Shop Forum More Submit  Join Login

No Constructive Comments #19

Mon Nov 19, 2018, 6:00 AM
ProjectComment has been an active group since 2009 to give you the constructive comments you deserve! What better way to do that than to give and get constructive comments on the artworks that have none in our No Constructive Comments project?

Comment on some of the pieces below today, and link us your comments for a chance to be featured in our monthly newsletter! :la:


OC REF 1: Honey by TwitchyTheNeko
BlackGoku by oronk
Street Midoriya by KinSyke
Rainbow whale by Sjoelie
Comforting The Prince by kyoyane
Butterfly by HikariTenshihime
Foxtober Day 4: Window by steffchep
The Steadfast by White-Chocoalate
Valtero and Chionella by LadyIlona1984
Heavenly tree (experiment) by Unicorn-Horse
.:Commission:. - Want something? by EisfederKatzenpfote
Pokemon #132 - Ditto - Clay Model by kerobyx
Mesick by Slauer

DeltaRune Papyrus by kyoyane
.:Always By Your Side (Digital Remake):. by Yoshifan1219
forest king in the night (sketch) by ThatRandomeTomboy
Madotsuki by 1000Visages
pink sweater meme by DeerElva
Gryphon Paladin - Royal Gryphon At Dawn by Arthas972
Witch Pumpkin by Slauer
him by kyoyane
Struggles in TLoZ: Breath of the Wild by Sitnfrizn
Gon by El-Rey-Chipinque
The Ice King And Gunther! by kerobyx
.:Picture:. - Mysty Wish by EisfederKatzenpfote
Baby Boo And Teady by AkiComics
The Illusionist by LouriusBD
.:Guarding and Watching V3:. by Yoshifan1219
Digital Canvas Artwork # 003 by hamidkashif11
Inktober Day 3 Roasted by BrendanRizzo
SHLZ Family Reunion Pt1(Enter Garus) by Sir-Duke01
Invisible Revamp by IAmDaBestofDaBest
Iron man Mask by nitinrajput90
Exploration by AkkeeArtist
Darwin Watterson - The Amazing World Of Gumball by kerobyx
Unexpected Cargo, a Home Made Audiobook on YouTube by CherokeeGal1975
Hide by cgRainden
The Star Theater by AkiComics
(OLD)  Ferdinand the dragon (Fan-made) by Blaria95


More Exposure #79

Tue Nov 13, 2018, 6:14 PM
ProjectComment is a Group that provides Guaranteed & Constructive comments for the DeviantArt community, but we aim to feature under-appreciated artwork too!

This article series will highlight works submitted to the More Exposure folder. Submit your pieces to this folder for more exposure on our front page and a news article! Submission limit is 1 deviation/week.

Before you submit, please comment on some of these pieces!
If you do, link your comment below for a chance to be featured in the monthly newsletter! :la:


Sleepy Ari by Crystal-Sushi
Legends Of The Hidden Sand Temple by kerobyx
Sky Gators in Flight by Lil-Lewlew
Hybridzoo Adopts (Open) by CoolCordova
Two Halves of a Greater Whole by Silif-is-back
Man Eats Pie by Seeeks
Pathseeker by AvengerofSquids
Koishi Komeiji by Ancient-Meme
[COM] Horse by arcane-alchymist
.:: Dead Dinosaurs Live On ::. by JVCE
A Jolly Monster by Noobynoob103
Because why not by Springtrap9Atlas
Craig Hamilton by GabrielLoboDX
ocs by Skarr45
m by spaghettae
OC - Miyu by Toriichi3
Super Pixel Bros. - 3: Rayman by EricSonic18
Gladiator by CalebPerkins
In The Hands Of Death by AkiComics
Bowsette x Peach | Do we really need Mario? by louverusee


ProjectComment has been an active comment group since 2009 to give you the constructive comments you deserve. In support of those efforts, MagerBlutooth shares with us insights, analysis, and more of their artistic and critical journey on DeviantArt.

Why do you give comments?

I comment for the same reason I draw. I have ideas that I wish to bring to life, and commenting is the medium that lets me express them most effectively.

Why do you want comments?

The reason I want comments is dependent on the work. For my more story-based works, I'm looking to have people get invested in the story, ask questions, and potentially point out inconsistencies.

For works that place more emphasis on the art, I'm interested to see what aspects people think have been done well, as well as areas that leave room for improvement. I want to gather a consensus of areas I need to focus on for making better art in the future, as well as potential techniques I can use to help me improve.

What comments have helped you with your artwork?

ToddNTheShiningSword's comment from Is This What They Call Love? by MagerBlutooth
This was a comment that went above and beyond merely addressing the image and pointing out areas of improvement. In addition to making relevant points, the commenter provided a tangible counterexample of how it might have looked when done properly. And even in that regard, this comment stands out as special because of the medium used to create the counterexample. A quick two-minute sketch would have sufficed, but this commenter made a clay sculpture, which structurally came out as a superior piece to the picture I made.

This comment helped me to see not only the issues with my art, but also how it could look if I hadn't made those mistakes. This is the shining example of an exemplary comment.

dviouslecunning's comment from Romina - Contest Entry by MagerBlutooth
This comment critically addressed a picture that I considered the best I could make at the time. I had some noteworthy anatomy and depth issues that the comment addressed. It also found some minor errors that I was able to easily correct, and addressed my recurring issue of drawing uninteresting grounds and backgrounds.

This comment offered me both immediate and long-term goals, and touched right at the heart of the key issues with the picture. After this comment, I later made the next piece featured and improved upon at least the human anatomy.

EduartBoudewijn's comment from Liliruka by MagerBlutooth
This comment addressed my issues with depth, shading, and pose, as well as offering an analysis of how the weight may be believably shifted to improve realism, even though realism wasn't my intent with this picture. Seeing the alternative perspective allows me to imagine what the picture might look like if I were attempting to draw it more realistically.

This comment touched upon relevant issues with the piece and my art in general, while also making the useful suggestion to start smaller and work up to the complicated techniques.

Istrandar's comment from Chara of the Colossus by MagerBlutooth
This comment went hard on addressing the shading and coloring issues with a piece I considered to be my best at the time. While I do think it's still one of my best pieces, I can definitely see how the colors could be more appealing, realistic, or both, and a stronger understanding of light sources would help greatly. Even though contrast was a big focus in this one, I didn't consider the contrast of all elements.

This comment placed a strong focus on one key area of improvement and described how it might be improved upon.

fluoroid's comment from Stuck in the Sewer by MagerBlutooth
This was yet another comment that touched upon relevant issues with the piece; this one addressing composition and shading. The suggestions offered underline the commenter's artistic knowledge, describing higher-level ideas like guiding the viewer's eye and creating a visual loop. The suggestion is tailored to the skill level of the artist based on the artist's assumed understanding from the work presented, and there's nothing described that I fail to understand.

This comment offers relevant suggestions for how the piece could be improved. Also, bonus points for responding with still more suggestions after I replied to it.  

What has helped you with your commenting?


Literary Criticism
Before commenting on artwork, I provided comments on stories, addressing both positive and negative aspects in much the same way. While such activity didn't improve my knowledge base on art or my ability to make artistic suggestions, it helped quite a bit in forming a commenting style. Even with a different subject matter, the underlying principle is much the same, and taking the time to do it absolutely helped me leave better comments.

Receiving Comments
In order to know how to leave a good comment, you have to know how it feels from the perspective of one receiving comments. In providing feedback, there are many aspects that feel good to the sender that mean little to the receiver. By focusing on which aspects I enjoy as both a sender and a receiver, I have been able to make more client-focused comments, as opposed to sender-focused comments. In addition, receiving criticism allows one to develop a stronger resistance to it and become less sensitive to negativity. In the past, I used to fill my comments with unnecessary filler words like "probably", "maybe", "I suppose", "in my opinion", and the like. These words lack confidence, suggesting the commenter doesn't believe strongly in what they are saying, and once fear of criticism has dissipated, these words become annoying nuisances to the reader.

MauLer
When talking about improvements made to my feedback, I would be remiss to fail to mention the YouTuber known as MauLer. MauLer is a reviewer of video games and movies who operates under a philosophy of objectivity in fiction. Providing feedback is his job, and his attention to detail combined with his knowledge base and work ethic have inspired me to apply a higher standard to both myself and others. His views have challenged my perception of what I consider to be quality material, and while it primarily relates to my appreciation of writing, it naturally extends into artwork as well. He makes a big point against pretension in writing, how people will use ostentatious language as a display of authority, potentially at the detriment of the viewer. In order to stay viewer-focused in my commenting, it's important to keep my verbiage colloquial.

Also, in the past, I refrained from bringing up certain issues I noticed in a piece, fearing they were too minor to bring up. However, to think as such is merely an assumption on my part. In reality, that information could be invaluable to the artist. Much like other commenters do to me, I wish to challenge the artists I critique to go at least one step beyond their current level, and I can attribute my affirmation of that goal to MauLer.

Comment I made in 2016 vs. Comment I made in 2018

What has surprised you about giving comments?

There hasn't been too much that surprised me about giving comments. I suppose I am surprised that I have managed to write such lengthy comments at times, but my literary criticism was much longer on average.

What has surprised you about getting comments?

My artistic knowledge base has improved greatly thanks to the little nuggets of wisdom I've picked up over the years from commenters. I could say I'm surprised to have made most of it second-nature to the point where I can immediately spot it in artwork, both mine and others. It's similar to learning to read.

I was also really surprised to get a clay sculpture as feedback for one of my pieces.

Share with us one positive and negative experience from giving comments.

The comments I left on someone's piece led to us becoming online friends and working on a collab together. As for a negative, I would say it's unfortunate whenever I leave a lengthy, detailed comment on a piece and receive no reply to indicate it was even read.

Share with us one positive and negative experience from getting comments.

It's fantastic whenever I see people pay close enough attention to notice the minor details I added to my art, especially when it's one of my story-based pieces. It was less fantastic that one time I received a comment that was blatantly plagiarizing a previous comment for the purpose of meeting the word count.

What advice would you give to other people about giving comments?

If you're an artist yourself, think carefully about the kinds of things you like reading as comments and apply them to what you write yourself. Once artists start getting a decent amount of feedback, the empty praise from simple acknowledgements like "This is cute" and "Awesome!" become like serving them grass for dinner. The best comments elicit the best replies. A simple compliment leaves little for the artist to say other than "Thanks." A thoughtful criticism or question provides a topic for the artist to respond to. If they're passionate about their work, they'll be ready to talk your ear off in reply.

But most importantly, when in doubt, comment. Because we artists always want to hear what you're thinking. Your words are not insignificant.

What advice would you give to other people about getting comments?

Comments can come in all lengths and widths. Receiving positive comments can be great, but be wary if all of it is positive. You want to see at least a little criticism in your comment section every now and then. Otherwise you can stagnate. As for the negativity, it's important to separate the constructive from the destructive. It's important to remember that both can be harsh, but only the latter is harmful. Constructive criticism offers a path toward improvement. Even if it's incredibly rude, it can be valuable information that you won't want to dismiss entirely simply because of the tone. Destructive criticism, however, makes no such attempt and only wishes to cause harm. These sorts of comments can be safely ignored. Here's some examples of the difference:

Constructive
  • "The shading here needs so much work. Focus on where the light source is coming from and make all the shadows fall accordingly. Try it with..."
  • "For crying out loud. Study some anatomy. That arm is bent so far back I'm surprised it hasn't snapped off. And that hair looks like seaweed that's been taped onto her head. Hair comes out of the head. It's not a hat!"
  • "This picture is terrible. Just look at the way the character is running. Have you ever seen a person running before? One leg goes forward and one goes back. This looks like some kind of weird dance, which doesn't fit at all with the context of the character trying to run away from the bad guy in the background. Speaking of that guy, what's with his eyes? They're practically touching his chin! Do you even anatomy!?"
Destructive
  • "I don't know why you bother drawing. You're clearly not cut out to be an artist. Just stick to posting low-res vacation photos. At least then you won't embarrass yourself."
  • "I was going to add this picture to my collection, but then I realized it was dumb fetish garbage. And it's not even that good. Good luck with your pathetic, sad life."
  • "This picture is terrible."

Thank you MagerBlutooth! :heart:

No Constructive Comments #18

Mon Nov 5, 2018, 5:08 PM
ProjectComment has been an active group since 2009 to give you the constructive comments you deserve! What better way to do that than to give and get constructive comments on the artworks that have none in our No Constructive Comments project?

Comment on some of the pieces below today, and link us your comments for a chance to be featured in our monthly newsletter! :la:


Charging by kolgarave
Huevember - Sunshine Child by mageofmind-art
Pokemon, Vulpix by Lunaris-Art
.:Always By Your Side (Digital Remake):. by Yoshifan1219
forest king in the night (sketch) by ThatRandomeTomboy
The Sun of K'or 1 4 by Naarok0fKor
Ascension Veil - Sekrai Teniba by Veryek
Lost by Kirisy
Madotsuki by 1000Visages
pink sweater meme by DeerElva
SonSon (Marvel vs Capcom 2) by Pinksillycupcake
Time Traveller by JaneVindom
Gryphon Paladin - Royal Gryphon At Dawn by Arthas972
Witch Pumpkin by Slauer
BMO - Adventure Time - Clay (tutorial) by kerobyx
Male Anarchy by HeiwaMegami
I N S T A X by scrxeams
Black by AkiComics
him by kyoyane
Struggles in TLoZ: Breath of the Wild by Sitnfrizn
Gon by El-Rey-Chipinque
The Ice King And Gunther! by kerobyx
.:Picture:. - Mysty Wish by EisfederKatzenpfote
Baby Boo And Teady by AkiComics
The Illusionist by LouriusBD
Hazakira by Veryek
.:Guarding and Watching V3:. by Yoshifan1219
Digital Canvas Artwork # 003 by hamidkashif11
Inktober Day 3 Roasted by BrendanRizzo
SHLZ Family Reunion Pt1(Enter Garus) by Sir-Duke01
Invisible Revamp by IAmDaBestofDaBest
Iron man Mask by nitinrajput90
Exploration by AkkeeArtist
Darwin Watterson - The Amazing World Of Gumball by kerobyx
Unexpected Cargo, a Home Made Audiobook on YouTube by CherokeeGal1975
Hide by cgRainden
The Star Theater by AkiComics
(OLD)  Ferdinand the dragon (Fan-made) by Blaria95
FNAF - (FNAF4 House Party Contest 1) by funstorytime127


Project Comment - November Newsletter

Wed Oct 31, 2018, 9:00 PM
Our thirty-seventh edition of reviewing things that have happened in the previous month and what we have planned for you all this month! We will be announcing the next commenter to receive our comment award, as well as showcasing the most active and constructive commenters of our projects!

Highlights

  • We would like to say a huge thank you to the mysterious benefactor who gifted Super Group status to ProjectComment last month! Super Group has allowed us to connect with you on an even deeper level. One example of that is through polls, where we have asked for your thoughts and gauged your interest in our various activities. Look out for more polls in the future, and watch this space...
  • ...For we are launching monthly contests starting today! We are excited to welcome PinkRangerPower as Contest Manager of the group. Any contest ideas, contest prizes, or anything else related to contests, don't hesitate to note PinkRangerPower. We certainly can't wait to see all of your great contest entries and participation! :la:
  • We posted a few new projects last month, including Comment Advice, for all your commenting needs, and Your Words of Thanks, if you'd like to express your appreciation! This month, we'll be kick-starting thought-provoking interviews with our lovely members, and launching a project that we think you'll really like. :eyes:
  • For those who don't know, alongside our Comment Operations team, we have our Official Commenters team, consisting of DoubleDandE, EduartBoudewijn and Gequibren. These amazing admins regularly provide constructive comments to members of the group on an official capacity. If you'd like to join the team, send us a note today.

If you have suggestions for people to be featured, workshop ideas or questions to ask to our members, send us a note!

Project Comment Award


Congratulations to VenomQuill for receiving November's Golden Words Award! Every single constructive comment that she writes blows our breath away. Not only are the comments out of this world, you'd be hard-pressed finding anything like it on DeviantArt. Frequently featured as a Great Commenter and Admin Pick's Comment of the Month, we thank VenomQuill for her dedication, enthusiasm and thoughtfulness. Her wonderful contributions encapsulate everything this group stands for, and we couldn't be more honored to have her here with us. 

Mature Content

Mature Content

How Am I Supposed to Get Back at You?!    Currently, Stanford stood flat against the wall, trying vainly to step back when there was no ability to do so. The room, stone and carved with ancient symbols, closed in around him. Before him, his twenty-eight-year-old best friend stood, blue eyes narrowed, and a golden gun with a blue light bulb muzzle in his hands. His small, circular glasses glinted in the light of the bulb and the red sheet of glass acting as a blast shield hid most of his face.
    The flickering blue light caused by the bulb sent weird lights and shadows over the carved walls, smooth floors, and the clothes and faces of the two men. Stanford, his glasses flashing in the light and causing him to narrow his eyes, let out a small wheeze. “Wh-why?”
    “Why?” echoed the blonde man, his eyes going wide before narrowing again. “Why? You’re askin’ me WHY?!” his voice raised to a bark. The gun s

A Friend's Perspective by VenomQuill Orange Halloween by VenomQuill


A huge thank you to the talented UszatyArbuz for creating this award for ProjectComment! :heart:

Admin Pick - Comment of the Month


The comment of the month goes to PinkRangerPower for her brilliant comment, one of many awesome comments she's given! PinkRangerPower offers fantastic insights to the artist's work, greatly utilizing the 'three Es': examples, explanations and evidence. The comment is holistic in its support and guidance, the compassion clearly felt.



Projects and Active & Constructive Commenters


Gallery at a Glance ~ KokoKiero

If you sometimes feel a little lost on your artistic journey, if you would like a fresh pair of eyes to help you pinpoint where your strengths and weaknesses are, or if you would just like to know the impression that your art leaves on other viewers, come join us for a round (or two)! :la:

We'd like to give a special shoutout to Group #264 for kicking butt! Thank you ScienceWithSteve, Bigmix505 and frankly-art for being very quick and making thorough comments!

Congratulations to Jorgipie for being the most active and constructive commenter!




More Exposure ~ 3wyl

This article series highlight works submitted to the More Exposure folder. Submit one piece a week to the folder if you'd like to be featured in a journal and on our front page!

Congratulations to RuinousRapture for being the most active and constructive commenter!

Nature v. Nurture - 2018 by RuinousRapture Mabs Drawlloween Club Day 5: Laboratory by RuinousRapture Mab's Drawlloween Club Day 7: Haunted Object by RuinousRapture


No Constructive Comments ~ 3wyl

We feature the artworks submitted to the No Constructive Comments folder, a collection of artwork with no constructive comments at all.

If you have a spare moment, why not give a constructive comment today on the pieces in our No Constructive Comments project?

Congratulations to Haleyzen for being the most active and constructive commenter!

Little Zoey mostly done by Haleyzen Zoey's Sunset (Probably final) by Haleyzen Hilda w bg by Haleyzen


Quick Comments ~ Riemea

Take part in our Quick Comments for all your quick commenting needs! If you would like to help someone on the fly, or ask for some quick help, hop on over and give the project a go now! :la:

Congratulations to TigRaidoXXX for being the most active and constructive commenter!

Little big stellar =) by TigRaidoXXX Szeth on Urithiru tower by TigRaidoXXX Autumn park by TigRaidoXXX


Weekly Commenting Project ~ 3wyl

If you would like to go the extra step, consider signing up for our Weekly Commenting Project. As a thank you from us for your efforts, we submit your pieces into our Gallery for constructive comments.

Congratulations to EduartBoudewijn for being the most active constructive commenter!

Commission: Hermione gets mad part 3 by EduartBoudewijn

Mature Content

Commission: Claptrap's Screw-up by EduartBoudewijn
Art Trade: Amooora meets the Mangog by EduartBoudewijn


A Tip and Final Word!


:lightbulb: Don't hesitate to reach out to ProjectComment (by noting us or otherwise) with an idea, question, concern, suggestion, or anything else! :typerhappy:

We would like to thank everyone who has given a constructive comment in the past month. It takes time, effort and more, but every constructive comment you make helps a member of DeviantArt, a fellow artist who may or may not be in a similar position to you. We hope that the artist will pass on the kindness and give a constructive comment to another member. Without your comment, we may not be able to hope at all.

Thank you to our Comment Operations for this Newsletter: KokoKiero, Riemea, PinkRangerPower

Thank you for reading. :dalove:


More Exposure #78

Tue Oct 30, 2018, 5:41 PM
ProjectComment is a Group that provides Guaranteed & Constructive comments for the DeviantArt community, but we aim to feature under-appreciated artwork too!

This article series will highlight works submitted to the More Exposure folder. Submit your pieces to this folder for more exposure on our front page and a news article! Submission limit is 1 deviation/week.

Before you submit, please comment on some of these pieces!
If you do, link your comment below for a chance to be featured in the monthly newsletter! :la:


City Night by cgRainden
Squirrel by AkiComics
Orochimaru by AHowDraws
Denis Sarazhin - Oil Painting #2 by SaraMohsen
Funtime Foxy meets Bendy by Springtrap9Atlas
Team by kolgarave
Rainy day by Kawaii-SoupBowl
Childhood Anime by Karses
Brownie Butler - FF Fanart event by fireytika
Umbrella by beefhouse
Flower Garden 2/3: Misu Pose by Redherochild
Animu Shota by 1000Visages
Mr. Game And Watch Clay Figure by kerobyx
The Original Moon + Speedpaint by AlwysbCreative
We're just spilling our guts - Neon gore by LilaTheIndigoCat
Orange lily by its-jan
Souls are overrated by Gyuufun
Justin and 'Uncle' Alric by Foxton-Stokholm

Now you shall turn into a unicorn as well by Blaria95


No Constructive Comments #17

Sun Oct 21, 2018, 5:43 PM
ProjectComment has been an active group since 2009 to give you the constructive comments you deserve! What better way to do that than to give and get constructive comments on the artworks that have none in our No Constructive Comments project?

Comment on some of the pieces below today, and link us your comments for a chance to be featured in our monthly newsletter! :la:


I'm Slog Tired(colored) by Bruce04

Diego Brando by TheCoolestCat0
Elephantom by CalebPerkins
Toddler Jim Hawkins from treasure planet by ColinKingsland
Struggles in TLoZ: Breath of the Wild by Sitnfrizn
My Heart's Fear by DeathSpreeandViolet
Gon by El-Rey-Chipinque
Goretober: Day 11 - Temone by Clinical-Depression
The Ice King And Gunther! by kerobyx
Drowning sadness by kyoyane
.:Picture:. - Mysty Wish by EisfederKatzenpfote
Baby Boo And Teady by AkiComics
The Illusionist by LouriusBD
Hazakira by Veryek
Citrus - Sisters Outside, Lovers Inside by xxRicket
.:Guarding and Watching V3:. by Yoshifan1219
Digital Canvas Artwork # 003 by hamidkashif11
Inktober Day 3 Roasted by BrendanRizzo
SHLZ Family Reunion Pt1(Enter Garus) by Sir-Duke01
Invisible Revamp by IAmDaBestofDaBest
The Moon by AkiComics
Iron man Mask by nitinrajput90
Exploration by AkkeeArtist
[SFM/FNAF] Let's play a game... by ShiningKnightmare
Darwin Watterson - The Amazing World Of Gumball by kerobyx
Unexpected Cargo, a Home Made Audiobook on YouTube by CherokeeGal1975
Hide by cgRainden
The Mysterious Elixir Courage Test by AkkeeArtist
The Star Theater by AkiComics
(OLD)  Ferdinand the dragon (Fan-made) by Blaria95
FNAF - (FNAF4 House Party Contest 1) by funstorytime127
Ender Dragon - Minecraft - Clay Figure (Tutorial) by kerobyx
HA HA HA HA HA!!!!!! by Elijah022906


Your Words of Thanks

Fri Oct 19, 2018, 5:25 PM
With the amount of time, effort and more it takes to give a constructive comment, sometimes all we want to do at ProjectComment is say...


This journal is written for the community, by the community, dedicated to show our appreciation and express our gratitude for your support. Any words of thanks for a commenter, posted as a reply to this journal, will be featured in this journal. :love:

Our aim is to make this a place for artists to write a small (or big) thank you to the commenter. Or if, during your commenting, you see an awesome comment, let us know how awesome it is here!

For those who want to be anonymous, you may fill out a quick form here and your words of thanks will be included in this journal anonymously.

And if you would like to go the extra mile, nominate a commenter... they may win 100 :points:!

So, what are you waiting for? Who would you like to thank? :heart:



Frozen-Sol: I'd like to thank everyone who's helped me improve my art skills on ProjectComment Heart But no one has helped me more with critiques than Ja-me-thy. He may not paint that much anymore, but he has shared so many helpful critiques which have all help me become the wonderful artist I am today. So a big thanks and hug from me~~ Hug Heart +fav +favlove


AgentLema: I would first like to thank 3wyl for noticing me and inviting me to the group. Secondly, xblackxbloodxcellx and Yuntoko for the commenting advice. I still have a long way to go give really good comments but you have helped me a lot. I'll keep trying to give my best feedback whenever possible.


Angel47093: I wanna thank 3wyl for inviting me to join ProjectComment. Ever since I first came to DA, I got so anxious, shy and nervous about sharing my art online because I was afraid what will people think about my art Worried. But after submitting my submissions during the Weekly Commenting Project I signed in, I gained confidence in my skills knowing that I still have the talent inside me. Reading the comments I received on my submissions helped me and I learn some new things I won't forget through this group :D (Big Grin). I'm so excited to do it again next time! Plus, I'll submit some more to the group when I had time to give more constructive comments. Thanks again 3wyl, and thank you everyone from ProjectComment for being such a big help! wink Peace Heart Love


PinkRangerPower:Thank you to the group and all of its members for their participation and kindness.

Thank you to 3wyl for giving me an opportunity to make an impact on the community. :iconbrohugplz: Heart


WindySilver:I want to thank everyone who commented on my Xanasteins artwork back over a year ago as part of Comment Giveaway, but most especially I want to thank Anvonavi for her input, which has helped me improve at drawing faces a huge lot.
I also want to thank everyone who's part of this awesome group and keeps it going! Star!


DeadBird-Hushabye: My thank goes to everyone in this group. Because you joined with the intention to help people improve their work or simply feel more self-confident with it. I want to thank you for being this bright light on this platform that I see every time I see some constructive feedback on one of my artworks. And I want to thank everyone who did so :D (Big Grin) I am thankful to be here, to be able to give and receive those amazing comments and knowing, that there are people who appreciate and listen to what you have to say.
And I want to thank you in particular, :icon3wyl: and the entire Project Comment staff for running the best group there is!
:Constructive:


BrendanRizzo: I would like to thank everybody who has commented on my work, in particular VanVeleca, who provided some very necessary constructive criticism that I would not have figured out on my own, as well as ToddNTheShiningSword and DoubleDandE, for encouraging me to continue as well as giving some pointers.


VanVeleca: I  would like to thank MelvineKadmiss, moonmute, annakaipo, and DaiseyMae. Without their tips and such, I wouldn't have tried new things and ways to draw.


Pandanias: Before I knew about this group, I felt that my art wasn't getting enough exposure for the amount of effort I put into it.  I tried to promote my art by submitting it to various groups, but that wasn't giving me the kind of exposure I wanted.  When I was first invited to the group, I didn't really know how to submit to the group, and my starting point was a bit shaky, but I've found my way from there.  Whenever I submit to this group, I know that I will more likely than not get plenty of feedback from the group, making it worth all the effort I put into my art.  So thank you 3wyl for inviting me to this group, and thank you to everyone and anyone who has ever commented and given me feedback on my works.  I really do appreciate your comments, and without some of your feedback, I can assure you my art wouldn't have been nearly as good as it is now, but even then, I still have a ways to go.  Thank you all so much.  Love ya! (no homo) Heart


TheLukrie: Id like to thank everyone who helped me out over the last month!
And I'd like to give a very warm and special thanks to Yuntoko , atomicsnarl and JubeiSpiegel for helping me greatly on my REM in a Nightdress [Re:Zero FanArt] Drawing.

I appreciated it very much, and to this day, I use the tips I got from that!


DTKinetic: As a former admin of ProjectComment, I just wanted to say thank you to all the members for their patience, cooperation and willingness to support and participate in our many events. Above all, thank you for your kindness in consistently pushing out constructive comments so we can create a place where people of all skill levels can feel welcome here and take the opportunity here to grow. Also thanks to 3wyl and the current admins for keeping this place running :nod:


kmkibble75: I'd like to thank everyone who's commented on my work, but also the group itself for providing an unexpected launching pad for some great creative friendships I've formed in my time here. Thank you!


atomicsnarl: I would like to thank the people posting and asking questions, because it helps me think about my works and how to improve them as well!  The variety of methods, topics, and styles is a great eye-opener.


xblackxbloodxcellx: I'd like to thank you, 3wyl, for constantly being here for dA community for all those years! Huggle!

I'm not able to properly express my happiness when I saw
ProjectComment and you even more active than I remembered from the past (after all these years that I haven't been active).

My final thanks goes to all the people who are part of
ProjectComment - dA wouldn't be such a nice place without such a warm community. *Free Icon/Emote* Thank You Pusheen


Anonymous: All members of ProjectComment, thank you all for being so nice and helpful in your comments!


DaisyNovo: I just want to say what an awesome project this is. I'm happy you invited me to it.
I want to thank the staff for this organization, you are awesome people.

Mrs-Elizabeth: This is totally AWESOME! I love this group!!! Rose Thank you 3wyl and everyone who makes this group the best group on DA! :squee:

VenomQuill: Oof, I love this group so much. I can honestly say, this group is what's keeping me on dA. Otherwise, I'd have left. I mean, written works aren't the norm here and I don't concentrate on non-written works too often. However, this group is amazing. Critiques or even just passing comments have helped boost my moral considerably as well as helped in my writing (or sometimes drawing). I'd also like to thank PinkPowerRanger for helping me out in a pretty cool critique on "Mother?" It was well-thought out and obviously care went into it. Above that, it was really cool to see another person on dA who puts out written works!
And, I guess I should thank 3wyl for being amazing. I mean, I remember commenting on one of the journals to decide a challenge. I was genuinely shocked to see a reply. Even though it seems insignificant, it really did mean quite a lot. So, thank you for being awesome! For helping out people and doing what you do.

Tinselfire:When I was first invited to ProjectComment, I had no idea what to expect. What I found is it has been a community in the community that I am both glad and proud being part of, perhaps one too large for "everyone to know everyone" in practice, but very much so in spirit. There are so many people I am grateful for meeting here that mentioning them all would be a list where nobody stands out, so I will limit myself to a few who I do not already see mentioned... and lastly one notable exception:

To Mythiril for setting an example with his eloquence, tenacity, his incentive and organising skills, and an artistic humility and capacity for self-critique I have only seen in very few people.

To Planetrix and craftsbyblue for their seemingly boundless ability to transform suggestions into useful ideas, and an ability to both provide and digest feedback I truly envy and seek to cultivate.

To WindySilver for her endless encouragement, and for never ceasing to remind me it is never too late nor too early learning a new trick.

And to 3wyl, not only for providing the opportunity, but for her uncanny ability to hoover up my comments when I forget to report them.
Louis Armstrong will however have to wait to next year.

Thank you.

Luna4s: I'm thankful to have found this community.
I've been getting wonderful comments on my work ever since I joined and I'm delighted being able to help out others. ^^




Donation Appreciation Feature

Wed Oct 17, 2018, 5:19 PM
ProjectComment is a group fostered by generous souls who spend their time, effort and more providing constructive comments for the DeviantArt community. While we are deeply thankful for every form of support you give to the members of this group and the group itself, we would like to give a special shoutout to those who have donated :points: for this cause via CommentOutreach. Your donation, no matter how big or small, has aided the members of this community through our Features of Great Commenters (latest here), contests and more. :dalove:

We appreciate and welcome any and all donations made to CommentOutreach. If you have a few spare :points: and would like to support our efforts, we would be very grateful.

Thank you. :heart:



ARTificialphanTOM
Blue Trane by ARTificialphanTOM Yoot by ARTificialphanTOM Yuki-onna by ARTificialphanTOM

ChaosFay
Synesthesia by ChaosFay Circle of Song by ChaosFay Subdued Storm FINISHED by ChaosFay

CozyCatcoon
[AF2018] Peace and Love by CozyCatcoon [AF2018] Tending to the Garden by CozyCatcoon [AF2018] Sweet as a Strawberry by CozyCatcoon

CrazyEngine
Bloodmoon by CrazyEngine Quick Render - Cog wheel by CrazyEngine Abandoned industry hall by CrazyEngine

crystalaii
Hero School Is Stupid.. by crystalaii October! by crystalaii Commander Shortie by crystalaii

Daphne-Brown
Delphi Babysits by Daphne-Brown FootstepsMike McDonald woke to the sound of footsteps. At first, he tried to ignore it, but it kept getting closer and louder. Finally, nervously tip-toeing out of bed, he headed to his parents’ room.
“Mom, dad. Someone’s walking around outside my room.” he said, shaking them slightly.
His dad stirred.
“Mike, what are you doing up at this hour?”
“There’s someone walking around outside my room.”
His dad got out of bed and grabbed a bat and a flashlight from the closet, “Where did you hear this guy?”
“Right outside my room.”
A quick but thorough check of the house turned up nothing.
“I think you just had a nightmare.” Mr. McDonald said, tousling his son’s hair, “Go back to bed.”
Mike nodded and rushed upstairs to his room.  
--
 
Later that night, Mr. and Mrs. McDonald awoke to the sound of their son screaming and screaming and screaming. They ran to his room and slammed the door
Happy Slender Family by Daphne-Brown

DestructionFox
the voices of the lake by DestructionFox underwater study by DestructionFox autumn elfling by DestructionFox

devillnside
Accretion VS version 1.3 by devillnside Invader Reanimated by devillnside MSI Gaming RS3-RS2 by devillnside
 
Gryphynx


LindsDraw
Day 4 by LindsDraw I made a goatasus oc by LindsDraw May I help you? by LindsDraw

LulaScarlette
Art #32 by LulaScarlette Art #29 by LulaScarlette Art #36 by LulaScarlette

PixelZagreo
Amy Rose! by PixelZagreo :thumb766618367: Commission for Cuddly's by PixelZagreo

Ralunix
Moondust by Ralunix Gerard and Tobias by Ralunix A new beginning. by Ralunix

RavensPass
Sketch - Sea Kayaking In Rough Waters by RavensPass Wolf Head Drawing by RavensPass Museum Pen Sketches by RavensPass

Sassy--Cat
Johnny Reb The most Rebellious by Sassy--Cat Lover Boy by Sassy--Cat Si-gh by Sassy--Cat

ShadowNuzlockes
Favorite Pokmon by ShadowNuzlockes The Other Shade of Gray (Revised Cover) by ShadowNuzlockes Picture Perfect by ShadowNuzlockes

SuppressedFeelings
It's High Noot! by SuppressedFeelings Alaska Mountain Range by SuppressedFeelings Persona 5 Joker Mask Gif by SuppressedFeelings

SwiftySwoo
borkbork by SwiftySwoo Doodles of my bean by SwiftySwoo Ma boi Storm by SwiftySwoo

tufta
Art style challenge meme: Quell by tufta Boy and the Town by tufta Snow Rick and the Seven Morties by tufta

WhiskeyDreamer
To My DaughterTo My Daughter,
I’ve watched you grow from a tiny peanut into an incredible young lady.  You’ve had many adventures along the way.  Some easy, some hard but all of them meaningful.
I still remember the first time you asked to use my typewriter because you wanted to make a story of your own.  I had to tell you not to pretend smoking my cigarettes before you gave your grandmother a heart attack.  I remember when you asked for a fountain pen (with orange ink because it’s your favorite color) so you could write like mommy.  
I’ve given you every tool I can scrounge up because creative writing  is something that burns in my soul and if there’s one thing I can pass on to you of mine, it will always be the desire to create, by whatever means you can.
We write.  We draw.  We paint.  We watercolor.  We embroider.  We craft.  We create.  You do these things because it’s fun.  I do them becau


WoodsterZ
Felix Argyle by WoodsterZ Dragon Loli by WoodsterZ Kale by WoodsterZ

And many thanks to CrazyPaintbrush, Sovuniya, Hetabee, HimayaRajesh, KitKatto, Ninterjonesylad, Paessh, THEtreh, thewhitetubbie, Volt-Draws
We are all Heroes in our Own Story by CrazyPaintbrush bob! by Sovuniya Sweet as Cheesecake~ by Hetabee Seaside view... by HimayaRajesh Ghost Busted by KitKatto Memories by Ninterjonesylad AngelicRamen Commission by Paessh Shy demon by THEtreh My icon by thewhitetubbie Aeromarine: Submerged 2018 entry [Animated] by Volt-Draws


More Exposure #77

Mon Oct 15, 2018, 4:32 PM
ProjectComment is a Group that provides Guaranteed & Constructive comments for the DeviantArt community, but we aim to feature under-appreciated artwork too!

This article series will highlight works submitted to the More Exposure folder. Submit your pieces to this folder for more exposure on our front page and a news article! Submission limit is 1 deviation/week.

Before you submit, please comment on some of these pieces!
If you do, link your comment below for a chance to be featured in the monthly newsletter! :la:


Connor by Tacky-tella
mission accomplished by InstaDoodle
Nice isn't it - colored by AkkeeArtist
Request: A Nice Day for Writing by funstorytime127
heart in the box by katyawentzart
Kay by KaisPotato
Pops - Regular Show! by kerobyx
A friend have arrived, more to come by Enerla
Geheimnis (insta DTA)  by CatFace2405
Cambri Loves Black bg by theflotinghead
Shadows in the dark by blazeorson
My Own Universe by UnknownPOV19
autoportrait by kyoyane
Blue ref sheet by Bunieo
Elemental Belly Dancer - Water redraw w/video by andromacke
Little Temptations II by luxwar
The Project of Destruction Page 18 by Yoshifan1219
A Wild Jellii by Nonamations
Roller Derby by Nickelnicker
Eye of the Storm by toouniqueforgaudi


As a result of our Nominate a Commenter + Win 100 Points project, we will be announcing the winners of those 100 :points: and bringing you features of our great commenters every month!

Week of 8th - 22nd September


Feature of Great Commenters!

Commander-Ferox, EduartBoudewijn, Gequibren, IamNoHere, Kornderia, Luna4s, MalyssaLipscomb, marikyuun, Seeeks, Silif-is-back, StephOBrien

The Demon Prince by Commander-Ferox
Art Trade: Amooora meets the Mangog by EduartBoudewijn
Lacrima using her water powers (Contest entry) by Gequibren

OC | Gorn Thai Exorcist AU by Kornderia
Inktober - Spell Book by Luna4s
Envelop by MalyssaLipscomb
Walking home by marikyuun
Hide And Seek by Seeeks
The Breath of Ruin by Silif-is-back
Inktober 2 - Tranquil by StephOBrien

Week of 22nd September - 6th October


Congratulations Haleyzen for winning 100 :points:!

Zoey's Sunset (Probably final) by Haleyzen Hilda w bg by Haleyzen The Bandit Leader by Haleyzen

Feature of Great Commenters!

39rin, ado-mi, Alexandritea, DeadBird-Hushabye, DoubleDandE, EshiSnu, Gequibren, MagerBlutooth, Pheenixorphan, Seeeks, StephOBrien, StickyLunatic, The-Espresso-Cat

Ritsu Namine by 39rin
diwata ng kalangitan by ado-mi
Peacekeeper by Alexandritea
Axel Kondo - Street Fighter by DeadBird-Hushabye
It Lives in the Swamp by DoubleDandE
How to Yeti by EshiSnu
Elder Scrolls - Oblivion - Khajiit Portrait by Gequibren
Diamond and Dazzle: Desire by MagerBlutooth
Not The Pumpkin! by Pheenixorphan
Hooded Figure by Seeeks
Inktober 6 - Drooling by StephOBrien
Victorian Chaotic by StickyLunatic
Mermaid's Song by The-Espresso-Cat

If you would like the chance to win 100 :points: or be featured,
nominate a commenter now!



Welcome to ProjectComment's Comment Advice!

If you would like comments on your comments, answers to commenting questions, tips to handling commenting situations, suggestions on helping others better, or anything related to comments and commenting, seek advice here from members of the group!

To take part, please reply to this journal with...
  • A specific question about comments/commenting (see examples below).
  • A link to your comment, if applicable (right click the time stamp of your comment and copy the link location).
If you would like to ask a question, please try to answer a question in return. Questions can be found in replies to this journal.

Our members and admins will do our best to offer advice within 24 hours. Answers may vary in length, depending on your questions.

Example Questions

  • How can I give a better comment? I really tried in this example [link], but I feel something is missing.
  • I want to receive suggestions for improving my artwork, but all I get is praise. What can I do?
  • I'm a beginner artist, but sometimes I see something I can help with, from an artist that's better than me. Should I say something? I don't really have much ground to stand on.

Guidelines

  • Please do not call out other commenters or artists. We want this to be a safe place to seek and offer advice. If you believe your post is of a sensitive nature, please note the group instead.
  • For quick feedback on something specific (e.g. a quick answer to a burning question) about artwork, please post in Quick Comments.

No Constructive Comments #16

Sun Oct 7, 2018, 6:08 PM
ProjectComment has been an active group since 2009 to give you the constructive comments you deserve! What better way to do that than to give and get constructive comments on the artworks that have none in our No Constructive Comments project?

Comment on some of the pieces below today, and link us your comments for a chance to be featured in our monthly newsletter! :la:


Bottle tag for Montlouis dionysos proposition 1 by WILLIFINK
Inktober Day 1: Poisonous by AlexGrowing
Lonesome by ValeriyaSegal
Sum portrait by 1000Visages
girl and owl by Kirisy
.:Guarding and Watching V3:. by Yoshifan1219
ill rename this later. by Clinical-Depression
Digital Canvas Artwork # 003 by hamidkashif11
Inktober Day 3 Roasted by BrendanRizzo
SHLZ Family Reunion Pt1(Enter Garus) by Sir-Duke01
Invisible Revamp by IAmDaBestofDaBest
The Moon by AkiComics
From Siberia with love by SadCranberry
Birthday Girl by bobby-jam
Iron man Mask by nitinrajput90
Untouchable Beauty by kyoyane
Devil Eyes by KittyPantera
Exploration by AkkeeArtist
[SFM/FNAF] Let's play a game... by ShiningKnightmare
Darwin Watterson - The Amazing World Of Gumball by kerobyx
Unexpected Cargo, a Home Made Audiobook on YouTube by CherokeeGal1975
Hide by cgRainden
The Mysterious Elixir Courage Test by AkkeeArtist
The Horror(Gore) by AkiComics
The Star Theater by AkiComics
Fear on a man's heart. by Wynet
(OLD)  Ferdinand the dragon (Fan-made) by Blaria95
FNAF - (FNAF4 House Party Contest 1) by funstorytime127
Ender Dragon - Minecraft - Clay Figure (Tutorial) by kerobyx
HA HA HA HA HA!!!!!! by Elijah022906
The Simpsons by SecretName1010
I'm so sorry bun....(GORE WARNING) by Bunieo



More Exposure #76

Wed Oct 3, 2018, 6:09 AM
ProjectComment is a Group that provides Guaranteed & Constructive comments for the DeviantArt community, but we aim to feature under-appreciated artwork too!

This article series will highlight works submitted to the More Exposure folder. Submit your pieces to this folder for more exposure on our front page and a news article! Submission limit is 1 deviation/week.

Before you submit, please comment on some of these pieces!
If you do, link your comment below for a chance to be featured in the monthly newsletter! :la:


Snoopy And WoodStock - Lazy Day by kerobyx
Veronica Davis by getbeened
self portrait by beefhouse
Nicco by Jinklo
Zero Two Dude - Darling in the Franxx by AmandaDarko
Cute trap (full body) by WoodsterZ
Dragonball Raging Budokai Chronicles: Beginnings by Sir-Duke01
SabakuSarasu No Karasuna: Art Trade by Redherochild
LIght Up--with video process! by andromacke
EPSON024 couverturebis by Shirahakun

The gateway to the Silver Bell Ball? by Blaria95

High mountain cave Barcelona warrior by BradyRain
Awake My Soul by LocalPeaches
.:Carnival Night Zone Act 1:. by Yoshifan1219
DEJ III Day 1 - Vera by Hikatsuke
Taking Steps: The skies are hers... by A-D-R
A Dragon's Treasure [Contest] by Mrs-Elizabeth



Our thirty-sixth edition of reviewing things that have happened in the previous month and what we have planned for you all this month! We will be announcing the next commenter to receive our comment award, as well as showcasing the most active and constructive commenters of our projects!

Highlights


If you have suggestions for people to be featured, workshop ideas or questions to ask to our members, send us a note!

Project Comment Award


Congratulations to DeadBird-Hushabye for receiving October's Golden Words Award! DeadBird-Hushabye consistently provides thoughtful insights to members' artworks, going into detail with explanations and suggestions for improvement. As an amazing contributor to the Weekly Commenting Project, and frequently mentioned in our Feature of Great Commenters series, we are honored to spotlight DeadBird-Hushabye for October -- congratulations!


A huge thank you to the talented UszatyArbuz for creating this award for ProjectComment! :heart:

Admin Pick - Comment of the Month


The comment of the month goes to Enerla for their awesome comments here and here. The time and effort spent in supporting the artist is immediately felt, demonstrated in the artist's response to the comment as by far the best I have ever read. Enerla thoroughly explains his viewpoint and offers thoughtful suggestions and points of consideration.


Projects and Active & Constructive Commenters


Gallery at a Glance ~ KokoKiero

If you sometimes feel a little lost on your artistic journey, if you would like a fresh pair of eyes to help you pinpoint where your strengths and weaknesses are, or if you would just like to know the impression that your art leaves on other viewers, come join us for a round (or two)! :la:

We'd like to give a special shoutout to Vixtri for being the newest comment helper! If you'd like to help Gallery at a Glance with comments, note KokoKiero now! :eager:

Congratulations to Chartzan for being the most active and constructive commenter!

In the forest.. by Chartzan Ghost Courtyard - colored by Chartzan Traveler by Chartzan


More Exposure ~ 3wyl

This article series highlight works submitted to the More Exposure folder. Submit one piece a week to the folder if you'd like to be featured in a journal and on our front page!

Congratulations to Haleyzen for being the most active and constructive commenter!

Zoey's Sunset (Probably final) by Haleyzen Hilda w bg by Haleyzen The Bandit Leader by Haleyzen


No Constructive Comments ~ 3wyl

We feature the artworks submitted to the No Constructive Comments folder, a collection of artwork with no constructive comments at all.

If you have a spare moment, why not give a constructive comment today on the pieces in our No Constructive Comments project?

Congratulations to Yuntoko for being the most active and constructive commenter!

Spell by Yuntoko Miku by Yuntoko ? by Yuntoko
 


Quick Comments ~ Riemea

Take part in our Quick Comments for all your quick commenting needs! If you would like to help someone on the fly, or ask for some quick help, hop on over and give the project a go now! :la:

Congratulations to atomicsnarl for being the most active and constructive commenter!

Spherical Balrog by atomicsnarl


Weekly Commenting Project ~ 3wyl

If you would like to go the extra step, consider signing up for our Weekly Commenting Project. As a thank you from us for your efforts, we submit your pieces into our Gallery for constructive comments.

Congratulations to CoattailsOfJustice for being the most active constructive commenter!

Gangsta by CoattailsOfJustice Soraaaaaaa by CoattailsOfJustice Fantasy Lawyers by CoattailsOfJustice


A Tip and Final Word!


:lightbulb: Don't hesitate to reach out to ProjectComment (by noting us or otherwise) with an idea, question, concern, suggestion, or anything else! :typerhappy:

We would like to thank everyone who has given a constructive comment in the past month. It takes time, effort and more, but every constructive comment you make helps a member of DeviantArt, a fellow artist who may or may not be in a similar position to you. We hope that the artist will pass on the kindness and give a constructive comment to another member. Without your comment, we may not be able to hope at all.

Thank you to our admins for this Newsletter: KokoKiero, Riemea

Thank you for reading. :dalove:

No Constructive Comments #15

Wed Sep 26, 2018, 4:53 AM
ProjectComment has been an active group since 2009 to give you the constructive comments you deserve! What better way to do that than to give and get constructive comments on the artworks that have none in our No Constructive Comments project?

Comment on some of the pieces below today, and link us your comments for a chance to be featured in our monthly newsletter! :la:

ego logistics by delphifilm
Darwin Watterson - The Amazing World Of Gumball by kerobyx
Unexpected Cargo, a Home Made Audiobook on YouTube by CherokeeGal1975
Kim Namjoon Fanart by annmarysecond
Vanessa by AkiComics
Tofy by kolgarave
Hide by cgRainden
Cop Error by kyoyane
Quick Sketch Giorno JJBA by GiraffeMeow
Dragon Girl by Karses
Neko by AkiComics
.:Picture:. - Ready to Die + SPEEDPAINT by EisfederKatzenpfote
Do you like him? by WolftenDragon
Im Ok I Guess by Bunieo
The Mysterious Elixir Courage Test by AkkeeArtist
The Horror(Gore) by AkiComics
Self Portrait XVII by luxwar
Gardens neighborhood by PriscillaSantanaArts
ado by tristallyngirl
The Star Theater by AkiComics
Color illustration by Shirahakun
Fear on a man's heart. by Wynet
The deviant group (Important READ THE DESCRIPTION) by WILLIFINK

(OLD)  Ferdinand the dragon (Fan-made) by Blaria95
FNAF - (FNAF4 House Party Contest 1) by funstorytime127
Ender Dragon - Minecraft - Clay Figure (Tutorial) by kerobyx
Design Proposal for Pomeranian Sculpture by LiHy
Sea Demon by BlackPhoebe
Glowing by BanalRas
HA HA HA HA HA!!!!!! by Elijah022906
The Simpsons by SecretName1010
Annie are you Okay? by NerdBurger65
Golden by kolgarave
I'm so sorry bun....(GORE WARNING) by Bunieo



As a result of our Nominate a Commenter + Win 100 Points project, we will be announcing the winners of those 100 :points: and bringing you features of our great commenters every month!

Week of 11th August - 25th August


Congratulations Luna4s for winning 100 :points:!

Crystal Galaxy Potion by Luna4s Ocean Potion Vial 01 by Luna4s Pink Palette Mountain Landscape by Luna4s

Feature of Great Commenters!

39rin, Aiecloud, casvalty, chronoRUS, DeadBird-Hushabye, fluoroid, Gequibren, Headzor, kmkibble75, Lilia-DeRosso, Peace-In-Violence, ro5ert, RoanNna, Shamanique, Squabblelobster, StephOBrien, ToddNTheShiningSword, UnknownPOV19, yeo-ja, Yuntoko

Kotori by 39rin
Lilith by Aiecloud
dskdhhsgghgsghh by casvalty
Nomads by chronoRUS
Worried [Gift, Collab] by DeadBird-Hushabye
The Author - B1 P11 - Dream to Reality by fluoroid
Krita Video Tutorial 6 (subt. in 7 languages) by Gequibren
Mystic Road by Headzor
Princess Eilonwy and Her Magic Bauble by kmkibble75
Touched by frost by Lilia-DeRosso
A Lesson in Madness by Peace-In-Violence
Blackstar by RoanNna
learning watercolors with a Portrait by ro5ert
aphids troubles? I will eat those aphids! [Day 13] by Shamanique
I'm Fine/Save Me by Squabblelobster
The Obvious Right Answer by StephOBrien
Triple-Decker Lineup by ToddNTheShiningSword
My Own Universe by UnknownPOV19
T h e M a n a g e r by yeo-ja
? by Yuntoko

Week of 25th August - 8th September


Congratulations Enerla for winning 100 :points:!

 Suicide Prevention Week Special by Enerla Globe On A Desk by EnerlaDrow In Russia by Enerla

Feature of Great Commenters!

39rin, bioniclop18, BlackHawk45LC, DeadBird-Hushabye, Dev807v, Doritomancer, DoubleDandE, Gequibren, IamNoHere, InstaDoodle, JINOUCHII, MagerBlutooth, MalyssaLipscomb, mchoi14, MimiChair, NeosArtista, Peace-In-Violence, SoundFX09, Squabblelobster, Yuntoko

(OC) Nijiiro Cloudy by 39rin
Lahjat Loboti by bioniclop18
Lacilla takes aim. by BlackHawk45LC
Exploring the 80s [Gift] by DeadBird-Hushabye
I had to change Vlads design again by Dev807v
Request - Rogue by Doritomancer
It Lives in the Swamp by DoubleDandE
Shots, planes and angles - Subtitle in 7 languages by Gequibren

Story Cover - 3 RED MOONS by InstaDoodle
Rem by JINOUCHII
Is This What They Call Love? by MagerBlutooth
Soccer Girl by mchoi14
Transformation by MimiChair
True power by NeosArtista
The birth  of  meglomania by Peace-In-Violence

Inktober 4 - Underwater by Squabblelobster
Spell by Yuntoko

If you would like the chance to win 100 :points: or be featured,
nominate a commenter now!



More Exposure #75

Mon Sep 17, 2018, 4:59 PM
ProjectComment is a Group that provides Guaranteed & Constructive comments for the DeviantArt community, but we aim to feature under-appreciated artwork too!

This article series will highlight works submitted to the More Exposure folder. Submit your pieces to this folder for more exposure on our front page and a news article! Submission limit is 1 deviation/week.

Before you submit, please comment on some of these pieces!
If you do, link your comment below for a chance to be featured in the monthly newsletter! :la:


Enami Katsumi Baccano Study by GiraffeMeow
OC REF : Morgane's Outfit2 by RoyDFearwood
The king and his guard by shywah
I'm In Love With Control + Speedpaint by AlwysbCreative
Patreon Tier Sneks by KingKrokoFox
Ribbon Girl Miku at Shinjuku Station by xxRicket
Dragon by CalebPerkins
Im evil, so what by AbracadabraZenWolf
Clockwork Sentinel by Cheeky-Scrub
NieR Automata - 2B (Traditional) by 7Repose
Uloe by ArtofaWhiteDragon
Hypnotic Love by DarkwingDuckfanatic
Headshot Comm {1/2} by Cocka-Mocchi
Poppy Out Of Fuzzysticks  by rainbowjoyner456
That dragon painting by andromacke

Ice Fishing by ReesieRoo
Protect from the cold (#upsidedownfacechallenge) by WILLIFINK
Black Hat Again by ZtheSOI
noodz by SolarQvartz


No Constructive Comments Feature!

Tue Sep 11, 2018, 5:30 PM
ProjectComment is a Group that provides Guaranteed & Constructive comments for the DeviantArt community.

In order to support those efforts, we encourage dedicated users to give comments too. As part of our No Constructive Comments Project, here is a feature for all those who have given comments to others! Many thanks to everyone featured below! :la:

AgentLema, Badly12, Bunieo, Bruce04, CreatorSharky, Cupric, ForsThenebriss, Foxton-Stokholm, GladrilReem, Gyuufun, indigo7232, InsoManiakk, Mahogi, Mira-Image, Proximasaur, Sir-Duke01, W-R-Draw, xxRicket, Yuntoko

DEJ (2018) - 15 by AgentLema
Piss by Badly12
What Persona Should I Use by Bunieo
AC 1 Title by Bruce04
A Fight for Tranquility by CreatorSharky
Slaying the Molten Annihilator by Cupric
Amstaff by ForsThenebriss
Justin and 'Uncle' Alric by Foxton-Stokholm
Pennywise by GladrilReem
Crazy runs in the family by Gyuufun
violin player by indigo7232
Imagination by InsoManiakk
Spring Flowers: Gladiolus by Mahogi
You Can Trust Me! by Mira-Image

Dragonball Raging Budokai Chronicles by Sir-Duke01
Lina Drawing by W-R-Draw
Ribbon Girl Miku at Shinjuku Station by xxRicket
Taking a break by Yuntoko

Thanks for reading! :love:

3wyl, on behalf of ProjectComment

No Constructive Comments #14

Sun Sep 9, 2018, 3:25 PM
ProjectComment has been an active group since 2009 to give you the constructive comments you deserve! What better way to do that than to give and get constructive comments on the artworks that have none in our No Constructive Comments project?

Comment on some of the pieces below today, and link us your comments for a chance to be featured in our monthly newsletter! :la:


Enji Night by KindaRiotCoffeeLover
Do you like him? by WolftenDragon
Im Ok I Guess by Bunieo
The Mysterious Elixir Courage Test by AkkeeArtist
Self-portrait by Napaie
The Horror(Gore) by AkiComics
.:3 Friends Remake:. by Yoshifan1219

Self Portrait XVII by luxwar
Gardens neighborhood by PriscillaSantanaArts
Just a girl by 1000Visages
ado by tristallyngirl
Cabara(Rebel) color by Sir-Duke01
The Star Theater by AkiComics
Color illustration by Shirahakun
Fear on a man's heart. by Wynet
The deviant group (Important READ THE DESCRIPTION) by WILLIFINK
Request- Betty Bunny (Read Description) by Kallista-DW
Boo And Teady by AkiComics
(OLD)  Ferdinand the dragon (Fan-made) by Blaria95
FNAF - (FNAF4 House Party Contest 1) by funstorytime127
terumi, ramlethal and bullet by Butterface27
Ender Dragon - Minecraft - Clay Figure (Tutorial) by kerobyx
Design Proposal for Pomeranian Sculpture by LiHy
Sea Demon by BlackPhoebe
Glowing by BanalRas
Zonogard by SaifRygo
HA HA HA HA HA!!!!!! by Elijah022906
The Simpsons by SecretName1010
Annie are you Okay? by NerdBurger65
Golden by kolgarave
I'm so sorry bun....(GORE WARNING) by Bunieo