lot of undiscovered artists :clap:
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Jul 4, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
There is that as well. :nod:
Reply
:iconlady-compassion:
Lady-Compassion Featured By Owner Jun 24, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I would take notes from fractal submissions and anime/semi-realism.
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Jul 25, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Done, thanks!
Reply
:iconteaphotography:
TeaPhotography Featured By Owner Jun 15, 2015  Professional General Artist
This is a very creative and interesting idea! Great job! :clap:
I have fav'd it personally, and requested this to a couple of groups, where all-media artists come together, which I think is best for spreading the word! :nod:
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Jun 18, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Glad you think so!

Indeed! Thank you so much for your support. I do hope it reaches more artists. :nod:
Reply
:iconteaphotography:
TeaPhotography Featured By Owner Jun 22, 2015  Professional General Artist
I requested it to dAWishingWell too since there is a wish there for spreading this information! :XD:

Yes, I would like to help this reach more artists, and I hope it will. :nod:
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Jun 25, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Thank you so much! :hug:
Reply
:iconnocturnaliss:
Nocturnaliss Featured By Owner May 31, 2015   Writer
I really like this project, how can one apply to be a commenter?
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Jun 3, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
If you note ProjectComment, that will do!

Send us a note with subject, "Commenter", containing the following:
  • Categories of art you would like to comment on.
  • The amount of comments, per user, that you can make, per week.
  • Any exceptions, preferences, specializations you may have.
  • Whether you would like to receive weekly notes containing deviations that need commenting (commenting on one piece a week is compulsory).
  • A link to one constructive comment on a deviation listed in our Targeted Commenting blog.
Reply
:iconnocturnaliss:
Nocturnaliss Featured By Owner Jun 22, 2015   Writer
I'm a bit late with it, but I sent in my note ^^ (just so you know)
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner Jun 25, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Awesome, thank you! No worries about the lateness!
Reply
:iconlolitartheist:
lolitartheist Featured By Owner May 28, 2015
thank you so much for adding me on the list of commenter ! :hug:
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 29, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Thank you for applying! :hug:
Reply
:iconlolitartheist:
lolitartheist Featured By Owner May 31, 2015
its my pleasure :tighthug:
Reply
:iconspintherella:
Spintherella Featured By Owner May 23, 2015
I like this! Just had to say it xD hehe
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 24, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
I am glad! Thank you for your support! :hug:
Reply
:iconspintherella:
Spintherella Featured By Owner May 24, 2015
No problem :D Here's a kiss for you, my love! 
Reply
:iconborntodostuff:
BornToDoStuff Featured By Owner Edited May 22, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
if you cant see their specialties and stuff try this 
docs.google.com/document/d/1Lj…
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 24, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
That is amazing! Thank you so much for doing this! :faint:

What happens when we silently make amendments to the System? :paranoid:
Reply
:iconborntodostuff:
BornToDoStuff Featured By Owner May 25, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
well you should be able to copy paste this into your own document for editing or I can give you author permissions on the current document.
Reply
:iconjimnotaco:
Jimnotaco Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Ermergerd. THANK YOU SO MUCH YOU AWESOME PERSON YOUU xD
Reply
:iconcontrasprite:
ContraSprite Featured By Owner May 21, 2015
I have a question.. If I become a commenter, is there somewhere that I supposed to report my comments to? I'm still just learning how this group works and it seems that in many events we are asked to provide links to the comments we make. If I become a commenter for this, where should I report my comments and provide a link?
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 24, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Looks like you have been answered! If you have any more questions, don't hesitate to ask. :D
Reply
:iconfelizias:
Felizias Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
In this project the artist will request a comment from you directly.
When you comment on the piece, please do add "commented on behalf of" or something similar.
You are not required to reply to their note then.
If you can not or will not comment for any reason, please do reply to their note to let them know. :)
Reply
:iconcontrasprite:
ContraSprite Featured By Owner May 22, 2015
Mmk, sounds good. :]
Reply
:iconmjaxmajoran:
MjaxMajoran Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
well, assuming you recieve notes from the people. you simply reply to the notes with your link. :)
Reply
:iconcontrasprite:
ContraSprite Featured By Owner May 21, 2015
Right, I understand that part. I'm just wondering if you're supposed to report our comments to the group like we do for other events. :]
Reply
:iconmjaxmajoran:
MjaxMajoran Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
if it's by request of an artist, you merely have to reply to the artist, adding the fact that you did it on behalf of Project comment spreads awareness like

"Commented on behalf of :iconprojectcomment:"

if it's from 3wyl, you can just reply to them! for the other stuff, like if you wish to be featured and stuff... the instructions are on the group page, hope that helps!
Reply
:iconcontrasprite:
ContraSprite Featured By Owner May 21, 2015
Perfect, thank you! :]
Reply
:iconjoshbeta1:
JoshBeta1 Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Thanks for being included at least in this list...xD
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Indeed! :highfive:
Reply
:iconjoshbeta1:
JoshBeta1 Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
OK...xD
(Although "Fetish" isn't an exception. I can check out drawings about Fetishes and Bondage but I forgot to specify it due to the fact I thought this group might not be tolerative with N.S.F.W. and B.D.S.M. topics)
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 28, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Oh right, I see. :nod:

I will remove that then!
Reply
:iconjoshbeta1:
JoshBeta1 Featured By Owner May 28, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
OK...XD
Reply
:iconaslix:
aslix Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
i am already on the list . to be a commenter. thank you :aww:
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Awesome! :la:
Reply
:iconmelodyglow:
MelodyGlow Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I think there is a problem, the hyperlinks (hover over brackets) don't work.
;)
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Hmm...They work for me, so it's quite strange. =/

I will go back to how it was and hopefully that will sort it. :nod:
Reply
:iconkarynrh:
KarynRH Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I don't understand the hovering over elements thing. It just appears as plain text to me, nothing to hover over. Hovering over usernames just shows the link URL on the bottom left of my screen. I checked in Chrome, Firefox, and IE.
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Thanks for checking. :nod:

I have changed it - hopefully it is better now? :)
Reply
:iconkarynrh:
KarynRH Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Works perfectly now. I wish I knew why it wasn't working before, though. Your code was fine!
Reply
:icon3wyl:
3wyl Featured By Owner May 28, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
That is great! :)

Yes, it is a curious thing, but it's all good. :D
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×

:icon3wyl: More from 3wyl


Featured in Collections

News and Journals by TeaPhotography

Promoting by Andorada

Articles Journals News by Riemea


More from DeviantArt



Details

Submitted on
May 21, 2015
Submitted with
Sta.sh Writer
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
3,831
Favourites
26 (who?)
Comments
62